/       /       /    Protection board for 3S battery packs
Support the project on Patreon


Protection board for 3S battery packs

$5.07 (5шт без учета доставки)
Go to store
For one of my projects, I bought a small protection board. Its specs are modest: 3S, up to 10 A. In fact, I needed even less, so today I'm not just reviewing the board, but also making a small modification.


I actually bought the boards for a friend, since they come in lots of five. I just bought one for myself, which worked out a little cheaper than buying them individually. I needed it to make a battery pack from three 18650 cells.



The seller's page has something resembling a set of technical specifications, translated by Google, but they're quite understandable.
Though, of course, the stated specs cover such a wide range that they could probably apply to half the boards on AliExpress :)


It's all assembled quite compactly and neatly. Two MOSFETs handle the power switching, while a bunch of discrete components control them. There's no balancer here.


The underside of the board is bare, with only the markings for connecting the batteries and the board's output.


There's not much point in measuring the overall dimensions, since the board is designed to be mounted on the end of a pack made from three 18xx0 batteries. You can get an idea of its size from this photo anyway.


The product page includes a wiring diagram, though it seemed so straightforward to me that I could do without it.


I decided to do things a little differently and used a three-cell battery holder. It's easier for me to mount, and I already had one. Besides, looking at the last photo, you can see that the wiring comes out very neat this way too.


The only thing is, knowing the “weak spots” of these holders, I soldered all the power wires directly to the terminals rather than to the contacts specifically provided for that purpose.


The board didn't need an external power supply to start up. By the way, it behaved inconsistently: after a protection cutoff, it would switch off and then turn back on after a while. But it seemed to me that this didn't always happen reliably, and a couple of times I had to “kick-start” it by connecting a charger. I didn't keep track of the circumstances when this happened.


To determine the overdischarge and overcharge protection thresholds, I connected the battery pack to an electronic load.


It turned out that one cell in the pack was charged more than the others, so the overcharge protection tripped during the first charge.


Then I discharged the pack until the protection tripped, “kick-started” the board to turn it back on, and continued discharging while monitoring the voltage of the cell with the lowest voltage.
I also took the opportunity to balance the pack a little by discharging all the cells to the same voltage. The charger’s subsequent startup was rather strange: the voltage and current didn't settle immediately. I observed this several times when starting the board manually (when I didn't want to wait for it to start automatically).


In the end, I got the following results:
Overcharge cutoff at 4.3 V
Overdischarge cutoff at a load current of 1 A: 2.53 V

Overall, I think that's fine, and safe to use.


A test with a load current of up to 10 A showed that this wasn't enough to trigger the overload protection.


Before switching the pack to a more powerful load, I measured the voltage drop across the board. It was about 240 mV in total at 10 A, giving an overall resistance of 24 mΩ, which is pretty good.


The board can handle 10 A continuously, but the transistor temperature is almost at the limit: after 10 minutes of discharge, it was about 115 degrees.


After that, I fully charged the pack. This time, the load itself stopped the charging current because I had balanced the cells a little.


But since the board has no balancer, the voltage on one of the cells was still slightly higher. Although it didn't reach the cutoff threshold, the capacity of a pack like this will be a little lower, so I recommend balancing the cells by fully charging them.
Total voltage, and the voltages of the cells in order from the bottom one in the circuit.


A test with a different load showed that the board shuts off at a current of about 13.5 A, which is roughly in line with the product page specifications.


But as I mentioned at the very beginning, I had to modify this board a little. The thing is, the device this pack is intended for doesn't need a high current—in fact, it would be harmful. More specifically, a pack with this maximum current could theoretically kill the weak cells I planned to use in it in the event of an overload. The device itself draws about 0.5 A.

In the end, I decided to simply replace the shunt. The original was 10 mΩ, with a trip current of 13.5 A. I decided to install a 40 mΩ shunt to reduce the current by a factor of four.


The calculated trip current is 13.5/4=3.37 A. A test with a load showed a slightly higher value—3.7 A—which was fine by me too. I could have used a 50–60 mΩ shunt, but I didn't have one on hand, and I didn't want to cobble one together from two resistors.


I came across a similar board that also costs very little and has the same specifications, but comes with a controller: link


That's about it. My only complaint is that the board has no balancer. Otherwise, I can definitely recommend it: it's inexpensive, works great, and its shape and contact layout make it convenient for building battery packs.

That's all from me. I hope you found this useful.
$5.07 (5шт без учета доставки)
Go to store
This page was found when searching for:
zxd-ltg-5316-3s схема, схема подключение трех аккумуляторов 3 -7 в с платой зашиты, схема компактной сборки 3s10p, плата bms 3s красная 5,9 в на выходе, схема mh99 w5a3, kirich bms 3s, bms 3s 20a схема, bms 3s схема подключения на 18650, схема подключения платы защиты 3s 18650, схема платы bms 3s 12 в, bms 3s схема, схема bms плат, 18650 3s1p плата защиты, схема подключения bms 3s к аккумуляторам 18650, плата бмс 3s схема подключения, можно ли плату 4s bms подключить на3s, подключение bms 3s, bms 3s 20a подключение схема, bms своими руками 3s схема, плата bms 3s схема, проверка параметров китайской bms 3s 20 а платы, модуль защиты 3s форум, подключение платы bms 3s, плата защиты 3s 60а подключение, 3s1p плата защиты

Questions and answers

At what voltage does the 3S protection board cut off on over-discharge?

With a 1 A load, it cut off at 2.53 V.

What cutoff current did the 3S board have after the shunt was replaced?

The author replaced the original 10 mOhm shunt with a 40 mOhm one. The cutoff current fell from 13.5 A to 3.7 A.

Does the 3S protection board have a balancer?

No, it has no balancer. The author recommends balancing the cells by fully charging them.

The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Other devices

Calculate manuallyAll calculators

Discounted products


You may be interested in


Discounted products


Support the project

All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!

Comments6

Comments are published in their original language.

  1. 12 April 2020 14:24#1
    Здравствуйте! Я несколько раз обращался к вам с вопросами и всегда получал ответы, еще раз благодарю! На этот раз я собираю электростанцию из солнечных элементов, off grid инвертора и из банок аккумуляторов от электрокара Ниссан, всего 48 вольт, 260 ампер (6 секций по 4 штук параллель в каждой секций, 1 штук литиевый аккумулятор, это 2x 3.7-4.2 вольт = 8.4 вольт, 65 Ампер). Мне нужно подобрать BMS и балансир для уравнения напряжений. Я нашел в продаже такие BMS 12S 160A Common Port - ​https://bit.ly/2y3LzFT​​​  и балансир 5A Active Equalizer Balancer - ​https://bit.ly/2RvCxIt​​​
    Можно ли использовать их для мойх литиевых аккумуляторах электрокара Ниссан  https://postimg.cc/hX4MH8WV ?
    0
    1. 14 April 2020 00:03#2
      плату защиты обычно выбирают исходя из максимального тока батареи и тока нагрузки, но на ток не больше чем может отдать батарея.
      Если не путаю, у Вас 6 сборок по два элемента последовательно в каждой сборке, т.е. реально получается не 6S, а 12S батарея. Не помню, там можно вывести средний контакт чтобы балансировать каждый аккумулятор или нет. 

      интересные платы балансиров, у меня лежит похожая, но на 1А, нашел такие как у вас, только немного дешевле вроде - ссылка
      0
      1. 14 April 2020 11:37#3
         Да, получается 12S батарея (можно вывести средний контакт из каждой 6 банок от аккумуляторов Ниссан, чтобы балансировать каждый аккумулятор). Но в каждой секций максимум 4 параллельно соединённых аккумуляторов по 65 Ампер, получается 260 Ампер. Так вот надо защиту ставить, параметры батарей такие - 48 вольт, 260 ампер, зарядный ток 30 ампер, нагрузка через преобразователь 48 вольт, 220 вольт, мощностью 5 квт. Вроде некоторые BMS китайские можно использовать?
        0
  2. 10 May 2020 21:53#4
    Здравствуйте уважаемый!
    А скажите пожалуйста, есть ли на Али, платы BMS 3S с балансиром?
    Если есть, подскажите ссылкой.

    Заранее благодарю. 
    0
    1. 16 May 2020 03:20#5
      то что они там есть, уверен, мне попадались, но вот чтобы ссылку, даже как-то сходу не наду, напомните через несколько дней, если не сложно.
      0
      1. 16 May 2020 03:29#6
        Я буду ждать, уважаемый! 
        0

Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forum

Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.

Log inRegister