EagleTac 17650 1600mAh batteries from Nkon
As usual, a reminder: to keep up with new posts on the blog, I recommend following me on Instagram, where I'll post notifications about every new topic and maybe write about something interesting now and then — link to my account
So, a friend of mine has a flashlight that runs on batteries of this unusual size. When I placed another order with Nkon, he asked me to add a couple of batteries for him too, so he could save a little on shipping. It was no trouble at all to add them, so some time later I had them in hand, and he suggested I test them.
Actually, this isn't my first review of batteries in this size. About 8 years ago, I already tested some under the rather "well-known" UltraFire brand. By the way, they're still working, on the charge I gave them about 8 years ago when I was modifying the device :)
But let's get to our test subjects.
Each battery comes individually packaged. Everything is neat and "on brand," especially considering they cost almost $5 apiece.

I couldn't find any specifications, but I did find a test of these batteries on a well-known website — link, which also listed their specs.
Official specifications:
1600mAh IC PROTECTED Rechargeable Cell (takes the place of 2-R123 cells in some applications) (4.2V hot off charger)
Measures 67.6mm in height (+/-0.1mm) and 17mm in width
IC protected for a) over-charge, b) over-discharge, c) short circuit, d) current overflow of 3A+
True protrude top design, fits all flashlights
High discharge rate 3A+
Nominal voltage: 3.7V, charge up to 4.2V, use CC/CV charger to charge
Reinforced steel plate bottom, highly efficient protective PCB design
Packaged in individual box and anti-static bag
I also found their specs at one of our online stores. In both cases, there wasn't much useful information, just general specs, so I'll choose the charge/discharge settings based on my experience with other batteries and their typical characteristics.

They're wrapped in black heat-shrink tubing, but I wouldn't call the finish neat. In my opinion, it's not much better than the UltraFires.
There's a label on the side, but it contains almost no useful information either.
The positive terminal is a button top; the negative end is recessed so far that I wondered how they'd fit in a holder. It turned out to be fine, though: the negative contact is almost as wide as the opening. You can see the protection board near the negative contact.

Dimensions and weight—nothing unusual, except that they seem a bit light to me.

It's basically the same as an 18650, just a little smaller in diameter, which is why two things seemed odd to me:
1. Weight. The volume isn't reduced nearly as much as the weight is.
2. Capacity. Again, the diameter is only 1mm smaller, yet the capacity is half that of typical high-capacity cells. Why high-capacity rather than high-current? Because a battery with a maximum discharge current of 3A, or 2C, certainly doesn't qualify as high-current.

Next, as usual, I put them through a "normalization" cycle at a discharge current of 500mA. When it finished, I was very surprised: instead of the promised 1600mAh, I got about 1100—roughly 1.5 times less.
All right, I thought, let's check them with a proper tester. Maybe something went wrong.

But before moving on to the capacity measurements, a few additional tests.
Charging time at 0.5C, or 800mA (here and below, I take 1C to mean 1600mA).
It took ages—an absolute age.... About half the time, the battery was in the CV phase.

All right, let's take the second battery and charge it at 0.5 A, or about half its actual capacity.
This one does a little better, but only a little.

The batteries have protection circuits, so let's see how they respond to an overload.
The protection tripped at 5.2–5.3 A, which is perfectly normal, so I have no complaints here.

Response to overdischarge. Ideally, I should also check how it responds to overcharging, but that's not very convenient for me to do, so I limited myself to an overdischarge test.
It cut off at 2.5 V and 320 mA, which is excellent in my book.

Now we can move on to measuring capacity.
The test was run in four modes: 0.2C, 0.5C, 1C, and 3 A.
What can I say? Grim, very grim. Not only is the capacity low, but at 3 A it's clear that this is an obvious overload for them: you can see the voltage sag at the start, followed by a rise as they warm up internally.

Temperatures at discharge rates of 1C and 3 A are generally fine, given the stated specs, of course.

The second battery performed even worse than the first. And just to be clear, the tests were run at an ambient temperature of 23°C, so everything was done as it should be.

Temperatures in the same modes.

Comparison of the test results for the first and second batteries. The second one is clearly lagging behind, so their characteristics are inconsistent as well.

Battery impedance as received, after "normalization," and after testing. One thing that stands out right away is how quickly the voltage drops after charging: charge it fully, let it sit for an hour, and it's already at 4.15 V instead of 4.20 V. The situation was a little better at first.
Also, impedance increased after testing compared with the "normalized" state, so the batteries are slowly dying.

As I was wrapping up the tests, I kept wondering what to compare them with. Then it occurred to me: why not compare them with some good 14650 batteries at a similar price? No problem—we'll compare them with the Vapcell 14650 V11 1100mah, which I tested earlier.
And here you can see that the batteries under review are clearly outperformed. In fact, they'd also lose to an even smaller sibling, the 14500-size batteries —I was just too lazy to put everything together in a graph.

So, here's the bottom line.
I don't know what cells are inside, but in my opinion, based on the evidence and test results, these batteries spent a very, very long time in storage. Though I don't know how long they'd have to sit around for that to happen, considering I have Chinese batteries that are over 8 years old and are clearly in better shape.
So it's a combination of factors: low-quality cells stored for a long time in improper conditions. I can't think of anything else. Anyway, I'll contact the store's support and ask what to do, because a battery with a remaining capacity of around 70% of its new capacity is definitely considered defective.
That's all from me. Hang in there, friends—we won't be broken, and power outages are a problem we can solve!
https://www.kirich.blog/obzory/akkumulyatory/1118-akkumulyatory-eagletac-17650-1600mah-iz-nkon, 17650 аккумулятор, nkon
Questions and answers
What capacity did the EagleTac 17650 1600mAh batteries deliver?
The first test yielded about 1100mAh, rather than the rated 1600mAh. The second battery performed even worse.
At what current and voltage does the EagleTac 17650 protection trip?
Overcurrent protection disconnected the battery at 5.2–5.3A. During over-discharge testing, it disconnected at 2.5V and 320mA.
What was the author's verdict on the EagleTac 17650 batteries?
They performed worse than the Vapcell 14650 V11 1100mah in the comparison, and the second cell lagged behind the first. The author suspected poor-quality cells and long storage, and planned to contact the shop's support team.
The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Batteries
Discounted products
You may be interested in
Discounted products
All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!
Comments2
Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.
Log inRegister




Comments are published in their original language.