/       /       /    CSB HRL-1234W-F2-FR Battery or Thoughts on Replacing Them with LiFePO4
Support the project on Patreon


CSB HRL-1234W-F2-FR Battery or Thoughts on Replacing Them with LiFePO4

$25
Go to store
I recently published two reviews of 32700-size LiFePO4 batteries. At the time, I wrote that I’d like to use them as replacements for conventional lead-acid batteries. Then, quite by chance, I got my hands on a brand-new CSB HRL-1234W battery, the kind used in UPS units, and I wanted to see “what’s what.”


The backstory is simple: a friend’s APC UPS broke down. He quite reasonably assumed the battery had died, though it later turned out that the UPS itself was probably dead. But that’s another story. Anyway, he bought a new battery and installed it, but the UPS still wouldn’t work properly, so he brought it to me. Since I had the battery on hand, I got curious about its actual capacity and how it compared with the LiFePO4 batteries I’d written about recently.

I found a datasheet online with all the necessary information, right down to the dimensions. But while lithium battery datasheets are usually clear and straightforward, lead-acid battery datasheets are confusing and convoluted.
In short, it’s a 12 V, 9 Ah battery with an internal resistance of 17 mΩ.


It looks like a classic example of the type. I think anyone who’s ever opened up a UPS has seen batteries in this form factor.


The battery was made in Vietnam. With lithium-ion batteries, everything is simple and transparent: the capacity in mAh is printed on the case or listed in the datasheet. Here, all you get is the 34W marking.


The battery weighs 2.7 kg. That reminded me of carrying a box of six batteries to replace the ones in a Delta UPS. I have to say, the total weight was quite something. By the way, you can actually judge battery quality by its weight. There are lots of batteries on the market sold for security alarm systems. They usually not only deliver less current, but are also noticeably lighter.


The date of manufacture is printed on the label in “mirror image” format: April 6, 2018. A little old, if you ask me. There’s also another marking on the case, but as far as I can tell, it indicates when the battery case was made.


The graphs are just as confusing. Even though I’ve been testing various batteries for a long time, they’re still very hard to make sense of.
For example, the one-hour discharge is listed as 0.3PW, and the 15-minute discharge as 1PW. The beginning of the datasheet says that the battery delivers 34 W over a 15-minute discharge down to 1.67 V per cell. Since the battery consists of six cells, that works out to 10.05 V.


I hadn’t originally planned to write a review or do extensive testing, so I simply topped up the battery to 14.5 V, stopping when the current dropped to 0.1 A, then discharged it at 6 A until the voltage fell to 11 V. I just wanted to check that the battery was working properly, nothing more.
The result was a capacity of 5097 mAh, or 60.16 Wh.


Charging at 1.5 A took 5244 mAh, or 68.79 Wh.


For the next tests, I first looked up the table showing the relationship between discharge current, cutoff voltage, and discharge time.
The EBC-A20 load is limited to 85 W, and the more powerful one was busy testing another device, so I stuck to discharge currents of 3.96 and 5.61 A, plus an additional high-power discharge test at 23.5 A.


First, I fully charged it at 1.8 A, which is 0.2C based on the rated 9 Ah capacity. Charging took 4 hours and 20 minutes, and the battery took in 6.182 Ah, or 82.94 Wh. We can consider the preliminary results a kind of warm-up, since these look more realistic now.


Since the difference in load current was small, and the battery itself can be discharged at up to 60 A, the results are similar: 6.0 and 5.9 Ah, or 71.7 and 70 Wh, respectively.


For the second test, I used two loads at once: the EBC-A20 plotted the discharge curve, while my DIY load actually discharged the battery.


Here, the discharge current and power delivered are closer to a real-world use case, since the battery supplied around 300 W during the test.
The result was 4.285 Ah.


It's difficult to calculate the capacity in Wh, but the graph shows that the voltage dropped to 11.8 V fairly quickly. At lower discharge currents, it reached this level closer to two-thirds of the way through the test.


The subsequent recharge also took less: 4.35 Ah or 58 Wh. I think these figures, compared with the previous results, give us a rough idea of how much energy the battery delivered.


The internal resistance was a pleasant surprise: after the tests and a full charge, it measured 12 mΩ.


So, now I want to compare what a lead-acid battery can deliver with what LiFePO4 can deliver.
The lead-acid battery's advantage is its low internal resistance, just 12 mΩ. The LiFePO4 32700 cells I tested earlier had considerably higher resistance: 8–12 mΩ for the first batch and 6 mΩ for the second. Since you need four cells, the battery pack's resistance, excluding the protection board and interconnects, will be no less than 40 mΩ in the first case and 24 mΩ in the second. You can get closer to 12 mΩ only with a 4S2P pack.

LiFePO4 has greater capacity, both in Ah and Wh. For example, cells from my first batch delivered around 5.8 Ah/17.5 Wh, while the second batch did even better: 6.5 Ah/20.25 Wh at discharge currents of 6/6.5 A, respectively.
In a 4S1P pack, that would give 70 Wh for the first batch and 81 Wh for the second. In the same test, the HRL-1234W delivered 5.9 Ah and 70 Wh. In other words, a pack of decent LiFePO4 32700 cells rated at 6500 mAh can already deliver more energy, and that's without even considering 4S2P packs.

At 23.5 A, the lead-acid battery really disappointed me. Discharged down to 10.5 V, it delivered just 4.3 Ah. Even the dismal VariCore cells delivered 5.8 Ah/16.8 Wh in this test, or 67 Wh for a 4S1P pack.


And what about the price?
The title gives a price of $25, which is about what the CSB HRL-1234W batteries reviewed here cost in stores. A 4S2P pack of Litokala cells with a protection board comes to around $30 and has 2–3 times the capacity, though of course you'll have to do some hands-on work. Is it worth it? In my opinion, yes.

And I tested a genuine battery, not the junk sold for $10, and compared it with cheap batteries from AliExpress. Sure, the picture would be less rosy if we compared it with genuine A123 LiFePO4 cells, but in my opinion, LiFePO4 still comes out ahead.

That's all from me. If you have any thoughts or comments, let me know.
$25
Go to store
This page was found when searching for:
f2fr vs f2, CSB (HR1234WF2) vs (HR1232W), lfp 1234 для ибп, vfhrbhjdrf hrl1234w f2fr, восстановление аккумуляторов hr 123wf2, hr 1234w f2 ремонт, https://www.kirich.blog/obzory/akkumulyatory/864-akkumulyatornaya-batareya-csb-hrl-1234w-f2-fr-ili-razmyshleniya-na-temu-zameny-ih-na-lifepo4, hr1234w f2 характеристики, csb hr 1234 f2 как расшифровать, аккумулятор hrl 12в 34w csb hrl1234w, аккумулятор csb hrl 1234w,f2,fr, csb hr или hrl, hr1234w различие а2, csb battery, philippines, gp1234f2,, hr 1234w f2 российский аналог, отличие клемм f2fr от f2, что такое f2 fr в акб, батарея hrl123f2, akumulators hr 1234w f2, csb hrl 1234w f2 обзор, hr 12 34 w разница hr 12 34 wf2, батарея аккумуляторная hrl, csb hr1234w f2 аналоги, 1234w f2fr 1234w f2 в чем отличие, hr 1234w f2 и hr 1234w f2fr чем отличается

Questions and answers

How much energy did the CSB HRL-1234W deliver at a 6 A discharge?

About 5.9 Ah and 70 Wh.

How did the CSB HRL-1234W perform at 23.5 A?

When discharged to 10.5 V, it delivered 4.3 Ah.

Is it worth replacing the CSB HRL-1234W with a LiFePO4 pack?

The author estimates a LiFePO4 4S2P pack costs about $30 versus about $25 for the CSB and has 2–3 times the capacity, but it must be assembled by hand.

The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Battery packs and power banks

Calculate manuallyAll calculators

Discounted products


You may be interested in


Discounted products


Support the project

All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!

Comments5

Comments are published in their original language.

  1. 24 March 2020 09:57#1
    Самое главное поработать ручками))) они у меня  из  жопы((((((

    Самое интересное китайцы еще не додумались делать такие блоки?
    Гтовое рещение на LiFePO стоило явно больше чем 30 баксов....

    Еще бы интересно было знать сколько циклов у LiFePO и свинцовых и сравнить.

    0
    1. 25 March 2020 12:18#2
      Китайцы такое уже делают, LiFePO4 батареи в формате обычных, на Нконе видел разные, цены правда не радуют :(

      по циклам думаю свинец тоже проиграет, хотя здесь сильно зависит от условия эксплуатации.
      +1
  2. 19 September 2020 13:48#3
    KIRICH, добрый день!
    А разве в даташитах на АКБ не пишется в разрядных характеристиках током и мощностью эти параметры для одной ячейки, а не для АКБ целиком? То есть этот ток/мощность не надо умножать на 6 дополнительно?
    0
    1. 19 September 2020 19:06#4
      Ток в последовательной цепи одинаков, насчет умножения мощности не совсем понял.
      А в даташите приводятся режимы ко всей батарее так как сам даташит идет именно на батарею, а не на составляющие её ячейки.
      +1
  3. 20 September 2020 01:50#5
    Про перемножение: что берём мощность или ток из разрядной характеристики АКБ и умножаем его на 6 ячеек что бы получить для всего АКБ значение номинальной отданной мощности за определенный период времени. Это имел ввиду. Но раз указано для АКБ целиком, то перемножение не актуально.
    Почему вообще такие мыли возникли: где-то указано в первой колонке разрядной характеристики напряжение конечное АКБ, а где-то на ячейку. Я по работе в постоянном контакте с АКБ от Exide (Marathon, Sonnenshine, Tudor) так там указано в разрядных характеристиках только напряжение на ячейку конечно в первом столбце разрядных характеристик, а у других АКБ от Volta например, где то и конечное напряжение акб на банку. Это и неразбериху и внесло. 
    0

Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forum

Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.

Log inRegister