Geekcreit 36V 180W Power Supply, Part Two
As always, the review will cover the inspection, schematic, tests, more tests, and conclusions.
By pure chance, I ended up with two identical power supplies from the same store. In fact, they’re the very same listing. But I was sorely mistaken when I thought this review would be simple and short...
I’ll start with why I consider this a “people’s” power supply. Many years ago, I reviewed two power supplies that went on to become very popular. I’m talking about the 12 V 6 A and 24 V 4 A models.
This power supply is marketed as roughly twice as powerful, while still being relatively inexpensive. The store periodically sells them for $9.
Specifications
Model: WX-DC2416
Protection: short-circuit protection, overcurrent protection, overvoltage protection
AC input: AC110-240V
AC frequency: 50 Hz / 60 Hz
Output voltage: DC36V
Output current: 5-6.5A
Overload current: > 6.5A
Output power: 180 W (220 W maximum)
Dimensions: 115x65x34 mm (measured)
The matching item numbers suggest they’re identical. The store’s photo shows only one of them, but reading the reviews on the product page revealed that the store ships them at random, with a 50/50 chance of getting either one.
You can see that there are noticeable differences even in the packaging.

The narrative may be a little out of order in places, since the “peculiarities” didn’t become apparent right away. Besides, I’d originally planned to review just one power supply because I thought, “Well, they’re identical...”
I’ll start with the one shown in the store’s photo.

The power supply looks a lot like the “people’s” models, both in its layout and even in the color of the circuit board.


1. The input has not only an EMI filter, but also something almost unheard of in power supplies like this: a varistor! The layout is very similar to the unit from the previous review, but that one had a Y capacitor where the varistor is here. The input electrolytic capacitor is 100 µF, which is a bit small for 180 W.
2. There’s also an NTC thermistor to limit inrush current.
3. The interwinding Y capacitor is 2.2 nF.
4. The transformer dimensions are also in line with a 24 V 8 A power supply: 33x30x14 mm. And, as with that unit, the windings are made with ordinary wire of a decent gauge, which isn’t ideal at these currents.

1. The PWM controller section is rather bare.
2. The transistor is in a fully insulated package. There’s no thermal paste, and no insulation between the heatsink and the board.
3. The output uses two MBR20200 diode assemblies connected in parallel.
4. Near the output terminal block are the output filter capacitors: 470 µF 50 V, with two before the inductor and one after it. Yes, they didn’t “forget” the output inductor here.

The underside is bare, but the whole board is covered in some kind of streaks. It looks exactly the same in the store’s photo.

The second power supply looks almost identical to the first. At a quick glance, the only difference you’d probably notice is the different terminal block.

It’s almost the same as the first one. I’ll explain the differences in more detail later, in the comparison.

But this board is very clean.

Circuit board dimensions and the spacing between the mounting holes.

The board is just a little larger than the familiar 24 V 4 A unit, and noticeably smaller than the 300 W 36 V power supply.

Now for the comparison. I think this is more interesting than just describing the unit, especially since the store may decide for you which power supply to ship.
First, the name. It turns out that’s different too.
AC-DC2416 on the left, WX-DC2416 on the right (the one shown on the store’s page). To make it even easier to tell the units apart, check the sticker on the transformer. The unit shown in the store has one, so the one they may send you is the one without it.

As I already mentioned, the unit shown in the store has a dirty board (on the right), but there are actually some minor differences in the PCB layout too. Its traces are wider, and it also has extra copper areas for mounting the heatsink.

The input sides are identical. On the output side, the differences are the terminal block and the load resistor connected in parallel with the output. On the
AC-DC2416, it is 1 kΩ, while on the WX-DC2416 it is 2.2 kΩ. And while 2.2 kΩ is perfectly reasonable for 36 V, 1 kΩ is far too low: it dissipates 1.3 W, which is a lot. The installed resistor isn't rated for that, and replacing it is very awkward because it's almost underneath the heatsink.

The transformers and their windings are identical.

But there are more significant differences further on. AC-DC2416 is on the left, WX-DC2416 on the right.
1, 2. Different PWM controllers, 1203P100 and 1200P60. Both controllers are made by the same company and belong to the same series. I also got a laugh out of the optocoupler marked “shrap” :)
3, 4. The high-voltage transistors are the same type, 20N60C3, but one has a standard package and the other an insulated one.
5, 6. The output diode assemblies are identical, but the first is mounted with a thermal pad, while the second uses mica. Neither has thermal paste.

I also found minor differences in the feedback resistor values, so it was already clear that their output voltages would differ too. I drew the schematic and numbered the components to match the WX-DC2416 board, since its component numbers were printed on the board; the AC-DC2416 differences are shown in parentheses.

The first test confirmed what I said: the WX-DC2416 has a lower output voltage and draws less power with no load (its output resistor is 2.2 kΩ).

The tests that follow are for the WX-DC2416, since that was the only unit I originally planned to test.
The unit delivered 6 A at the output without any trouble, clearly more than its rated current.

I initially measured efficiency only for this unit too, but later decided to add the AC-DC2416's efficiency to the same graph.

The standard overload test, however, came as a bit of a surprise...
The description said the overload current was over 6.5 A. Out of habit, I expected this to be the current at which the protection would trip, but the controller handles overloads differently: as the current rises, it simply lowers the output voltage. Maybe some people like this kind of protection, but personally, I don't.
I had to speed up the video threefold because the load can't increase the current quickly, and during the test I had to show a wider adjustment range than usual.

Of course, I tested both the temperature rise and thermal stability.
I started with load currents of 2.5 and 5 A, running each stage for 20 minutes. But the unit seemed to be working just fine, so I raised the load current to 6 A and let it heat up for another 15 minutes.
I also checked how the output voltage depends on temperature:
4. No load, unit almost cold
5. After almost an hour of heating, at the end of the last stage with a 6 A load
6. No load, unit hot. The difference was 120 mV, which is on the high side, though still tolerable.

Temperature after 20 minutes at 2.5 A, then another 20 minutes at 5 A and 15 minutes at 6 A.
At 5 A, some components were already quite hot to the touch, but the unit worked normally.

As last time, I also checked the temperature with a pyrometer. The transformer was the hottest component. This test was done with the unit open; once it's installed in an enclosure, you'll need to either reduce the power or add a fan.

As I mentioned, the power supply has an inductor on the output to reduce ripple, and this had a positive effect on the ripple level.
1. No load. There is low-frequency ripple at the output because the controller has a “green” mode. But the unit didn't hum or buzz, and the voltage was very stable.
2, 3, 4. Ripple at 2.5, 5 and 6 A. Even the short spikes were only 200 mV peak-to-peak; most of the ripple was noticeably lower, around 15 mV. An excellent result, though I really feel sorry for the filter capacitors located before the inductor.
5, 6. Low-frequency ripple at 2.5 and 5 A. Here, the low power rating of the input capacitor is clearly having an effect, since the 100 Hz ripple is about 100 mV.

I was going to wrap up the review on this fairly positive note and move on to the conclusions, but I couldn't stop thinking about the second unit, the AC-DC2416. I expected it to behave exactly the same. Why wouldn't it? The internals are essentially identical, apart from a few minor details.
In the end, this led to me going through almost the entire test procedure again.
I started by checking the output overcurrent protection trip point, but it turned out the power supply could deliver 9 A and showed no signs of giving up. Honestly, it was a little unnerving: the PSU was running at almost twice its rated load, and given the reliability of Chinese equipment, anything could happen.

I really wasn't happy with that, so I desoldered one of the shunt resistors, the one rated at 0.47 Ω.

Since this PSU didn't reduce its output voltage at first, I figured it must have a threshold-type overload protection, and put the difference down to the two units using different PWM controllers.
But it surprised me here too: it also started reducing the voltage, just at a slightly different trip point.

I decided to measure the ripple mostly out of curiosity, and it turned out to be well worth doing: the two units are radically different in this respect. To rule out the current limit affecting the results, I put the current-sense resistor back in place.
1. No load, roughly the same as the WX-DC2416
2, 3, 4. Under load, the ripple looks roughly the same, but is actually very different. I think you noticed the slight “tilt of the horizon.”
5, 6. Seeing this unusual behavior during the low-frequency ripple test surprised me even more, because it looks genuinely alarming. These aren't even regular ripples anymore, but some kind of random noise. Oscillograms at load currents of 2.5 and 5 A.

What's more, this also showed up as instability in the output voltage. For example, at 2.5 A it varied between 36.413 and 36.445 V, a fluctuation of 30 mV. At 5 A, things got worse: the output voltage was jumping around by as much as 70 mV.

I even wondered if the input capacitor might simply be defective. I checked it with a meter, and its capacitance was actually close to the stated value. Meanwhile, the WX-DC2416, which works fine, measured low at 88 µF instead of 100.

The AC-DC2416 also ran hotter. While I was measuring efficiency and ripple, the PSU warmed up noticeably: the transistor reached about 92–94 °C, and the output diode assemblies nearly 110 °C. Yes, I ran it at around 5–6 A for a while, but the previous unit performed noticeably better even under those conditions.
The photo shows that the transformer hadn't even had time to warm up properly, while the other components were already close to 100 °C.
It also turns out there's another version of this power supply with the same stated specifications, but a completely different appearance. One of my regular readers showed me this version.

I found this while looking for photos of a similar unit on AliExpress. I wonder how many people have tried connecting their power supplies like this, and how it all ended....

So, what can I say? As for the WX-DC2416, I think it has more going for it than against it. It works, delivers its rated power and even a little more, is assembled reasonably neatly, and has an input filter and a varistor. But, like many Chinese power supplies, its stated specifications are better than reality: its maximum continuous power is only 150 W. The output capacitors are also poorly chosen and won't last long, so if you want it to work properly, they definitely need replacing.
I like the second unit, the AC-DC2416, better in terms of appearance; it looks a bit neater. But its strange behavior—or, more specifically, the very strange output ripple—really put me off. It also has an output resistor with the wrong value, runs hot, and has the same problems with the output capacitors.
The two models also have something in common: their overload protection behaves strangely. It seems to be designed simply to limit the current in the transformer's primary winding. Yes, this approach is sometimes used, but usually in low-power units.
The WX-DC2416 does keep the power below about 230 W, but with the AC-DC2416 and its stock shunts, I easily pushed it to 320 W, which is completely unacceptable.
One thing I liked about both PSUs is that they start almost instantly: there's no noticeable delay between applying input voltage and getting an output. I think this will be critical for anyone planning to power LED strips with it.
So, both power supplies have their flaws, but if I had to choose between the two, the WX-DC2416 is clearly the better performer. At least, that’s what I concluded from the units I tested.
That’s all from me. I hope this was useful, and as always, I’m happy to answer any questions.
народный бп. 180вт. 36в ,5а обзор кирича, блок питания 24в 180 вт обзор, блок питания 36в 180вт описалние, схема импульсного блока питания на 36в 5а, блок питания 2416 36в схема, wx-dc2416 обзор, плата модуля питания 36v 7a схема электрическая, блок питания 36 вольт 7 ампер обзор, ac-dc 2416 схема, ac 36v это, 1, "dc-36-7", dc 36v 5a wx dc2416, китайский блок питания на 36 вольт 7 ампер, dc-36-7 plus схема, 36v7a-plus обзор, блок питания dc1801b00291602f04p802, Блок питания С 3684V-H-R-W-C-V-T-134 AC/DC Convector. Powertronic GmbH, dc2416 какой стабилитрон, dc 36v 18a купить, 1200p60 блок питания схема, бп из модуля ac-dc 36v 5a, схема китайского блока питания 36 вольт 6 а, импульсный бп ас-дс 220-36в5а обзоры, dc-36v-7 plus схема
Questions and answers
How do the WX-DC2416 and AC-DC2416 power supplies differ?
They use different PWM controllers, have different output resistor values, and differ in some assembly details. The WX-DC2416 performed better; the AC-DC2416 showed unusual output ripple and reached 320 W with its stock shunts.
What continuous power can the WX-DC2416 power supply handle?
The author estimates its continuous power at no more than about 150 W. It delivered 6 A, while its protection limited power to around 230 W.
What faults were found in the WX-DC2416 and AC-DC2416?
The author expects the output capacitors in both units to have a short service life, and says their overload protection behaves unusually by reducing output voltage. The AC-DC2416 also had strange output ripple and an incorrectly rated output resistor.
This model is included in the summary table: Comparison of power supplies: ripple, efficiency, and temperature rise
The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Power supplies
Discounted products
You may be interested in
Discounted products
All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!
Comments34
Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.
Log inRegister




Comments are published in their original language.