/       /    Goonk, he's just Goonk, or an intense interrogation.
Support the project on Patreon


Goonk, he's just Goonk, or an intense interrogation.

$15.04
Go to store
While working on one of my long-running projects, which I started late last year, I needed some batteries. I had the idea of adding a backup power source to the device I’m building. So I decided to order these batteries and take a look at what they were like.
We’ll be testing 18650 batteries with a claimed capacity of 2800 mAh.
Anyway, the rest is below the fold.

I needed a supply voltage of 14–15 V, or at least 10–12 V. The current draw wouldn’t be very high, so even if the batteries weren’t great, they’d still do the job.
The lot includes four batteries and a case for them.
Well, I thought, maybe one battery won’t be any good, but I can use at least three if that’s the case, so I ordered them.
Besides, I was thinking of using the case as a holder for the battery pack I planned to build.

I’ll keep this brief, but as always, I’ll start with how the package arrived.
I ordered the batteries at the very beginning of February, and they arrived in early March.
They came by Singapore Post, as usual.
To avoid annoying anyone, I’ve put the photo of the packaging under a spoiler.

The batteries arrived in a rather nice, neat little box.
Just what I needed, I thought. A box is always useful, especially as a bonus.
The plastic quality leaves something to be desired, though. I doubt it’ll survive many opening and closing cycles.

Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.

The box even has a metal loop for hanging it somewhere. I didn’t need one, but it’s a nice touch.

Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.

And here’s the first disappointment. The latch is broken. The loop would have been better off broken instead :(
I don’t know whether the post did this or it was already broken.

Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.

As I expected, there’s room inside the box for terminals or contact tabs.
In other words, you can make flat metal tabs and fit them along the sides of the batteries to create contact pads. You could use the box as a battery holder without soldering wires directly to the batteries, but I never got around to doing that.

Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.

The batteries themselves look quite well made and neatly finished.
They have no protection circuit, and are marketed as batteries for e-cigarettes in the first place.

Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.

The negative terminal is the usual design, but the positive terminal is recessed more deeply than on ordinary 18650 batteries. As far as I can tell, for example, it might not work in a flashlight.

Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.Goonk being Goonk, or an intense interrogation.


As everyone here knows, it's hard to tell from pictures whether these batteries are any good.
As before, testing was done using a professional battery analyzer, the Vencon UBA5, but this time I did things a little differently.


But I decided not to stop there :)

What did the experiment show? Not much, actually—the result was entirely predictable.
But here are a few points worth noting:
1. The voltage drops sharply as soon as discharge begins.
2. For most of the experiment, the voltage stayed between 3.5 and 3.7 V. This is the “plateau,” the flat section of the discharge/charge curve, where the battery delivers or takes in most of its energy.
3. Once the battery passes the end of the “plateau,” the voltage starts dropping sharply.
4. For most common batteries, it makes little difference whether you stop the test at 3 V or 2.8 V—the drop from 3 to 2.8 V took less than a minute and a half.
No, some batteries will deliver energy below 3 V for quite a while.
But using such batteries comes with caveats, since most equipment powered by batteries stops working properly at 3 V.
In other words, you need not only batteries that can deliver most of their energy in the 2.7–3 V range, but also equipment that can operate properly across that range.
5. The battery analyzer readings matched the results of discharging at a constant current exactly. I doubt even a difference of ±50 mAh would have made much difference.
6. Batteries differ not only in capacity, but also in how capacity depends on discharge current. The better the battery, the smaller the difference in capacity when discharging at high versus low current.
Lead-acid batteries are now seeing a trend of listing capacity at a 20-hour discharge rate, even though the 10-hour rate has always been considered nominal. That's marketing for you. :(
7. Testing the batteries revealed very large differences in their characteristics within the same (so-called) batch. That's a very bad sign.

Summary.
I won't list pros and cons today; I'll just give my overall take.
Of course, nobody expected a capacity of 2800 mAh. We all know perfectly well that the fantasy department is on the second floor it's impossible.
You could say that 2000 mAh is an excellent result for Chinese batteries, and the discharge curve at 2.8 A confirmed it (capacity came out to around 1900 mAh), which is pretty good even for name-brand batteries.
If it weren't for one catch: only two of the four batteries had that capacity.
The other pair showed a big difference in capacity when discharged at 2.8 A versus 840 mA. That's very bad.
So, it's a bit of a lottery. I don't even know what to say—I definitely can't call them good, since you could end up with four bad ones. I've run into a similar situation before with other batteries.
I once stopped using domestic electronic components because their characteristics varied so widely.
I don't recommend using these in e-cigarettes, with their high discharge currents.


I hope this information is useful and that nobody will have any doubts about the accuracy of the battery testing in my reviews. I don't write “paid,” “commissioned,” or “advertising” reviews; all my conclusions are based on tests and measurements.
Now I'll look for other batteries for my device; I can't use these. :(

If you have any ideas about which batteries you'd like to see tested, let me know. If I get the chance, I'll do it.
$15.04
Go to store

Questions and answers

What capacity did the Goonk 18650 batteries actually deliver?

At a 2.8 A discharge, they measured 1053–1887 mAh; at about 0.84 A, they measured 1815–2010 mAh. None of the four reached the claimed 2800 mAh.

Why does the capacity of the Goonk batteries change with discharge current?

The author compared discharge tests at 2.8 A and about 0.84 A and found a notable difference, especially in two batteries. His results show that capacity testing needs to account for load current.

Are Goonk 18650 batteries suitable for e-cigarettes?

The author advises against using them in e-cigarettes with high discharge currents. Their capacity is low, and the four batteries have widely varying characteristics.


This model is included in the summary table: Battery comparison: measured capacity and resistance

The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Batteries


Discounted products


You may be interested in


Discounted products


Support the project

All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!

Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forum

Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.

Log inRegister