Basen BS217A battery, 4000 mAh in the 21700 size
Inspection, tests, conclusions, and a “strange oddity.”
Lately, I really have been coming across more 21700 batteries, which have “come into fashion” alongside another size, 20700. I’ve already reviewed models from Samsung, Molicel, LG, and Liitokala, and now here’s a less well-known option from Basen. Like the last one on that list, though, it’s a rewrap.
This time they sent three batteries, packed in individual boxes and wedged inside very tightly.

There’s no datasheet for these batteries, but the product page does have a brief spec list.

They look like ordinary batteries, with the positive terminal flush with the front end.

I tried looking for equivalents from well-known manufacturers, but unfortunately my database doesn’t have many “test subjects” of this size yet, and a reverse image search didn’t turn up anything.
But I did find some kind of marking under the heat-shrink on the batteries. Luckily, it’s translucent, so maybe someone will recognize it.

The weight and dimensions are also comparable to models from other manufacturers.
Yes, I’ll be testing two batteries, even though, as you saw at the very beginning, they sent three. The third one may well go into a cycle-life test, but I don’t know when I’ll get to that, so I’ll set it aside as a “sample.”

The “conditioning” run at a discharge current of 500 mA gave almost identical capacities of 4326–4340 mAh.

All tests used a charging current of 0.5C, with charging stopped when the current dropped to 100 mA. Charging took about 2 hours and 20 minutes in this mode, which is a little on the long side.

Batteries like these are often rated for charging at 1C, but in practice that doesn’t speed things up all that much. In general, I’d recommend charging batteries at no more than 0.5C.

Tests were run at 0.2, 0.5, 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5C, where C = 4 A.
The discharge curve looks a lot like that of the Basen 26650 batteries I reviewed recently: capacity in mAh increases at higher discharge currents, and the voltage drops sharply at the end of discharge. The latter is a plus, since the battery delivers more capacity in Wh, but not all charge indicators will work correctly.
At 0.2C, the battery delivered exactly 4000 mAh—can’t argue with that :)

Heating at 12, 16, and 20 A—not bad, actually.

The second battery delivered slightly less, by about half a percent.

But it heated up more at 20 A: 87.3 degrees versus 82.7 for the first one.

According to the product page, the battery has a continuous discharge current rating of 30 A. Interestingly, the same image also says “no more than 15 seconds.” Pretty much the same oddity appeared in the earlier image with the specs.

But we’re simple people: the batteries say 30 A continuous, so let’s try running them continuously. Maybe it’s time to buy a box of sand for these tests...
I’ve described my testing method before. In short, the battery is still discharged down to about 2.5 V (in this case), but all we can see is the capacity delivered in mAh, at 30 A.

I had to run the test in two stages. Once the battery warmed up to 95 degrees, I stopped the test and let it cool to about 65 degrees before continuing.
The first stage yielded 2482 mAh, and the final result was 3826 mAh—but once again, the temperature was close to 100 degrees.

The second battery “gave up” a little later, allowing it to deliver 2726 mAh on the first pass. The final result was 3868 mAh.
The temperature at the end of the second stage was lower because I let the battery cool to 55 degrees during the break, not 65—I missed it.
When I tried to continue the test, both batteries delivered another 100 mAh each.

Internal resistance measured at 1 kHz AC: before testing, after “conditioning,” and after all the tests.
You can see that the resistance has increased noticeably. The results before the 30 A test aren't shown in the photo; they were 14.53 and 14.12 mΩ, respectively.
An internal resistance of 14 mΩ is more typical of medium-current models. High-current 21700 cells are usually around 8–10 mΩ.

And now for some “strange oddities.”
While wrapping up the last test, I happened to notice that the negative terminals on the cells were different. At first I thought I was seeing things, then I took a closer look—and no, they really are different cells.
One cell has a stamped negative terminal, another has a flat one. The third cell (which wasn't tested) also has a flat negative terminal, so it's actually a good thing that I happened to test two different cells.

On the one hand, that's not good. On the other, if the manufacturer really does select its cell suppliers, the test results should be consistent. I can't even say for sure whether these cells are from different manufacturers or just different factories belonging to the same company.
On average, the cells performed about the same. For some reason, at 3C and 5C their results diverge in opposite directions, but the difference is very small. Judging by the shape of the curves, though, I suspect these are the same cells in different “wrappers.”

Since the cells do differ, if only slightly, there will also be two comparison charts. The competitors are the genuinely high-current Molicel INR21700-P42A and Samsung INR21700-40T, both of which can handle tests above 30 A in a single run.
The chart isn't as clear as I'd like—I tried to fit everything into as little space as possible—but I think it's still readable. Results are shown at 0.2C, 12 A (10 A for the Molicel) and 20 A.
You can also see that the Basen performs as well as its competitors at 0.2C and 3C, but falls noticeably behind at 20 A.

For the second cell, the same competitors are shown as before, along with the second samples.
The Basen's results look a little better, but it still clearly falls behind at high current.

And now for the conclusions.
These cells perform a little better than the previous 26650s. For example, at 30 A the initial voltage sag here was down to 3.35–3.4 V, compared with 3.2 V for the 26650s. The same difference was observed at 20 A. But in both cases, these aren't high-current cells; they're in the “medium-current” class, despite having the capacity of high-current competitors. I think their real continuous current rating is around 15 A. Higher currents will accelerate degradation, although they can deliver 30 A for short periods.
In my view, they're suited to power tools and e-cigarettes—in essence, they're a higher-capacity (and larger) alternative to models like the LG HG2 and Samsung 30Q.
As for service life, there's no way to tell without cycle-life testing. But increased internal resistance after heavy loads and a couple of overheating incidents (they're generally not supposed to be heated above 80 degrees) isn't a good sign. Samsung and Molicel cells haven't had this problem.
That's all for now. I don't have any battery reviews planned for the near future :)
Questions and answers
What capacity did the Basen BS217A deliver?
At a 0.2C discharge, one cell delivered exactly 4000 mAh. In a conditioning run at 500 mA, the two cells measured 4326–4340 mAh.
Can the Basen BS217A be discharged continuously at 30 A?
The author estimates its practical continuous current at about 15 A. During the 30 A test, the cells heated to nearly 100 °C, so that current is unsuitable for continuous use.
How does the Basen BS217A compare with high-current Molicel and Samsung cells?
At 0.2C and 3C, the Basen performed no worse than the competitors, but it fell noticeably behind at 20 A. The author considers it a medium-current cell despite its capacity being comparable to high-current models.
This model is included in the summary table: Battery comparison: measured capacity and resistance
The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Batteries
Discounted products
You may be interested in
Discounted products
All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!
Comments2
Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.
Log inRegister



Comments are published in their original language.