/       /       /    Vapcell batteries, part seven: protected 18650 cells rated for discharge currents up to 15 A
Support the project on Patreon


Vapcell batteries, part seven: protected 18650 cells rated for discharge currents up to 15 A

$12.99-$13.99
Go to store
Sometimes you need batteries with a built-in protection circuit, and the selection of models is considerably smaller. It gets even more limited when you’re looking for models with protection rated for high current. Today I’m reviewing three models, but testing revealed that sometimes things can be so good that they turn out to be "bad." Still, you can find out all about it in the review.


Vapcell sells batteries with protection circuits, and even has a separate category for them. I ordered all three types for this review.
The key difference from the ones I tested before, including models with a built-in charger, is their maximum continuous current of 15 A. Protected cells are usually rated for 5–6 A, sometimes 10 A, but this is my first time testing a 15 A model.


Contents:
Vapcell N1835A 18650 3500 mAh 10 A
Vapcell N1830A 18650 3000 mAh 15 A
Vapcell P1830A 18650 3000 mAh 15 A
Conclusions

Vapcell N1835A 18650 3500 mAh 10 A

I’ll start with the high-capacity model, the N1835A. According to the information on Vapcell’s website, it was released on August 21, 2020. It isn’t available in their AliExpress store yet, so here’s a link to the Vapcell website.

As usual, I ordered two cells, packed in the manufacturer’s box.


The specifications for this model, as well as the next two, are provided only as an image.


In addition to the outer box, the batteries are individually wrapped in bags. As usual, they have a label with basic specifications: capacity, maximum continuous current, and an indication that they have protection.
The protection circuit is installed at the negative terminal, which is completely flat. The positive terminal is a button top and protrudes quite a bit beyond the casing.


The batteries are 71 mm long, so keep that in mind when choosing them: they may not fit everywhere. That’s a characteristic of protected models.


The first cycle in a universal charger from the same manufacturer measured capacities of 3438 and 3475 mAh, slightly below the 3500 mAh printed on the casing.


Two charging modes are supported, at 1.5 and 3 A. The lower setting is even below the usual 0.5C, but that’s perfectly reasonable for a high-capacity battery.
Charging in this mode takes 2 hours and 46 minutes.


A 3 A charging current is clearly too high for this model. The graph shows that it entered the CV phase relatively quickly; total charging time was 1 hour and 50 minutes.


The manufacturer’s website showed test graphs at currents of 2, 5, 10, and 15 A, but 15 A is clearly an overload for high-capacity batteries of this size. I also noticed that they now test at low currents using an EBC-A05+ tester, which is a very good thing. For some reason, I suspect that my repeated comments about how inaccurate the EBC-A40L is when measuring low load currents may have played a part.


The tests were run at more familiar discharge rates: 0.2, 0.5, 1, and 2C, as well as 10 A. The charging current was 1.5 A, charging stopped when the current dropped to 100 mA, and discharge stopped when the voltage fell to 2.5 V.
At the standard test rate of 0.2C, the measured capacity was 3426 mAh, or 12.45 Wh. The manufacturer specifies a minimum of 3400 mAh at this rate.


Temperatures at discharge currents of 3.5, 7, and 10 A. The temperature was perhaps a bit high only at 10 A, but that was more or less expected from a high-capacity battery.


Strangely, the second sample came in a little below 3400 mAh. After the “conditioning” cycle, I expected more from it. And this isn't a measurement issue, since it delivered less than the first one in every test mode.


Temperatures were the same as for the first one.


Now we can test the protection circuit. I checked two parameters: the undervoltage protection threshold and the current at which the overcurrent protection trips. To get ahead of myself, the protection on this battery and the others does not reset automatically after tripping.


I also measured the remaining charge after the 10 A test, once the battery had cooled to room temperature.
The protection tripped when the voltage dropped to 2.42 V. The higher the load current, the lower the voltage at the terminals when the protection trips, but in reality it always trips at the same voltage across the cell terminals.
The remaining charge after the test at 10 A was 155 mAh, or 0.436 Wh.


The listing specified an overcurrent protection trip current of 15–18 A. My EBC-A10H is limited to 10 A, and higher-current electronic loads can't run tests with a stepped increase in current, so I had to use my old homemade load in load-capacity test mode.

And this gave me a bit of a shock: the protection tripped at around 21 A! This is one of those rare cases where too much of a good thing is a bad thing. Lower voltage drop, less heating, and better handling of pulsed currents are all great, but because this is a high-capacity cell, currents around the specified 15–18 A could kill it quickly.
The GIF also shows battery number 2. When I tested the first one, I couldn't resist stopping the test at around 20.3–20.5 A, figuring the protection simply wasn't working. For the second one, I set the upper limit to 22 A and ran the test again.


The batteries' internal resistance was measured together with the protection circuit, which of course isn't quite accurate—or, to be precise, not accurate at all—but it still gives us a rough idea. Most likely, they use the same cells as the Vapcell F35, which I've already tested.
The measurements taken on arrival, after “conditioning,” and after all the tests look pretty good to me for a protected high-capacity battery.





Vapcell N1830A 18650 3000 mAh 15 A

This model was also added to the Vapcell catalog in August 2020, but it's already available on AliExpress — link. It costs $12.99 for one or $18.99 for a pair, with other quantity options available. As far as I understand, the price includes the branded case, but I received the batteries in a plain little box.
By the way, I should suggest that they offer the batteries without the case too. I think that would bring the final price down a bit.
These batteries are also listed on the Vapcell website — link.


These are medium-current cells with a capacity of 3000 mAh and a maximum continuous discharge current of 15 A.


They look very similar to the previous ones. The only obvious difference is the color, along with the stated specifications, of course. They have the same button-style positive terminal and smooth negative terminal. The protection circuit is also on the negative terminal, as indicated on the battery itself and by the model name (the N at the beginning).


The battery is just over 70 mm long and 18.5 mm in diameter.


The conditioning run showed a capacity slightly above the stated 3000 mAh.


Two charging modes are specified: standard charging at 1.5 A (0.5C) and fast charging at 4 A. In the usual mode, charging takes 1 hour 16 minutes, which is pretty good, especially considering that the battery has a protection board.


The battery also performed well when charged at 4 A, though the CV phase was of course longer. I’d recommend charging these at no more than 2.5–3 A as a good compromise between charging time and wear.


The manufacturer’s website has a test graph showing tests at 2, 5, 10, 15, and even 17 and 20 A!


I tested it at currents I’m more used to: 0.2, 0.5, 1, and 2C, as well as 10 and 15 A, where C = 3 A.
The battery easily delivered the rated 3000 mAh, and even a little more, which is nice.


Temperatures at 6, 10, and 15 A were quite reasonable overall, and downright excellent at 10 A.


The second sample produced almost exactly the same results—the consistency is excellent.


The temperature results were similar, too.


These batteries are specified to cut off at currents above 17–20 A, with a minimum voltage of 2.5 V.


The low-voltage protection kicked in at 2.4 V, which is perfectly normal.
I also tested the remaining capacity along the way. This was done after discharging at 15 A, letting the battery cool, and then discharging it again at 0.2C. It delivered another 183 mAh.


Having learned from my experience with the previous batteries, I set the upper limit to 30 A. But this one surprised me a second time: its overload protection trips at almost the same threshold as the N3500A, around 22 A. The battery can briefly handle 25 A for 1–2 seconds before the protection trips. As before, the protection latches, and to reset it you need to connect the battery to a charger.


Even with the protection board, the resistance is about 22 mΩ. As usual, these are the results before testing, after conditioning, and after all the checks.





Vapcell P1830A 18650 3000mah 15A

These are probably Vapcell’s newest cells. They were added on September 9, 2020, but are already available in the AliExpress store — link, priced at $13.99 each or $20.99 for a pair. Larger quantities get an additional discount, and the price is said to include the branded case.
These batteries are also listed on the Vapcell website — link.


Their stated specifications are almost identical to the previous model: the same capacity, maximum discharge current, and so on. There is one detail, though: the protection board is on the positive terminal, as indicated by the P in the model number. Honestly, I don’t see any difference for my own use, other than the fact that these cost a little more than the N1830A.


There are some external differences, though. To start with, the color scheme is completely different, and there’s a hole in the positive terminal and a stamped pattern on the negative terminal.


It’s 1 mm shorter than the N1830A, which so far seems to be the only significant difference.


The “conditioning” run also showed no significant differences. The capacity is slightly higher, but still within the measurement error.


There are also two charging modes, 1.5 A and 4 A. Since the cells used appear to be identical to those in the previous model, charging takes the same amount of time.



The test conditions and results are very similar to the N1830A: the same 2, 5, 10, 15, 17, and 20 A. But this battery “gave up” sooner. The 20 A test stopped almost right at the beginning, and it didn’t even complete the 17 A test, unlike the N1830A.


I tested it at the same currents as before: 0.2, 0.5, 1, and 2C, as well as 10 and 15 A. The results are practically identical to the N1830A, well within the tester’s measurement error.


The temperature measurements, however, differ much more significantly. At 15 A, the battery heated up to over 100 degrees, while the N1830A didn’t even reach 90. In fact, the thermal camera recorded the temperature near the positive terminal as the maximum, not the temperature of the cell itself. The battery reached 88–89 degrees, just like the N1830A. The thing is, when the protection board is at the bottom, most of the heat is conducted away through the holder contacts. That doesn't happen with the positive contact, so this area gets hotter.
I think this explains the poorer results in the 17 and 20 A tests: the protection board heated up faster and cut off the battery sooner.
Temperatures at 6, 10, and 15 A.


The second sample produced identical results to the first. I'm really pleased with this consistency; it usually indicates that genuine cells are used.


The same goes for the temperatures.


Judging by the specifications, the same protection board is used.


The voltage cutoff is at 2.45 V with a current of 600 mA.
After the battery had cooled down following a 15 A discharge, the remaining charge was 171 mAh, or 0.475 Wh.


My theory that the protection board heats up more and therefore has a lower cutoff current is also supported by the load test, which showed a cutoff at 20.65 A—1 A lower than the N1830A.


Unexpectedly, though, the resistance is about 1.5–2 mΩ lower than the N1830A, a difference of around 10% overall.
Results at the very beginning, after “conditioning,” and at the end.


Naturally, I made a comparison graph showing the N1830A in blue and the P1830A in red. I can say that there is a definite, if small, difference, especially at 15 A. The lower resistance of the protection board and its circuitry makes a difference.
Comparison at 0.2C, 6, 10, and 15 A.

By the way, about the protection board. If we assume that the N1830A and P1830A use a VTC6-type cell inside—which seems very likely—with a resistance of 12.5 mΩ, then the protection board has a resistance of about 10 mΩ. But based on the N1835A's protection trip current, the cells' resistance without the board would be 38−10=28 mΩ. This suggests they may use LG INR18650-MJ1 cells, which are also rated for 10 A, have a similar discharge curve and capacity, and a resistance of 27–28 mΩ.




Conclusions
As in my other reviews, I'll first give my thoughts on each cell individually, then offer an overall assessment.
Vapcell N1835A 18650 3500mah 10A - According to the “investigation” above, these most likely use LG INR18650-MJ1 cells, which is good. They also perform well at load currents up to 10 A and have a real capacity of around 3400 mAh. But there's a “fly in the ointment”: the overcurrent protection threshold is set much too high. 20–21 A is still a lot, and you could accidentally damage the battery.
Vapcell N1830A 18650 3000mah 15A - Also good, though honestly, I think they're very good. These batteries really do deliver more than 3000 mAh, can sustain discharge currents up to 15 A and handle brief bursts up to 20 A. The protection trips correctly, even allowing pulsed loads up to 25 A while still providing the necessary level of safety.
Vapcell P1830A 18650 3000mah 15A - These batteries, on the other hand, still have me puzzled. In practice, they're the same N1830A cells, but with the protection board near the positive terminal. I don't know what advantage that offers, but the price is slightly higher, they're 1 mm shorter, resistance is 1.5–2 mΩ lower, and the appearance has been changed. That's it.


And overall:
Most likely, all these batteries are built around genuine cells: LG INR18650-MJ1 for the N1835A, and Murata VTC6 for the N1830A and P1830A. But as they say, that's not certain—although the discharge curves do point that way, at least for the N1835A.
Overall, they're all pretty good. The N1835A drew the most criticism: one sample fell just short of the stated minimum of 3400 mAh, and it has an oversized protection board. As for the other batteries, the only real complaint is their relatively long length, but that's the trade-off for having protection.

While preparing this review, I checked the prices offered for the 11.11 sale: $12.18 for one N1830A, or $17.80 for a pair including a case; for the P1830A, $13.12 for one and $19.68 for a pair.

That's all for now. I hope you found this useful.
$12.99-$13.99
Go to store
This page was found when searching for:
следующая после vapcell s4 plus модель в линейке, аккумулятор 18650 защита от бактерий телефона, vapcell аккумуляторы 18650, http

Questions and answers

What capacity did the Vapcell N1835A 18650 deliver?

At a 0.2C discharge rate, the first cell delivered 3426 mAh (12.45 Wh); the second tested below 3400 mAh.

At what current does the Vapcell N1835A protection trip?

Its overload protection tripped at about 21 A, although the stated threshold is 15–18 A. The author considers this too high for a high-capacity cell.

How do the Vapcell N1830A and P1830A differ?

The P1830A has its protection board by the positive terminal, is 1 mm shorter, and has 1.5–2 mΩ lower resistance. The author sees no significant advantage in these differences.


This model is included in the summary table: Battery comparison: measured capacity and resistance

The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Batteries

Calculate manuallyAll calculators

Discounted products


You may be interested in


Discounted products


Support the project

All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!

Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forum

Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.

Log inRegister