Active Capacitive Balancer for 6S Battery Packs
$25.11
After my review of the inductive balancer, one of my readers got in touch and suggested I review a balancer he was planning to order for his lithium battery. We agreed, he placed the order, it arrived, and eventually it ended up on my workbench. He also lent me the battery this balancer will be working with, for which I’d like to thank him.
Along with the balancer and battery, he also included a cable for connecting it to a charger and a connector for the balancer.

Let’s start with the battery.
It’s a 6S lithium pack with a claimed capacity of 12 Ah, and even has a strap. I don’t think I’ve seen one like this before; most are the usual cylindrical type.
The pack is rated for a maximum discharge current of 25C. Charging specs are 4.2 V per cell and up to 2C. It’s available in configurations from 3S to 12S.

It weighs 1.6 kg and measures 177 × 71 × 63 mm, excluding the wires. There’s a bulge around where the strap is attached, though, which makes the battery look a little swollen.

The balancer connects through a standard 7-pin connector with 2.5 mm pitch. The spare mating connector wasn’t needed, but it was still nice of him to think it might come in handy.
The power connection uses an XT90 connector.
The power wires are 10 AWG, and very flexible. Here I’ll make a brief digression: the connector and wires are attached to the battery using a terminal block. I strongly advise against using these terminal blocks because they’re unreliable, and recommend soldering instead.

That’s the battery. Now let’s move on to the balancer board itself. It’s also sold under other brands, including Heltec.

The only useful information on the seller’s page is this brief description (machine-translated by Google):
Balancing mode: capacitor (full group), equalizer
Operating voltage: 2.0–4.2 V
Low-voltage sleep setting: sleep voltage can be selected from 2.0 V, 3.0 V, or 3.7 V. Supports ternary lithium, lithium iron phosphate, and lithium titanate batteries.
Balancing accuracy: less than 5 mV
Balancing current: 0.1 V 1 A, 0.2 V 2 A; the greater the voltage difference, the higher the current
Maximum balancing current: 6 A
Balanced static power: 12 mA
Suitable for batteries: 30 Ah–300 Ah
The board is small, measuring 80 × 50 × 16 mm. The wires are very flexible and about 45 cm long, although the black wire is a little shorter.

The top has the telltale sign of a capacitive balancer: a crowd of polymer capacitors, in this case rated at 2200 µF, 6.3 V. This is a 6S balancer, and you can see six pairs of capacitors on top, plus another pair that appear to be shared by the whole balancer.
You can also see that the balancer comes in two versions: one for Li-Ion/LiFePO4 batteries and another for LTO. When I was looking for a photo for the title, I came across a version for three types, listed as “standard,” LiFePO4, and LTO. As far as I know, though, there’s no point in separating the first two types.

The underside of the board is also packed with components. Most of the area is taken up by MOSFETs: 24 in total, four per channel. There are also six SO-8 chips, presumably MOSFET drivers; a small SOT23-6 chip that, judging by the nearby inductor, is almost certainly a DC-DC converter; and another SOT23-5 chip, possibly an oscillator.
There are also six fuses at the top, marked with the letter U. I couldn’t determine their trip current; for some reason, I couldn’t find it in the tables, but I found them on AliExpress, where they’re listed as 72 V and 6.3–8 A.
The board is coated with protective varnish, which improves reliability.

The person who sent me the board had already looked into what components it used, so he removed the varnish from a couple of them.
MOSFETs: MDU1518, 30 V, 94 A, 4.2/6.2 mΩ
The eight-pin chip next to them is presumably an EG2131 driver.
I couldn’t identify the DC-DC chip.
The oscillator is probably something similar to the ubiquitous 555 timer.

Judging by the number of channels, this uses a different balancing principle from the inductive balancer. First, the capacitors on each channel are charged from their respective batteries. The voltage across the capacitors is the same as across the batteries.
The transistors then disconnect them from the batteries and connect them in parallel, equalizing their charge levels.
After that, the capacitors for each channel are connected to the batteries again. This time, though, they are at the same voltage, so the more charged battery charges the capacitor again, while the less charged one is topped up from it.
This circuit allows the voltage across the battery cells to be balanced more precisely.
The battery arrived completely discharged. The cell voltages shown here and below are listed from the first to the sixth; the first is the one connected to the circuit's negative (common) wire, marked in black.
There is also a slight imbalance: the battery's total voltage was 18.467 V.
All voltages shown here and below were measured with the balancer disconnected. I'll note separately where measurements were taken with the balancer connected.

I'll run the experiment under the most challenging conditions, so I'll charge just one cell—the first one in the circuit.
It took 12.25 Ah to fully charge it, which matches the capacity stated on the battery.
After charging, the first cell was at 4.1819 V, and the total was 19.574 V. I'll put everything into one table later, but for now I'll show the key moments in chronological order with photos.

Naturally, I wanted to measure the current in the battery circuit during the test, but I didn't want to introduce any additional measurement error. So I took a slightly different approach: I measured the wire resistance, then used the voltage drop across the wires to determine the current.
I got 13.37 mΩ over a length of 44 cm. The wire is marked 18AWG. According to the table, a wire of this length and gauge should have a resistance of 9.2 mΩ, which is close to my measurement, though I suspect the wire itself may be undersized.

To make the measurement easier, I soldered short pieces of wire to the first and second cells. I connected one multimeter probe to these, and the other to the connector contact without breaking the circuit.
Here are the results (measurements taken at 20-minute intervals):
1. Immediately after connection: 1S - 4.78 A, 2S - 287 mA
2. 20 minutes: 1S - 3.17 A, 2S - 127 mA
3. 40 minutes: 1S - 2.33 A, 2S - 40 mA
4. 60 minutes: 1S - 1.93 A, 2S - 27 mA
The balancer was rated for a balancing current of up to 5–6 A. My initial results were similar, and I think the current could have been higher if the wires had been shorter.

The board heated up mainly around the balancer for the first cell. These measurements were taken 20, 60, and 100 minutes after the test began.

An hour and 20 minutes into the test, I measured the current in the last cell's circuit out of curiosity. The results were:
1S 1.66 A
2S 11 mA
6S -264 mA
In each case, I connected the multimeter's negative probe to the board and the positive probe to the connector. As you can see, the current through the last battery is flowing in the opposite direction.
This measurement isn't entirely accurate, since the current is pulsed, but I hope the multimeter was able to measure the average current correctly.

About 10 hours into the test, the current had dropped noticeably:
1S 322 mA
2S 2.5 mA
6S -51 mA

After that, I connected the first cell to the charger to check how much capacity it had used.
In theory, with a capacity of 12 Ah and perfect balancing, the cells should end up at 2+2+2+2+2+2 Ah instead of the original 12+0+0+0+0+0 Ah. That means charging the first cell should take about 10 Ah, though of course that's under ideal conditions and at 100% efficiency. The charge took 8.231 Ah, which also suggests that the first cell had supplied most of the charge for the other five.

After that, I put it back on the balancer and measured the currents about 6 hours later. The results were:
1S 266 mA
2S -37 mA
6S -36.8 mA
I took these measurements for my own interest, but included them because, unlike in the previous measurements, the current was now negative not only on the sixth channel, but on the second as well.

The cell voltages 35 hours into the test, after recharging the first cell once, were as follows.
Note that cells 2–6 were charged only by the first cell. The largest difference was between the first and second cells: 16 mV. The total voltage of the pack was 22.626 V.

Next, I connected the entire battery to the charger, but kept an eye on the voltage of the most charged cell just in case, since the battery has no protection board.
1, 2. Toward the end of charging, the voltage on the first cell rose to the critical level of 4.25 V, but since it didn't rise any further, I didn't stop charging
3, 4. In the end, charging took 9.296 Ah, and the maximum voltage on the first cell was 4.2517 V. It was measured directly on the balancer board, so there is some measurement error.
I think shortening the wires would have helped a lot here. With the higher voltage on that channel, the balancer could have redistributed the energy more effectively.

In reality, the voltage on the first cell was a little higher. Almost immediately after disconnecting the charger, it measured 4.256 V, and the battery's total voltage was 25.194 V. The largest imbalance was between the first and second cells, at 79 mV.

And here are the results after 12 hours. The maximum difference was just 1 mV, again between the first and second cells. I'd say that's excellent.

And of course, here are the results in numerical and graphical form.
The leftmost column shows the time in minutes. For the first three hours, I checked every 20 minutes; after that, the checks were more sporadic, since the main balancing phase was over.
The results 6 and 18 hours after the intermediate charge of the first cell are highlighted in yellow.

The same data as a graph. The numbers along the horizontal axis correspond to the table rows.

I also measured the voltages with the balancer connected. The numbering is a little different here, so it's easier to go by the time elapsed since the start of the test. This chart also includes the results after fully charging the battery, highlighted in orange.
Note that with the balancer connected, the final imbalance was just 0.6 mV!

The graph shows the intermediate charging stages: point 7, when the first cell was charged, and point 11, when the battery was fully charged.

The battery's total voltage was 25.1 V. I then connected it to the charger again, and it took just 178 mAh to charge.
By the way, the seller's page listed the board's own current consumption as 25 mA. I measured less: 178/12 = 15 mA, and that's with the battery still being balanced.

And of course, the conclusions.
In my opinion, this is an excellent balancer. There are better options, but definitely not at this price, so I won't even consider them—their price is several times higher.
Compared with an inductive balancer, its advantage is that it doesn't transfer energy from the first cell to the second, then from the second to the third, and so on. Instead, it balances the whole battery at once, distributing energy from the most charged cell to the less charged ones.
This operating principle is what allowed it to achieve a balancing accuracy of 0.6–1 mV. I didn't monitor the process any further.
There are drawbacks, too. With a large imbalance, the process is slow. Also, the balancer clearly consumes more power than an inductive one, where a dedicated chip handles everything and can enter sleep mode. I think this is partly why it's recommended for use with high-capacity batteries.
And then there's the price: it's noticeably more expensive than an inductive balancer.
Even with these drawbacks, I can recommend it. What I liked was that it managed to balance the battery quite well even though only one of the six cells in the pack was charged.
I also have some recommendations for improving the setup I reviewed, as well as for setups in general.
1. Don't use polyethylene terminal blocks in high-current circuits. Use something better, or solder the wires instead.
With tinned wires, heating can cause the clamping force to weaken, after which the terminal block simply starts to melt.
2. In my opinion, the balancing connector is a bit flimsy for currents around 4–6 A, since it was originally intended more for monitoring. It would be better to replace it with a more robust one.
3. Shorten the wires to the balancer. It will respond more dynamically and can deliver more current with smaller voltage drops. This won't help when balancing at low currents, but it can make a difference near the end of charging or discharging.
4. Use a protection board—it's essential. When connecting or disconnecting the wires, and generally while tinkering with the board, I was always worried something would short out. The special effects would have been spectacular :)
That's all for now. I hope you found this useful.
$25.11
This page was found when searching for:
3, 4, 1, подключение активного балансира, можно ли балансир 10s использовать в аккумуляторе 6s, smart балансир lto обзор, подключение балансировочный разъем 6s, разделение цепи зарядки и цепи нагрузки 6s аккумулятора, смарт балансир lto 6s, 2, схема балансира на свинцовый акк, какую выбрать bms lto 6s 12v 100ah, активный балансир своими руками, какой провод нужен для батареи 6s, для чего нужна перемычка run в активных литиевых балансиров, https://www.kirich.blog/obzory/akkumulyatory/995-aktivnyy-emkostnoy-balansir-dlya-6s-akkumulyatornyh-batarey, Активный балансир для АКБ элни-2/12-05, как сделать балансир на 6 волт овые батареи, ёмкостной балансир, перемычка run на емкостном балансире, как работает балансир 6с, lto 6s bms, балансир для bimax 6, емкостный балансир для lto, bms 6s с балансировкой 24v 30a
3, 4, 1, подключение активного балансира, можно ли балансир 10s использовать в аккумуляторе 6s, smart балансир lto обзор, подключение балансировочный разъем 6s, разделение цепи зарядки и цепи нагрузки 6s аккумулятора, смарт балансир lto 6s, 2, схема балансира на свинцовый акк, какую выбрать bms lto 6s 12v 100ah, активный балансир своими руками, какой провод нужен для батареи 6s, для чего нужна перемычка run в активных литиевых балансиров, https://www.kirich.blog/obzory/akkumulyatory/995-aktivnyy-emkostnoy-balansir-dlya-6s-akkumulyatornyh-batarey, Активный балансир для АКБ элни-2/12-05, как сделать балансир на 6 волт овые батареи, ёмкостной балансир, перемычка run на емкостном балансире, как работает балансир 6с, lto 6s bms, балансир для bimax 6, емкостный балансир для lto, bms 6s с балансировкой 24v 30a
Questions and answers
How does the capacitive balancer for a 6S battery work?
Its capacitors charge from the cells in turn, are then connected in parallel to equalize their charge, and are connected back to the battery cells.
What balancing accuracy did the 6S balancer reach?
The author brought the balancing accuracy to 0.6–1 mV, then stopped monitoring the process.
What does the author recommend changing when installing the balancer?
Use a more reliable connection for the power wires instead of terminal blocks, replace the weak balance connector, shorten the wires, and add a protection board.
The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Battery packs and power banks
Calculate manuallyAll calculators
Discounted products
You may be interested in
Discounted products
Support the project
All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!
Comments2
Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forumOnly registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.
Log inRegister




Comments are published in their original language.