A Budget Kit with Four AHD Cameras and a DVR, or What AHD-M Is All About
$85.38
I can’t compare them “side by side” because the previous set is now in use at a friend’s place, but I still have some screenshots, and they’ll be part of the comparison too.
So, the goal is to find the cheapest possible non-analog solution with 1 MP resolution (which, in my opinion, is the bare minimum). A set of IP WiFi cameras and a recorder cost about $140.
The set under review has roughly the same specs, except it doesn’t have WiFi.
Here are the specs listed by the manufacturer.
Recorder
Codec: H.264
Recorder video outputs: VGA, HDMI
Playback resolution: 1080N
Decoding: 4 x 1080N
Encoding: 4 x 1080N
Motion detection: screen divided into 192 zones, adjustable sensitivity.
Audio compression format: G.711A
Recording: HDD, network
Exporting saved video: network, USB hard disk, USB burner, SATA burner
Network connection: RJ45 10M / 100M
Power: 12V / 2A
Power consumption: less than 15W
Menu languages: Simplified Chinese, Traditional Chinese, Dutch, English, German, Hebrew, Italian, Kazak, Farsi, Polish, Portuguese, Russian, Spanish, Thai, Korean, Czech, Turkish, Hungarian, Romanian, Bulgarian
Video cameras
Sensor: 1/4 inch CMOS
Effective pixel count: 1280 x 720P
Frame rate: 25fps ( PAL ), 30fps ( NTSC )
Minimum illumination: 0.1Lux ( AGC on ), 0.01Lux ( IR on )
Signal-to-noise ratio: less than 50dB
Electronic shutter: auto
IR illumination: 36pcs LEDs
IR illumination range: 20m
Optics: 3.6mm 3MP lens
Power: DC12V, 1A
Temperature range: -20 - 80 Deg.C
Maximum cable length: over 500m
Protection rating: IP66
Viewing angle: 72 degree
First, what is AHD?
Last time, I wrote that video surveillance systems fall into several classes, but I divided them only into analog and IP cameras.
In fact, there’s a whole intermediate class of equipment, which I only mentioned briefly. Readers pointed this out in the comments.
I looked into it in a little more detail and decided to share what I learned. I hadn’t been interested in it before, since I’d simply switched from analog cameras to IP systems and forgotten about coaxial cable like a bad dream. So there may be some mistakes, but I’ve tried to get the general idea right.
By the time IP video surveillance came along, many people already had older-generation surveillance systems—that is, analog ones—so the question arose of how to upgrade the systems they already had.
Some will say, “What’s there to change? Just replace the cable and that’s it.” But it’s not that simple. Cable networks can be very expensive, rerouting them isn’t always possible, and the work itself costs money. Often, the cable run to a camera can cost more than the camera itself.
As a result, an entire class of equipment emerged: high-definition digital and analog cameras that work over ordinary coaxial cable.
All the equipment can be laid out in a table like this. The far-right column shows IP cameras using the familiar twisted-pair connection; the other cameras use coaxial cable.
Of all the formats listed, only HD-SDI and 3G-SDI cameras are fully digital. The others use an analog signal modulated according to a specific algorithm, or are fully analog. The table also classifies 3G-SDI as having an analog interface, but I don’t think that’s correct.

The first time I came across systems like these was when I saw HD-SDI. Its advantages were video with no delay, high quality (1080p), and the ability to use existing cable runs. There was one drawback, though: you needed a special video capture card installed in a computer. The cards were four-channel, which isn’t very convenient for larger systems.
AHD systems are said to offer much the same, with the added claim that they provide greater signal transmission distance and support resolutions up to 1080p.
Compared with IP systems, the greater range is a significant advantage, since the maximum network segment length over twisted-pair cable is limited to just 100 meters. But in terms of resolution, 1–2 MP cameras are entry-level, and 3.2, 4, and 5 MP cameras are already quite common, not to mention 8 MP (4K) models.
By the way, as far as I understand, 4K resolution is also supported by 6G UHD-SDI systems (4K at 30 fps) and 12G UHD-SDI systems (4K at 60 fps), which are implementations of the HD-SDI and 3G-SDI standards I mentioned above.

Another major advantage touted by all the sellers dealing in AHD systems is zero latency.
Yes, that’s true—but only until you start using a server-client setup.
Once you decide to connect to the DVR remotely, you can forget about zero latency. Your whole system will work just like a regular IP system: the camera sends the signal to the DVR, the DVR's DSP compresses it and sends it over the cable, and then your computer decodes it. In short, it's exactly what an IP camera does internally.
Besides, a properly configured IP system has fairly low latency (up to 0.5–1 sec total). That's critical in casino surveillance systems, but at home you simply won't notice it, so this advertising claim is pretty much meaningless.
AHD cameras do have one small advantage, though: they start up as soon as power is applied, while an IP camera takes about 30 seconds to turn on or reboot.

Now I'll move on to reviewing a budget surveillance kit with four 1 MP cameras and a DVR. Along the way, I'll make a few comparisons with IP systems and point out the key differences.
The kit comes in a fairly large box that is supposed to contain all the equipment you need.

The box has a colorful promotional sticker, as well as a smaller one with the product name and default login.

At first glance (and even at second glance), everything looks like it's been tossed in together. Surprisingly, though, it's all packed quite tightly and nothing rattles around. The DVR is also packed separately in protective packaging.

The equipment is packed in two layers. The top layer contains:
1. DVR
2. DVR power supply
3. 4 camera power supplies
4. Mouse
5. HDMI cable
6. CD with software (presumably)
7. Manual
8. Warranty card.
9. Screws for securing the

A set of paperwork; I'll show it in more detail later.
An HDMI cable, which is useful—we'll assume it'll come in handy. The last kit didn't include one.
The mouse is small and not very comfortable. A few times I pressed both buttons instead of just the left one.
The power supplies have European plugs, which is a plus. But the plugs on the smaller power supplies are a little shorter and don't fit very securely in grounded outlets.
The camera power supplies are rated at 12 V, 1 A; the DVR's is more powerful, at 2 A. In practice, it stays cool when running a 2.5-inch hard drive. The 2 A rating only matters with 3.5-inch hard drives.

The manual is in English. It covers everything, but very briefly, and it covers several DVR models at once.
The power supplies were taken apart and inspected beforehand.
First, the 12 V, 1 A unit. Both types of power supply have the same design; the only visible difference is their size.
It looks like a pretty budget power supply, though what else would you expect with a budget device?

The rest of the teardown is hidden under the spoiler, since I don't think many readers will be interested in it.
Comparison photo and a brief summary:
The power supplies are cheap. The smaller ones are fine, except for the lack of a fuse. I wouldn't use the larger one with a 3.5-inch hard drive, and it has the same problem with no fuse.
I just don't understand this kind of penny-pinching.

The DVR, so to speak, is the heart of the system.
The case is made of plastic, with a power indicator LED on top. It isn't very bright.
The plastic is matte, but fingerprints show up immediately. Quite a few DVRs with different names are made in this same case, so many people will recognize it.

Since the cameras connect via coaxial cable, there are four BNC connectors on the back. Next to them are a pair of RCA connectors for audio input and output.
Further to the right is a block with Ethernet and a pair of USB ports, followed by the power input. The two USB ports are a plus, since the previous model had only one, which was extremely inconvenient.
The monitor connectors are on the bottom: VGA and HDMI. That's convenient too—you can connect almost any monitor or TV.

The product page has a fairly clear diagram showing the possible connection options. The first shows the DVR working on its own; the second shows it connected to a local network, with access from a client computer.

The case has plenty of ventilation, with lots of slots on the bottom and sides. That's a plus.

I removed the four screws and took a look inside. Last time I reviewed a DVR with a metal case, and I'll say this: I like the plastic one better. The metal case sometimes resonated with the hard drive running, which was quite annoying.

Inside, we find a fairly familiar circuit board, the kind found in the vast majority of inexpensive DVRs.

The main board is secured with four screws, and the camera connector board with another three.

The camera connectors and audio input/output are on a separate board.
The camera inputs are protected by suppressors, which is good news: the chance of burning out an input is significantly lower. During testing, I deliberately connected cameras while their power was on, and everything worked perfectly.
But since I'm comparing IP cameras connected via twisted-pair cable with regular cameras, I have to point out that BNC connectors, despite looking sturdy, are very inconvenient. Proper connectors cost quite a bit, while cheap ones often lose contact. Sometimes the only solution was to solder the cable directly.
The same goes for this DVR. I used RCA-to-BNC adapters, and had no problems during testing. But then I moved the whole setup to another location, and both cameras stopped working. I wiggled the connector, and everything was fine again.
So in that respect, I much prefer RJ-45. It can have problems too, but far less often. Also, an Ethernet connection provides galvanic isolation; an analog signal does not.

The board is generally well made, but those hard drive power wires... They could have used a connector, but apparently gluing them in place with hot glue was easier. Overall, there are clear signs of cost-cutting.

The DVR has no indicators (apart from the power LED), no power switch—nothing at all. That's why some components are missing near the power connector. I spotted a couple of protective suppressors near it, but it's unclear where they go or what they protect, since some components around them are missing.

The connector for the front panel and (presumably) sensors isn't even populated. There's also no second SATA connector, even though the processor supports two drives.

But one thing that's genuinely good is the large heatsink. The previous DVR had no additional cooling at all, so credit to the manufacturer for this. In my opinion, it's better to save on a connector and include a heatsink than the other way around. Of course, having both would be best.

1. You can also see protection components near the HDMI and VGA connectors, but it's still better not to connect a monitor while the DVR is powered on.
2. The battery for the built-in RTC (real-time clock) is installed in a holder. Nearby is a spot for a buzzer, as well as a connector I don't recognize.

A quick look at the components.
1. NVP6124B, an ADC chip that digitizes the camera signals. It supports up to 4 cameras.
2. 8 MB flash memory 25L6406 for storing the DVR firmware.
3. 256 MB of DDR3 RAM K4B2G1646F.
4. mb358gm, a dual-channel operational amplifier, presumably responsible for the audio channel.
5, 6. Voltage regulators.

There are a few components on the back as well, but the main thing for me was that it identified which processor (SoC) was used.

1. Judging by the markings, the installed chip is a Hi3520D
2. 74LVC125, a four-channel buffer.
3. There is also an EEPROM chip on the underside.
4. While I was at it, I found another TVS diode on the underside, near the LAN connector. Apparently, the manufacturer added some basic protection.

The processor in the DVR is an almost fully integrated solution. It has a built-in network interface, SATA controllers, and four video outputs (two composite outputs, which aren't used).
You can see the full configuration in this block diagram.
The digitized signal from the ADC goes to the processor, which handles everything else: encoding and decoding video, transmitting it over the local network, recording to the hard drive, and so on.

And now I've finally made it to the cameras—hooray! If you haven't fallen asleep yet, let me remind you that you're reading a review of a DVR with AHD cameras :)
The cameras are packed in a second layer, nestled in compartments made of polyethylene foam.

One instruction manual is included for all the cameras, and each set also contains:
1. Camera
2. Mounting hardware
3. Hex key
4. Two BNC plugs.

The manual covers not only these cameras, but all the cameras sold by this company.
It lists the AHD camera specifications. Curiously, it gives two resolution options (720 and 1080), but three sensor options—or rather, three pixel counts.
It also says the cameras use a 1/3-inch SONY sensor, although the original specifications listed 1/4 inch.
It then gives some wild figures: 100, 130, and even 200 million pixels. So, yes, quite a manual.
Analog camera options are shown on the right.

The back of the manual shows some other camera options, but the DVR doesn't support them.

1. Mounting hardware, with the usual green wall plugs and a small hex key.
2. Two BNC plugs. It's a small thing, but a nice touch. I usually use my own, but having spares never hurts. By the way, if you're upgrading an old analog system, it uses the same connectors, so all you need to do is remount the cameras and switch the connectors.
3. The center contact is secured with a screw, which is unusual; soldering is more common.
4. The connector's ground contact is quite substantial. I have no complaints.

The camera looks pretty ordinary, maybe with a slightly different design, but that's about it.

The IR illuminator looks unusual, though. By the way, it's less noticeable in operation than on the previous cameras, which is good.

1. There are no markings on the camera body at all, just the company name. I see this as a drawback, since it took me a while to figure out whether I really had a megapixel AHD camera in my hands.
2. The bracket mechanism is pretty standard, although cheap cameras often use a different design where a nut clamps the ball joint. That's worse.
3. The camera's mounting base is a little larger than the one on the Escam, and it also has a foam rubber gasket.
4. A single cable comes out of the camera, ending in BNC and power connectors. The power connector fits very tightly, the complete opposite of the one on the Escam camera. There's no chance of accidentally unplugging it—I've checked.

I've taken apart a lot of cameras. Though, why stop there? I've always liked taking things apart, ever since I was a kid :)
The housing design is noticeably different from that of the previous cameras. The housing itself is metal, while the plastic front section is secured with four self-tapping screws. There's also a rubber gasket running around the entire perimeter.

And here's the whole assembly. I don't think I'm far off if I say the housing could be five times shorter.
The IR illuminator board, the camera board, and then... nothing. The mounting system is unusual too: the backlight board is attached to the housing with three self-tapping screws, and the camera itself is then screwed onto the backlight board.

At a glance, the only difference between the backlights is the type of LEDs installed.

The camera module. It looks like a very ordinary analog camera.

The board is designed to fit two sizes, so if you want, you can install it in an even smaller housing.
There are very few components. After seeing IP cameras, especially branded ones, this board looks practically empty.

1. The camera is based on the FH8532E chip. It supports 1 and 1.3 MP sensors, as well as standard CVBS/960H/1280H output and 720P60/50/30/25 HDcctv modes.
2. And a few power converters.
You may have noticed that the chip has no heatsink. I can tell you that this board draws very little power, which is why I said above that the included power supply is sufficient. In a way, that's a good thing, since IP cameras draw more power and therefore get hotter.

Since the IR filter shutter mechanism covered almost the entire board, I decided to remove it. But it turned out there was almost nothing on this side of the board either.


The only components on this side of the board are the IR filter shutter driver and an EEPROM chip that stores the video processing chip's settings.
A protective TVS diode is visible next to the driver; it protects the camera's video output from damage.

The sensor measures 4 × 2.5 mm, or 4.71 mm diagonally. The product description claimed it was 1/4 inch, while the manual said 1/3 inch. In reality, the sensor size falls somewhere between those two values: 5.33 mm is 1/3 inch, while 4.00 mm is 1/4 inch. It's not clear how they arrived at the stated size.

The overall concept behind this system, which looks so complicated, is very simple. The signal from the sensor goes to a processing chip, which modulates it and sends it down the line.
The signal then goes to a chip that digitizes it. I showed that chip when I took apart the DVR.
After that, the digitized signal goes to the processing and compression processor. That's it.
An IP system works differently. The signal from the sensor goes to a processing chip, like the one in the DVR, where it's processed and compressed. It then goes to a remote recorder, although some cameras can also record directly to a flash card, replacing everything up to and including the recorder. In that case, all you need to view the footage is a computer.

The housing can take hard drives in both sizes, 2.5 and 3.5 inches. I used a 2.5-inch drive for the tests.
There are special rails for a 3.5-inch drive, although I personally don't quite see the point of them.
There are separate mounting holes for each drive size, four for each. The only problem is that the included mounting screws are for 3.5-inch drives; 2.5-inch drives need screws with a smaller diameter.

Given the current price difference, I don't think it matters which drive you install, so I recommend a 2.5-inch drive because it runs cooler.

Let's start up the DVR. There will be lots of photos of the various menus. Since there are so many, even after removing some, I'll hide them under a spoiler too.
I had no problems using the DVR in standalone mode. There aren't many settings, but what can you expect? It's not an IP camera. By the way, if you compare the DVR's settings with those of the same Excam IP camera—or any other, for that matter—you'll notice that this DVR is missing an entire camera settings menu. That menu usually lets you select a wide dynamic range, backlight compensation, day/night mode, and so on. None of that is here. Not a single option—the whole menu item has been "cut out." It's a shame; after using an IP camera, you feel shortchanged.
But let's try connecting to the DVR over the network.
First, I launched the standard version of IE, which cheerfully informed me that I needed to install an additional player. All right, let's install it.

But even with the player, the image in the browser was problematic. Sometimes the picture looked normal (as far as you can call this image normal), and sometimes the screen turned green. The image kept switching between normal and green.
And that's not even mentioning that you can't access the DVR settings.

Well, browsers aren't working out. Let's try the tried-and-tested Tecsar software. This worked straight away, with no problems at all. The software found the DVR on the network automatically.

And just a few seconds later, it displayed the image on screen. So it's best to forget about browsers and use the dedicated software instead.
I won't go through the software settings in detail. I can only say that they duplicate the DVR's settings completely, except perhaps for a few items related to access and security, which makes sense.

Now we can finally get to what is, after all, the most important thing about a video camera: image quality.
Unfortunately, some of the images taken with inexpensive IP cameras were lost for good, so for the outdoor test I had to use screenshots from video that had already been re-encoded. This means I'm indirectly giving the cameras under review a slight advantage, since their screenshots are shown "as is."
So, let's get started.
Daytime: the quality is, to put it mildly, not very good.

1 MP IP camera from an inexpensive kit.

The comparison photo shows that the IP camera performs better, even though its image has been compressed.
I tried "playing around" with the contrast and brightness on the camera under review, and that did improve things somewhat, but I conducted the test using the default settings.

Same spot, at night.
Camera under review.

1 MP IP

Comparison. Once again, the image from the camera under review (it's on the right in every comparison) turns into "milk." What a shame.

I don't have a comparison photo for this one, so these are screenshots from the AHD camera only.
Daytime.

Evening, with the outdoor lights on

Night.

Now for a comparison indoors. The lighting is artificial.
Camera under review

1 MP IP camera. This is a full screenshot, captured using the video surveillance software.

The IP camera is on the left again, and the camera under review is on the right. The IP camera is sharper, but the camera under review reproduces colors more accurately, since our sofa isn't green :)

Complete darkness; the cameras are in the same order.
Camera under review

IP

The IP camera is on the left, and the AHD camera is on the right.
Neither image is very good, but in my opinion the left one shows more detail.

And finally, a test shot of some text. This time I had to move the camera as far away as possible because its field of view is narrow. The subject ended up about 3.1 m away.

Same conditions, but at the edges of the image.

To wrap up, I decided to connect an old but quite decent analog camera to the DVR: a Panasonic WV-CP284 with a Tokina 6-60 lens. I had to turn the focal length all the way down to 6 mm, but it was still narrower than on the cameras under review, whose focal length was closer to 5 mm. I focused it on the test sheet.
I selected D1 mode in the settings, but for some reason the screenshot came out at 960x576, which isn't quite right.
The camera is certainly old and had been installed at the site for several years, but I didn't expect the image to be this bad. I think the recorder and camera are incompatible.

The video turned out long—sorry about that.
It contains 10 clips, but here's a simpler breakdown:
1. Day
2. Night with IR illumination (that's not snow or rain, it's wind and dust)
3. Day
4. Night with street lighting
5. Night with IR illumination
I accidentally uploaded a video with duplicate clips, so I've re-uploaded the corrected version.
The recorder doesn't get very hot during operation; most of the heat comes from the power converters. Still, I'd recommend using 2.5-inch drives in recorders like this, especially since they don't cost much less than 3.5-inch drives.

That wraps up the test and inspection, so it's time to sum things up—some of the conclusions aren't very encouraging.
But let's take it in order. I'll start by explaining how IP differs from AHD, and what the advantages and disadvantages of each are.
IP system
Advantages
A wide range of additional features
Support for high resolutions
Some cameras can function as recorders
A camera can operate independently without a recorder, with access provided over the internet
Power over the cable (PoE)
Greater resistance to interference
Wi-Fi support
Disadvantages
Higher cost
A new cable run is needed when switching from analog surveillance to digital
Less reliable due to greater complexity.
The cable to the camera is limited to 100 m.
AHD
Advantages.
Can use existing cable runs.
Low cost
Easy to replace
The cable to the camera can be up to 500 m long.
Disadvantages
Resolution is limited to 1920x1080
Poor resistance to interference; I wouldn't use AHD systems at industrial sites.
Poor scalability.
Requires a video recorder
Very few image-processing settings—in fact, almost none.
Requires a separate power line for the cameras, or the use of splitters.
No way to transmit audio or control signals.
What can I say about the recorder under review? In my opinion, it has just two advantages:
1. Price. For $85, you get a complete surveillance kit with four cameras, a recorder, five power supplies, a mouse, and all the necessary connectors. That's pretty good.
2. You can easily replace old cameras with new ones.
If you're planning a new system rather than replacing or upgrading an old one, I'd definitely choose IP cameras, no question. In my opinion, AHD systems are a dead-end technology and essentially a "kludge"—a way to get something better than what you had when money is tight.
For this review, I deliberately compared roughly equivalent AHD and IP kits to see which was better and which was worse.
Last time, I estimated the cost roughly as follows:
4 Wi-Fi cameras at $25 each = 100
1 Wi-Fi recorder for $40 = 40
Total = 140.
This time, the breakdown is:
4 AHD-M cameras at $15 each = 60
1 recorder for $25 = 25
Total = 85
The kit under review is still a viable option, but probably only for a small private home with good lighting. You can replace old cameras and get a noticeably better result. The cameras perform better indoors, but their narrow field of view makes them inconvenient for indoor use; a system with a 2.8–3.6 mm lens would be a better choice.
Of course, this is a very budget-friendly solution, so you probably shouldn't expect anything exceptional from it. In practice, I didn't find any problems: it records video, doesn't shut down or freeze on its own, but the video quality is worse than that of the IP kit.
That's all. I hope I've managed to tell you a little about AHD video surveillance and that the information in this review will be useful. I bought the kit specifically for comparison.
$85.38
This page was found when searching for:
как переделать цифровую камеру в аналоговую, как переделать ip камеру в аналоговую форму, видеонаблюдение из видеорегистратора своими руками, плата видеорегистратор а6nhs-8, модуль камеры аналоговой купить, камера видеонаблюдения, обзор видеорегистраторов, тест камер, обзор камер, системы видео наблюдения
как переделать цифровую камеру в аналоговую, как переделать ip камеру в аналоговую форму, видеонаблюдение из видеорегистратора своими руками, плата видеорегистратор а6nhs-8, модуль камеры аналоговой купить, камера видеонаблюдения, обзор видеорегистраторов, тест камер, обзор камер, системы видео наблюдения
Questions and answers
How much does the four-camera AHD-M kit with recorder cost?
The review gives a total of $85: four cameras at $15 each and a recorder for $25.
How does AHD-M differ from the IP system in this review?
AHD uses coaxial cable and makes it possible to replace older cameras without rewiring the system. However, the author found its video quality worse than that of the comparable IP kit.
Does the AHD-M kit have latency or operating problems?
The cameras start almost immediately when powered, and the author found no faults, shutdowns, or freezes. Zero latency does not apply to remote viewing.
The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Other devices
Discounted products
You may be interested in
Discounted products
Support the project
All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!
Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forumOnly registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.
Log inRegister


























