/       /       /    A DVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance is all about
Support the project on Patreon


A DVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance is all about

$170.24
Go to store
I’m often asked in private messages about various video surveillance systems. The questions vary, but I’ve noticed that most of them boil down to explaining the theory. People also ask for help choosing an inexpensive, simple system for a summer house, private home, or small shop.
For this review, I’ve put together a simple kit and will use it to explain what’s what and why you need it.

As a brief preface, I should say that more experienced folks may spot some inconsistencies or mistakes in this review. The thing is, I don’t know everything either, even though I’ve been doing this for many years. And sometimes people have different views on the general principles of designing these systems. In any case, as always, the most interesting part is in the comments :)

First, a little theory—or “how I ended up in this line of work.” More precisely, I’ll tell you how I started working with these systems, and give you a little history along the way.

The first time I saw a video surveillance system being installed was around the end of 1996 (20 years ago). The cameras were pretty impressive for their time, with pan-and-tilt mechanisms, but they were huge monsters.

But a movie had a much bigger influence on me. Yes, watching it got me interested in video surveillance systems. The movie was Enemy of the State, released in 1998 and starring Will Smith. Back then it seemed like science fiction, but now many things in it look outdated. Even so, it’s still relevant today.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The first fully analog cameras were built around an electronic vacuum tube called a vidicon.
For example, Elektronika-501-Video (above) and Elektronika L-30.
I even had the second one at home. I tried to build my first video surveillance system, but hadn’t realized that this camera needed a special monitor, since the synchronization circuitry was in the monitor.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

But then cameras appeared on the market that made the earlier ones look like mammoths.
I started out with cameras that many of you have probably seen in stores selling this kind of equipment. They were ridiculously expensive back then: around $100 for a board camera and about $150 for one in a housing. These days, you can easily buy a 4-megapixel digital camera for that money.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The cameras were analog, but not entirely so, since they still performed some basic digital signal processing inside.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Analog video surveillance systems rarely had recording capability, mostly because of the cost, although I did come across systems based on a special VCR a couple of times.
Usually, the signals from several cameras were simply combined using a quad processor and sent to a monitor. A good quad processor was quite expensive, but there weren’t many alternatives.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

But with the advent of digital recorders and the simultaneous drop in camera prices, these systems became more and more common.
A typical video surveillance system looked roughly like this, although systems like these are still being made and bought today.
Their main advantages are simplicity and low cost, although lately the price of a basic analog system has almost caught up with that of a digital one.

The principle was, and still is, the same: signals from all the cameras are fed into a single device, the recorder. You then view the footage on a monitor connected to the recorder and/or remotely over the network.
Each camera can have its own power supply, or they can all be powered by a single shared power supply. I’m used to the second option, and I also install a protection board with a fuse on each channel (I’ve seen similar ones on AliExpress).

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Strangely enough, although I hardly ever work with video recorders, building my systems around computers, I actually started out with a video recorder.
Even stranger, the video recorders weren't imported. They were made (and still are) by the Moscow company Tral.
I worked with MSX models. Some of their specs might come as a shock, but back then they were really impressive.
Number of channels — 4
Resolution — 128x96 to 352x288 pixels
Total frame rate across all channels, color image, 325x288 resolution — 6 frames/s (1.5 frames per second per channel).
Computer connection — parallel port (LPT).

For all its simplicity, it had one important feature that other surveillance systems lacked. It could record video continuously while marking motion on a graph. That's not quite the same as recording only when motion is detected.
I often missed this feature in modern surveillance systems, and only very recently did I see it again in software from another company.

By the way, these recorders were how I first encountered “pregnant” capacitors in power supplies (a shout-out to the developers).
And this is what it looked like.

A video recorder and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

The device shown above belongs to the DVR (Digital Video Recorder) class—in other words, a device that records video digitally.

The next class is called PC-DVR (Personal Computer Digital Video Record), meaning a computer-based system for digital video recording.

After I'd had my fill of this recorder, naturally I wanted something more, so I started looking into alternatives.
I found information online about computer-based video surveillance systems. At the time, people were trying to build them around TV tuner cards and getting quite decent results. But one channel wasn't enough for me, so I bought a PICO-2000 surveillance card. I installed three or four of them in total, since the image quality wasn't great and the software was very basic.
The card was built around a chip used in TV tuners, but video was recorded from each camera in turn, in the sequence 1-2-3-4-1-2-3-4. The multiplexer (switch) chip is visible on the left. It could record audio from one channel (I may be misremembering; it was a long time ago).

A video recorder and four cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA video recorder and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

I wasn't satisfied with this system at all, so it was soon replaced with a more advanced DigiNet system, which delivered slightly better video quality.
With all 4 channels in use, video was recorded in real time (Real time), at the broadcast frame rate (25 frames/s per channel). That was a significant advantage. You could also expand the card by connecting additional video inputs (the connector at the top), though this reduced the frame rate. The frame rate could be adjusted separately for each camera.
But this card required far more resources than the others because it was “software-based.”
On the other hand, the software supported Server-Client mode: video was recorded on the server computer and could then be viewed from a client workstation when needed.

A video recorder and four cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA video recorder and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

I used DigiNet until 2006, when one of my friends (thanks, Vsevolod) introduced me to products from ILDVR. It was autumn, so you could say this is a round-number anniversary: 10 years.
These boards were a hardware-based solution: all signal processing and compression were handled by the board, not the computer's CPU. For example, a computer with a Celeron 800 MHz processor and 128 MB of memory could easily handle recording from 8 video cameras.
The boards were quite expensive, though. A four-channel model cost about $350, while an 8-channel one could run $650–800. Systems were often fitted with 2–3 boards.

The board could record video at 528x384, 25 fps, or 704x576, 17–18 fps. It also supported channel aggregation. In this mode, two channels could be combined into one and recorded at 704x576, 25 fps.
Another advantage was the ability to record pretty decent audio, with as many audio channels as video inputs.
The software offered more features than DigiNet at the time and was also more stable. I started with version 7.x, which had already been translated into Russian.

The photo shows the newer version; the boards used to be green.

A video recorder and four video cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA video recorder and four video cameras: what video surveillance consists of

The video quality was also better, mainly thanks to the increased color bit depth.
Here are examples of video recorded in 2006 by a DigiNet board and an ILDVR board using the same camera.




The most interesting thing is that, technically, I was introduced to Hikvision around the same time, since the boards from these two companies were completely identical.
These days, you can even find Hikvision chips on ILDVR boards.

A video recorder and four video cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA video recorder and four video cameras: what video surveillance consists of

But progress didn't stand still, and when digital cameras appeared, I became interested in them almost immediately. Although at the time they offered only a slightly better picture and cost an arm and a leg, they had at least one undeniable advantage.
Analog cameras transmit their signal over coaxial cable (sometimes over twisted pair using adapters), which means a loss in quality. If you need to transmit video over 100–200 m, you won't have much left of your 600 TVL—the image will be noticeably blurrier.
And then there are the interference issues. I work with industrial video surveillance systems, which means power cables, lots of equipment, and consequently, interference. Industrial video surveillance and security surveillance are quite different things; industrial systems have plenty of their own quirks. For example, cameras with heaters, cooling, and window washers (wipers) are even made specifically for industrial video surveillance, among other things.

Although these days I mostly use cameras that are sold in their own housings—in other words, complete, ready-to-use units—I still sometimes use cameras in protective housings.
A basic housing looks like this.

A video recorder and four video cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA video recorder and four video cameras: what video surveillance consists of

There are also housings like these, designed for dirty workshops. The price of this equipment is, of course, in a completely different league from the option shown above. And that's the simplest version shown here; there are also enclosures for extreme video surveillance, including explosion-proof models and ones resistant to radiation and high temperatures. Those cost astronomical amounts.

A video recorder and four video cameras: what video surveillance consists of

I've wandered off topic a bit.
Yes, digital video recorders started appearing along with digital cameras, but they were expensive at first, so manufacturers of analog surveillance systems came to the rescue, including ILDVR and Hikvision. I won't say much about the latter, since I don't work with their software much, but I can tell you about ILDVR.
Digital cameras and software that could work with digital and analog cameras at the same time were released right away.
This class of systems is called HVR (Hybrid Digital Recorder), i.e. a hybrid system. The same computer was used, with capture cards installed, but you could also connect digital cameras and use them just like analog ones. It's really convenient. The thing is, I use ILDVR software but Hikvision cameras. I tried ILDVR cameras, but somehow they just didn't work out for me: higher prices, lower quality. But this kind of workaround costs money: you have to pay a license fee to connect non-native cameras, and it's charged separately for each camera.

There are other software vendors too, such as Trassir, Intellect, and so on, but that's beyond the scope of this review, and I can already feel I'm going to get told off for writing too much.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

But as analog video surveillance is gradually dying out, a fourth class of surveillance systems has begun to develop: NVR (Network Video Recorder), i.e. a fully digital network video surveillance system.
There is also a separate class of devices: high-definition digital cameras that transmit their signal over coaxial cable and use their own capture cards. But these systems aren't very common, so I won't cover them.

So, we have four classes of devices:
DVR (Digital Video Recorder)
PC-DVR (Personal Computer Digital Video Record)
HVR (Hybrid Digital Recorder)
NVR (Network Video Recorder)

The first and last are the key ones, but since the first isn't of interest to us, I'll focus on the last one from here on.

Video surveillance systems were often considered complicated and overly technical, but systems that don't require any special knowledge or skills to install have started appearing. That means anyone can set one up (well, almost anyone). Today I'll tell you about one such system and show you how it's done.
I'll try to explain things in plain language, but unfortunately I'm no teacher, and I didn't study all that much myself, so I may get a bit confusing in places. If you have any questions, ask in the comments.

Video surveillance systems are usually sold as separate components: cameras, power supplies, cables, and a recorder. But all-in-one systems have started appearing—buy it, install it, turn it on, configure it, and use it.
I don't work with systems like these, and in general I rarely use systems with fewer than 8–12 cameras. At that point, a computer is more convenient.

This kit comes in one convenient box, although it's quite large. My assistant looks tiny next to it.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The large side panel is, of course, covered in advertising. Who would've guessed? :)
There's a carrying handle on top.
The sides list the basic specifications:

Four-channel video surveillance system with H264 compression and WiFi connectivity.
View footage over the internet using various browsers
Supports displaying information on iOS and Android devices
Motion detector with email notifications
Multi-window display (up to 4 channels).
One Ethernet port for connecting to a local network.
1 HDMI, 1 VGA, and 1 USB port
1 SATA port for connecting a hard drive with a capacity of up to 4 TB.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

That said, I have no complaints about the packaging. Everything is packed very tightly, and all the contents have double protection, not to mention the outer box, which isn't shown in the photos.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

After unpacking, I ended up with this pile of boxes on my desk. You can already see four identical camera packages, a bag with the recorder, and a box of accessories.

Kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofKit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Let's start with the accessories.
A separate large package containing:
Power supply
Patch cable for connecting to the local network
Mounting hardware
Mouse

Kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofKit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

1. The patch cable is a standard 1-meter cable. The bag of mounting hardware contains four screws for mounting a 3.5-inch screw hard drive and two for mounting a 2.5-inch drive.
2. The mouse is small. By the way, a mouse is often included with video recorders; at least, every one I've come across came with one. Well, think of it as a gift :)
3, 4. 12 V, 3 A power supply. It's just a power supply; it doesn't get particularly warm during use. I'll measure its power consumption later in the article. But it's nice that it has a European plug.

Kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofKit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The cameras come in identical boxes, but it turned out that not only the boxes are identical—the serial numbers printed on them are too.

Kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofKit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Each camera comes with:
The camera itself
WiFi antenna
Power supply
Mounting hardware and an Allen key

Kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofKit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

1. The antenna is fairly long and stays firmly in place once installed.
2. You can throw the mounting hardware away right away; the exact same kit comes with the more expensive cameras, too. The little Allen key, though, will come in handy—it’s needed to adjust the camera’s position.
3, 4. 12 V, 1 A power supply. It doesn't get warm during use, has a European plug, and I have no complaints.

Kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofKit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The cameras are relatively compact, and the housing is metal.

Kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofKit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The camera mount lets you set it at the desired angle. There are three adjustment points: the camera itself, the swivel joint, and the base. I have no complaints about this assembly. The joint has notches, so it won't turn on its own. I actually like this mechanism even more than the one on Hikvision cameras.
The base itself is metal too. I remember how much trouble we had with plastic ones, which dried out over time and simply broke under the slightest load. Fortunately, you hardly see those anymore.
Overall, no complaints on this point.

Kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofKit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

There is an antenna socket on the back. This is probably the only weak point; I’m not a fan of these connectors, especially on devices designed for outdoor installation. If you install this camera outside, I’d recommend either applying plenty of sealant around this spot or mounting the camera under an eave or roof overhang.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

There is a soft gasket on the bottom of the mounting foot to provide extra protection from water running down the wall. It will only help on very flat surfaces, though; it won’t do much on a brick wall, for example. Still, it’s better to have it than not.

They could have made the connector waterproof, but apparently decided to cut costs. Hikvision, for example, also used ordinary connectors for a long time. In any case, when installing the camera outdoors, you need to put a small junction box nearby to hide the connector in. I usually use electrical junction boxes, routing the cables in only from below so water can’t get inside.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The camera has built-in infrared illumination provided by 36 LEDs. They operate at a wavelength close to visible light, so their glow is noticeable—it looks like the tip of a cigarette.
From the description on the packaging, I gather there are two versions of the cameras: one with an array of 36 LEDs and another with four high-power LEDs. There’s no major difference. The individual LEDs may be more powerful, but it’s hard to say without trying them.

I usually recommend using a separate illuminator. That can give you a better image because the light source won’t be on the same optical axis. Also, a camera without built-in illumination attracts fewer insects, especially spiders, which like to spin their webs.
The underside of the sunshield has a black plastic insert that protects the camera from glare from the illuminator.

The front has glass, not plastic. That matters because plastic tends to get cloudy over time and is also very difficult to clean, while glass is easy to wash.
The central section containing the camera is separated from the rest. This is to prevent the LEDs from shining into the camera.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

According to the manual, the antenna should point upward, not sideways or down.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

When I first unpacked the cameras, they looked a lot like Hikvision cameras.
But when I compared them side by side, there turned out to be more differences: the mounting hardware is different, and so are the dimensions.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Disassembly. Most readers probably won’t find this very interesting, but it may help me figure out what exactly I’m looking at. I’ll comment on a few things as I go.

I was pleasantly surprised by the NVR's packaging. It's hard to damage anyway, but at least there's some protection against shipping damage. The NVR comes in a large, mattress-like bag.

A kit with an NVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with an NVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Included:
NVR
Manual
CD

I wouldn't call the NVR compact, especially compared with newer models from other manufacturers.

A kit with an NVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with an NVR and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Lately, I'm really surprised that they include a CD. At least this one has the manufacturer's branding, unlike the one that came with the computer.
Still, it's not very convenient. Fewer and fewer people have a CD drive.
I first tried to find the software online, but couldn't. I turned on the recorder and found a QR code, but it linked to phone software, not PC software. What's more, the software from the QR code and the disc are different!
In the end, I had to dig out a drive and make a separate archive, which is now available via the Yandex Disk link.

The manual isn't much use. An inexperienced user simply won't understand anything in it, except perhaps the picture showing how to position the camera and antenna correctly and incorrectly. An experienced user doesn't need the manual anyway.

A kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The most useful information is the technical specifications for this series of recorders. There are two recorder models, which can be supplied with three types of camera.
The recorders have 4 or 8 channels, and the cameras are available with 1.0, 1.3, or 2.0 megapixels. I have the most basic version.

I also found out that the cameras are rated to operate at temperatures only down to -10, which isn't very suitable for our climate. There probably won't be any problems at -20 either, but it's strange that they specify such a narrow range.

The camera manuals also list a parameter called Image sensor.
Image sensor — Usually refers to the type and size of the camera's sensor. It's a fairly important parameter that affects the camera's sensitivity; you can see its effect as increased image noise in low light. This camera uses a 1/4-inch sensor; 1/3 is better, and 1/2.8 is better still. In other words, the larger the sensor, the better.

A kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The recorder looks nice, although it's usually put in some storage room where nobody sees it. There are no buttons or switches on the front panel, just three spots for indicator LEDs: Power, HDD, and the mysterious SYS. The Power and HDD indicators seem to do their own thing; I never figured out the logic.
The front panel is mirrored and covered with protective film.

A kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

There are two WiFi antennas on the back. They're the same as the ones on the cameras, but permanently attached.

A kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The connectors are on the back panel.
VGA
HDMI
Enhernet
USB
Power

The first three connectors are straightforward: you can connect most monitors, and the Ethernet port takes a cable from the local network. The USB port, however, caused some confusion.
Or rather, not confusion so much as an odd situation. The 4-channel recorder has one USB port, while the 8-channel model has two.
So I never figured out how to do the simple, sometimes necessary task of copying video to another storage device without using a USB hub. They included a mouse, which is appreciated; it's certainly more convenient than using remotes and buttons, but in the basic setup you can connect only one device.
Of course, you can copy everything over the local network, which is actually more convenient in practice, but sometimes the recorder operates standalone.

A kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

There are four soft feet on the bottom, ventilation holes, and a label.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

Since DVRs don't come with hard drives, taking this one apart is essential. You'll have to do it anyway unless you plan to record to a network drive or remote computer, which isn't very convenient.

There's plenty of free space inside and a small circuit board. Plenty of free space is a good thing: the hard drive will run cooler. There's no fan; cooling is entirely passive, which is a plus here. If the case were smaller and made of plastic, with two drives installed, a fan would be necessary.
By the way, although the case has a decent paint finish, the metal is quite thin.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

There were two cables inside for connecting a hard drive. It's hard to plug them in the wrong way :)

A kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

The circuit board is marked HI3520D V318 NVR0408 and is built around an HI3520 processor.
This platform is fairly well known and widely used in inexpensive DVRs. It's not exactly new, though; it's been around for at least three years.
There's a buzzer on the board. It beeps briefly when powered on and can also be used for notifications about various events.
There's also a battery to power the built-in clock. The cameras synchronize with the DVR's clock.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

HI3520 processor (SoC)
Flash memory for storing the DVR firmware
SK hynix RAM
Wi-Fi module of unknown origin. It appears to be connected via USB, or at least that's my suspicion.
VGA and HDMI connectors.
Power converters, as well as contacts for connecting a power button, currently shorted by a jumper

The design is very simple, mainly because the processor handles almost everything; the only external components are the memory (RAM and flash).

A kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

At the bottom right, you can see a footprint for installing another SATA connector.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

The board is designed to accommodate two USB connectors, but the components for connecting the second one haven't been installed.

A kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four cameras: what video surveillance consists of

Installing the hard drive is very simple. All you need is the drive itself and a small Phillips screwdriver.
I didn't have a working 3.5-inch drive handy, so I tried it with a dead one. Installation is straightforward: position the drive, secure it with the four included screws, and plug in the two connectors.

I did have a 2.5-inch drive at home. I'd recommend using one of those, if not for one small issue. The kit includes two small screws, but you can actually secure the drive with only one. There's no standoff or hole for the second screw, and the holes for a 3.5-inch drive obviously don't line up. You'll also need a washer, since the screws are too long for a 2.5-inch drive.

A little about hard drives and choosing one for the DVR.

Calculating the required drive capacity
Drive capacity depends on several factors:
1. How long you need to keep the recordings
2. The number of cameras
3. The maximum recording bitrate
4. How much motion there is in the frame.

The first three are straightforward, but the last one is a bit of a wildcard.
1. Motion affects when the motion detector is triggered, and that depends on its settings. For example, a tree might appear in the frame, and in windy weather your DVR will record continuously.
2. The more motion there is in the frame, the higher the data rate (if Variable bitrate is enabled). For example, with an empty room in the frame, the data rate will be very low. But if the camera is outdoors and it's snowing, you'll get the maximum data rate.

So to start with, it's easiest to calculate the required drive capacity for the worst-case scenario: maximum bitrate and continuous recording. Here's an example.
2048 (recording bitrate) x 4 (number of cameras) x 3600 (seconds in an hour) x 24 (hours in a day) / 8 / 1024 / 1024 = 84 GB.
So even in the worst-case scenario, a full day of recording will take up 84 GB.
In practice, though, you can divide that figure by 3 in most cases, so the 250 GB drive I installed should hold about a week's worth of recordings.

Choosing a drive.
In principle, most drives will work with most DVRs, but low-power, low-heat drives are recommended. So it's best to look at Green-series drives with a spindle speed of 5400 or 5900 rpm.
Special drives for surveillance systems are now available, such as the WD Purple. They're optimized for handling a large number of recording streams, and their power-saving and head-parking algorithms have also been modified.
But that kind of drive is overkill for this DVR; a regular 2.5-inch drive will do.

DVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Power consumption of the DVR and camera
1, 2 DVR with 2.5- and 3.5-inch drives.
3, 4 Cameras, with the IR illumination off and on

DVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Next, I'll go through the DVR software and explain a few things about the settings along the way. I'll put anything I think might be useful in bold.
Apologies in advance for the poor photo quality.

Once the hard drive is installed, turn on the DVR.
The default username is admin, and the password is blank. I think they could at least have set it to 12345, just for appearances.

DVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The initial setup wizard launched automatically. If it doesn't, right-click and select Setup Wizard.
It offers to install the Android or iOS app and shows the system ID for the cloud service. I just skipped this step.
Next, set the time, date, time zone, and language. If you don't want to see a translation worthy of AliExpress, I recommend leaving the language set to English.

DVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR kit with four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Next, we're prompted to configure the local network connection. I somehow forgot to plug in the cable at first, which is why the first screenshot shows a no-connection notification.
Let's configure the connection. The default address is 192.168.11.114. Since my network uses slightly different settings, I changed it to 192.168.100.115.
The device supports getting its settings via DHCP, but I'm used to assigning fixed addresses to all my devices.
This address is needed to connect from a computer. But if you use the dedicated software instead of accessing it through a browser, there's no need to worry—the software will find the recorder on its own.
Configured and saved. All OK.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Connecting the hard drive.
The vast majority of recorders I've come across require the hard drive to be formatted. This is done using the recorder itself. It creates a file index database and some other things, but in any case, it does all the work itself.

Next, you'll get to the hard drive settings menu. The same is often true of video surveillance software: the program creates the file structure.
An example of the file structure on this recorder's drive

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Select our drive—fortunately, there's only one—check the box next to Format, then click the button with the same name and wait a little while (about 25 seconds for a 250 GB drive). That's it; there's nothing else to do here.
The initial recorder setup is now complete, and you can already use it as is.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The recorder comes with the cameras already connected. The video appears almost immediately after you turn them on, and each camera is assigned its own window, which you can change if you like. But if you don't want to dig through the settings, just turn on all the cameras and number them to match their windows. This applies only to this recorder; if you're putting the system together yourself, you'll need to configure it.

1. To open the additional menu, right-click. Here are the menu items you'll see:
Choose the number of windows. We have 4 cameras and no more, so there's no point in this option.
Camera connection settings
Recorder settings
Playback
Save recorded video
Adjust color/brightness
PTZ camera control — not used
Manual recording
Volume — not used
Setup wizard — we've already seen it.
Local network settings
Connect WiFi cameras — they're already connected, and you can't add any more
Shut down or restart

2, 3. Camera connection settings. Everything is already configured. On other recorders, this kind of menu is where you enter the settings for the cameras you want to connect.
4. Camera settings. At first I was pleased, thinking I could finally configure everything. Yeah, right. The only thing you can choose is the camera number. I thought I needed to enter a user account with admin privileges and a non-empty password, but no—the settings are still inactive :( On the other hand, everything is configured pretty optimally.

Camera settings.
These notes apply to most cameras, so they may come in handy.
Bitrate mode — compression mode: Variable or Constant. There are other options too, but not in this review.
In the first mode, we choose the maximum data rate, but the encoding system adjusts the bitrate depending on activity in the frame. In the second mode, the bitrate stays constant. The first option is used more often.
Resolution — resolution. I think this one is self-explanatory, but keep in mind that some cameras can only run at their maximum resolution with a lower frame rate. For example, 2 MP at 25 fps, or 3 MP at 17 fps.
Bitrate — data rate. The higher it is, the better the image quality, but beyond a certain point, quality doesn't improve much. 2 Mbps is more than enough for a 1 MP camera; for 3.2 MP cameras, I set the bitrate to 3–4 Mbps. But this setting depends on how complex the image is, so sometimes you can increase it. Some people immediately set it to something like 16 Mbps. The result is a heavier load on the processor and less recording time, without any improvement in quality.
Quality — image quality. I usually set this to maximum or close to it. This setting can affect processor load, especially in computer-based systems.
Framerate — frame rate. You can sometimes lower it to reduce the load, but I always try to keep it in the 20–25 fps range. This recorder supports a maximum of 15 fps, which isn't much, but is quite enough for most applications.
Encode format — encoding algorithm. H.264 is the most commonly used format these days. H.264+, H.265 and others are also available, but you should always check how they work; sometimes the tried-and-true H.264 is better.

You can also configure the main stream and the substream separately. The substream has a lower data rate, resolution, and quality. It's handy for previews and saving bandwidth, especially when accessing the system from a mobile device. If needed, just switch to the main stream to view the full-quality video.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Basic settings; you can skip these.
Date/time settings. I wanted to change the date display format, but couldn't. I only managed to do it after connecting to the cameras themselves.
VGA output resolution. I set it to 1080p, and it works without any problems.
Hard drive information. The recorder had been recording for a couple of days, and 59 GB was used.
Below is the option to automatically delete old files. In fact, all the recorders I'm familiar with are set to record in a loop by default: when they run out of space, they simply delete the oldest data.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Configure notifications for various errors
Recording schedule. For example, you can set continuous recording from 9 to 17 and motion-triggered recording from 17 to 9. This can be useful sometimes
Configure responses to external sensors; this feature isn't used. Where alarm inputs are available, you can start recording by command
Configure local network connection settings.

A kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

1, 2 DDNS service setup. A very useful feature. It lets you access the DVR without using “cloud services,” which I personally don't like very much.
This is used if you have a dynamic IP address. You register with one of the services, and it gives you a link you can use to “reach” the device. The device itself sends the service information about its current IP address. That way, you can always get to the right place.
3, 4. FTP and PPPoE. I don't use these features and only know them in theory, so to avoid getting anything wrong, I'll skip this part.

A kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

1, 2 Access via a 3G modem. In theory, this lets you access the DVR through a modem, but I can't say how well it works in practice—or whether it works at all. I don't have the equipment to try it.
3. Email notification settings. Very useful if the DVR is located somewhere far away.
4. The DVR's Wi-Fi settings; I left them as they were.

A kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

1. Camera settings — doesn't work
2, 3. Configure the display and position of additional on-screen information.
4. Motion detector
Almost all surveillance systems can record when motion is detected in the frame. The usual settings are sensitivity, selecting an area in the frame, and how long to record before and after motion is detected.
Set the sensitivity by trial and error until it works reliably. Don't just set it to maximum right away, or you'll most likely end up with continuous recording.
Selecting an area in the frame is very handy for masking areas with trees or streets with heavy traffic.
Most DVRs can record before and after motion is detected. Recording after motion is straightforward, but recording before it happens puzzles some people. Here's how it works.
It's very simple: the DVR is always recording, but it doesn't erase the footage immediately—it waits for a while. If motion is detected, it doesn't erase everything, only the footage from a set period (a configurable amount of time) before the motion. That's all there is to it; no clairvoyance involved :)
Unfortunately, this DVR doesn't have that option :((

A kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

You can select an area where the motion detector will be disabled.
By the way, in analog systems the DVR detects motion, while in digital systems the camera does it and tells the DVR when motion is detected. I haven't come across any devices without this feature.

A kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

1. Information about the data streams from the cameras. It seems useful, but isn't very practical, since the data changes quickly and you can only get a rough idea. Systems based on a PC usually handle this more properly.
2. Supposedly controls image rotation; it doesn't work here.

A kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a DVR and four video cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The DVR's live view screen.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

The connection quality was a pleasant surprise. In places where most TV boxes can barely pick up my router, the camera showed 3 out of 4 bars (the indicator in the upper right), and the connection was stable.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

There are two different apps for the phone. One is linked by a QR code in the manual, and the other was on the included disc. The first one has loads of complaints in the comments. I tried it; it seemed to work, but I ended up using the one from the disc.
In short, the app works. I only tested it on the local network, but you can set up remote access if you want—though DDNS is the better way to do it.

You can see what's happening right now, as well as watch recordings.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

Turn the phone sideways and the camera views rotate to fill the screen.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

Next, I tried accessing it through a browser. I tested it with IE, Opera, and Chrome. They all work about the same, though Chrome is a little more stable.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

The cameras connected without any problems. You can choose the main stream or the substream (the default),

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

There are lots of settings, and they even change things, but they don't do much. For example, you can change the bitrate and quality settings, but it makes no difference.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

You can watch recordings, but it works badly—really badly. Then errors started popping up, so browser playback is possible in theory only.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

The app included in the kit, on the other hand, was more stable. Once connected, it found the DVR automatically and asked whether to connect to it.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

You can set the cameras to connect automatically when the program starts. It works well; the cameras connect almost instantly. There’s an image zoom function, though it’s rather awkward to use. You can also connect cameras directly, without the recorder. The program will find them on the local network automatically, which is handy.

Video recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofVideo recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

You can view recordings, and this is implemented reasonably well. By default, recordings are saved to the recorder itself and, via the program, to the computer’s hard drive. It’s better to turn off the latter, though, or you’ll be wondering where all your disk space went.
Playback can be sped up to 8x; the recorder itself supports 32x.
A camera synchronization feature is missing. It would be useful when viewing several cameras with motion detectors enabled.

Video recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofVideo recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

There’s an option to save recordings. It’s a bit clunky, but it works. I wouldn’t select a lot of files at once, though, as the software may crash.

Video recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofVideo recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

The file is exported with the AVI extension. File details:

Video recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

There are plenty of settings, but once again, although you can change them, many don’t actually take effect.

Video recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofVideo recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

Since the cameras can be connected directly to a computer, I tried that too. I was also curious to see what they could do on their own, without the recorder in between.
I got the cameras’ addresses from the software, which found them on startup and offered to connect to them.
With Wi-Fi, the addresses are sequential, but here they’re all over the place: one camera is at 138, another at 11. The one thing they have in common is that neither has a password.
I was very surprised that there isn’t even a basic password. Someone could steal a camera and use it as is—there’s no need to reset a password. Security is nonexistent; this is not how it should be done.

Video recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofVideo recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

As with connecting to the recorder, you’ll be prompted to install ActiveX. If you want the video to display, you’ll have to do it.

Video recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofVideo recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

There are more settings here. For example, you can set the stream bitrate to 4096, and the setting takes effect. You can also set the frame rate to 25, but I couldn’t see any real difference compared with 15.

Video recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists ofVideo recorder and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance consists of

The color and brightness settings are available too, although they worked on the recorder as well.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The recorder didn't have these settings, though. For example, you can disable the switch to black-and-white mode, which can be useful if you want to keep the image in color when the brightness drops.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

There was no privacy mask setting either. This feature lets you block a specific area of the image from being recorded—for example, so security staff can see everything except a particular zone. That zone won't appear in the recording either.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Here I was finally able to set the date to display in the usual format. By default, it shows year/month/day, but we're used to day/month/year.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Wired LAN connection settings.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

DDNS settings. These work on the recorder too, but there they configure access to the recorder itself.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Wi-Fi settings; the password is visible here.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Time synchronization settings.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

Camera information

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

The encoder settings let you choose a custom resolution, though I couldn't figure out why you'd need that.

A kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists ofA kit with a video recorder and four cameras, or what video surveillance consists of

There’s no Russian language option—maybe that’s for the best. But this is the first time I’ve seen Persian O_O.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance actually looks likeDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance actually looks like

Of course, we also need to check the image quality from the cameras.
Basically, all the cameras produce the same image; I just had to adjust the focus on one of them a little.
It’s very hard for me to assess the image quality objectively, since lately I’ve only been working with cameras that have 3.2–4 MP resolution, so to me this looks mediocre. But considering that these cameras are inexpensive and have a resolution of just 1 MP, it may actually be pretty good. The only thing I’d change is the lens—it needs a wider angle.
Footage under artificial lighting

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance actually looks likeDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance actually looks like

Night mode. The cameras’ IR illumination is pretty good, at least comparable to Hikvision cameras. But because of the low resolution, the cameras are probably a little more sensitive.

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance actually looks likeDVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance actually looks like

Next up is a video. For some reason it doesn’t play in every browser; I don’t know why. Original file
Sample night recording, with the path about 15–20 meters away. The illumination is enough to tell that someone is walking there. You won’t be able to tell who, of course, but that’s a problem with all systems like this. If you want good results, you need proper lighting.


The next video was shot during the day. I picked three clips.
Here I’ll answer the question: what lens do you need to see a person’s face or a car’s license plate from my 8th, 11th, or 15th floor?
The answer is: none. You’ll only see a person’s face if they’re looking up, or a car’s license plate if it’s written on the roof. To see what you want, you’ll need to make arrangements with neighbors on the first or second floor.
Of course, you can install a lens with a longer focal length, but you’ll see either the person’s cap or the car’s hood.


The above applies when the person isn’t trying to hide from you.
If they do want to avoid being seen, they’ll take every measure to do so. Below is a clip from a robbery. The stall owner refused to install a dedicated camera, so the footage was recorded by the store’s overview camera.
If you’re setting up surveillance in a store, install one camera facing the entrance so it captures people’s faces as they come in.
It’s best to use a camera with BLC (Back light compensation). In this mode, the camera compensates for backlighting from the subject, and you’ll get a much better view of their face.


While preparing the video for this review, I found a bug in the PC software. When downloading video files to the computer, the software splits them into one-hour chunks. But during the download itself, it splits each file into two more chunks, about half an hour each.
The problem is that 5–6 minutes are missing at the end of each hour. For example, the first video covers 9:00–9:30, and the second 9:30–9:55; the next clip starts at 10:00. The 9:55–10:00 interval is lost.
That’s a serious bug. I don’t know how the developers let it slip through.


I’m also asked which lens is best to choose for a particular task.
First, besides focal length, there are also lenses specifically for high-resolution cameras (1 MP and up). The higher the camera’s resolution, the more demanding it is of the lens’s build quality—more specifically, the quality of its optics. Of course, a seller might pass off a regular lens as a “megapixel” lens, but that’s on the seller’s conscience.

Focal length also depends on the sensor size. For the common 1/3-inch format, here’s a chart:

DVR and four-camera kit, or what video surveillance actually looks like

For other sizes, it's best to use calculators: the first, the second.

A varifocal lens (with an adjustable focal length) would be a good solution, but they cost considerably more. Also, keep in mind that camera sensitivity decreases as the focal length increases. And don't forget the camera's size. So I would still recommend choosing lenses with a fixed focal length.

Keep in mind that the longer the focal length, the more camera shake matters—for example, from the wind.

Summary:
Pros
Relatively decent build quality
Almost ready to use straight out of the box
Good wireless range
VGA and HDMI outputs
Stable operation
Price

Cons
Only one USB port
Software growing pains
No pre-recording triggered by motion detection.
Limited software settings
Not upgradeable

My opinion. The kit is certainly very basic, and 1 MP cameras are the bare minimum for surveillance systems, but its main advantages are the price and how quickly you can get everything up and running—even if you're inexperienced. This kit would work well for a small shop, a private home, or a country house. Ideally, I'd have liked a couple of cameras with 2.8 lenses and a couple with 3.6 lenses, rather than all of them being the same. Image quality is average, but as I wrote, it's hard for me to judge objectively after working with more expensive cameras.
I was disappointed with the software, both as a recorder and on the computer. There aren't many useful settings. Some can be changed by connecting directly to the camera, but that's not very convenient. I was also surprised by the lack of pre-recording (and, consequently, post-recording) before motion detection is triggered, and by a bug that drops the last 5–6 minutes of every hour when backing up recordings.
And the fact that you can connect to the camera over a cable without a password is really bad.

As a simple solution, it's perfectly adequate, but for anything more serious I'd choose a more expensive model from a better-known manufacturer—though it would cost 2–3 times as much. The choice is yours.

The store provided the P2PNVR coupon, which brings the price down to $140. The coupon has been tested.

I hope you found this interesting. As always, I'm looking forward to your questions.
I'd also like to go over the details of installing the cameras, but unfortunately the review has a word limit.

The product was provided by the store for review.
$170.24
Go to store
This page was found when searching for:
2, hi3520 плата wi-fi регистратора, плата сетевой wifi видеорегистратор, плата четырехканального видеорегистратора вайфай моволс, телекамера самодельная, 5, 4, из старого видеокамеры сделать, видеокамера своими руками из сотового телефона, видеорегистратор a1004ns разъёмы на плате, hi 3520 drocv300 cp8161934, 6, из чего состоят видеокамеры, 10, плата видеорегистратора на 4 камеры подключение, 1, rtl8188eus v131, видеорегистраторы streamax принцип работы, что можно сделать из старой видеокамеры, drs_config.dat, видеорегистратор streamax с камерами что входит в комплект, как проверить видео входа на регистраторе без видеокамер, для чего нужны порты на плате видеорегистратора, чем открыть файл видеорегистратора ctv 9204ap dat, комплект видеорегистратор с четырьмя камерами и монитором

Questions and answers

Who is the four-camera surveillance kit suitable for?

The author says it can suit a summer house, private home, or small shop. It is nearly ready to use and can be set up quickly by an inexperienced user.

What image quality do the kit's cameras provide?

The cameras have a resolution of 1 Mp, and the author describes the image quality as average.

What drawbacks did the author find in the recorder?

The software has few settings and lacks pre- and post-recording around motion detection. During backup, the last 5–6 minutes of each hour are missing.


Discounted products


You may be interested in


Discounted products


Support the project

All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!

Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forum

Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.

Log inRegister