/       /       /    CL24, a preview of Atorch’s new electronic load model
Support the project on Patreon


CL24, a preview of Atorch’s new electronic load model

$33.12 - $49.68
Go to store
Those who regularly read my reviews know that I’ve already reviewed several electronic loads from Atorch. In each one, I’ve predicted (or suggested) what the next models might include. But less than six months later, the company has released a new model with the rather strange name CL24. In this preview, I’ll try to figure out what it’s all about.

To keep up with new topics on the blog, I recommend following me on Instagram. I’ll post notifications about every new article there, and might also write about something interesting from time to time: link to my account

You can also subscribe to updates and new articles on the Telegram channel - https://t.me/KirichBlog


So, let’s take it in order. I don’t know why this load is called CL rather than DL. I have a few guesses, but I want to go back to the backstory, and to back up what I say, I’ll link to the relevant reviews.
DL24, the basic model that caught my interest. I wrote right away that one transistor wasn’t enough and the current needed to be balanced, and I also pointed out a few other shortcomings.
DL24M. The next model was noticeably more interesting: four op-amps were added to the main board, along with extra modules whose load current was balanced by the main module. It worked better. But I immediately blew a transistor, because balancing is all well and good, but 150 W through a single transistor is still a lot. I also complained again about the poor performance of CV mode.
DL24MP. I didn’t have this model. The war had just started, so I missed it, but that doesn’t really change the story.
DL24EW. This board came out after the DL24MP, and the key changes from the DL24MP were essentially just the addition of a battery charging mode, moving the display back onto the main board, and replacing Bluetooth with Wi-Fi - review
Both the DL24MP and DL24EW included an important change, again in response to criticism of the previous model: they used four transistors instead of one. So the 600 W model now has 16 transistors with current balancing. The DL24EW’s CV mode was tweaked a little, but they “broke” the encoder: it “slips.” I tried installing the DL24M encoder on it (and most likely on the DL24MP too), and found that it works fine there. What I didn’t like were the small heatsinks on the extra boards and the clumsy implementation of charge control mode, which I wrote about at the time. Some people also complained that they preferred Bluetooth, although personally I like Wi-Fi better.

There seem to have been a few other models, but they never became popular. The same goes for the DL24M, which was taken off sale relatively quickly, even though it had potential.

And just the other day, Atorch released a new model. Let’s see what’s changed and which of our comments the folks at Atorch took into account.

There are four package options, each tailored to a particular use case.
1. Basic: the load, a power supply with an adapter, an external temperature sensor, a cable for connecting to a PC, a cable for linking loads, a USB testing adapter, and leads with alligator clips. This option costs $33.12.
2. Extended: everything in the basic package, plus two modules, one for Bluetooth and one for Wi-Fi. You can connect whichever one you prefer. The only catch is that the module occupies the USB port, so you won’t be able to connect via cable. This one costs a bit more, $38.30, but I think the price increase is reasonable.

These options are well suited to testing power supplies and measuring battery capacity.


3. Everything in the first option, plus a charge control module and an adapter for cylindrical batteries. I remember writing that they’d be better off including a proper single-cell holder instead of this imitation. At $44.29, this seems expensive to me.
4. Everything in the first and third options, plus Bluetooth and Wi-Fi modules—in other words, the full package. At $49.68, the price makes a bit more sense.

These options are primarily intended for battery testing.


The board looks like a hybrid of the regular DL24 and the newer DL24EW. For some reason, they removed the encoder and the option to install additional power modules. It looks like they kept a single power transistor, but for some reason added a whole bunch of op-amps. I’d even say this design is closer to the DL24 than the DL24EW.
They moved the charge module terminals to the left side. I think I wrote in my review that this would be better. But why did they remove the encoder?
It looks like they’ve put something more decent in charge of the brains, though at the very least that’s because there’s no UART-to-USB chip here anymore.



Now let’s see what the specs look like. Here’s the product page, with the key features highlighted.
Load voltage-U: DC1V~200V
Load current-I: =1V,0.01~5A | ≥5V,0.01~25A
Load power-W:U×I≤150W(max)
To avoid pulse damage, the total load power is capped at 60W when the load voltage is ≥120V
Capacity metering range:0~999999mAh
Energy measurement range:0~999999mWh
Applicable power supply: DC12V 1A/PD12V PD voltage trigger power supply (must have a PD charger)
Wiring mode: four-wire system A+ V+ V- A-
Display mode: 2.4 inch TFT color screen
Control operation: 4x button control
Heat dissipation mode: After powering on, the fan will continue to rotate. In the OFF state, when the waiting time is reached, the fan will stop. A 60S standby time can be set in the background. The fan will not stop working while the device is in operation or standby!
Over-voltage protection: support
Overcurrent protection: support
Over power protection: Support
Over-temperature protection: the core temperature exceeds 100 ℃ to stop the load (Not-adjustable)
Time limit discharge: Support
Specified voltage shutdown:Support

Let me explain the highlighted points.
1. The load current is limited to 5 A at input voltages up to 5 V; above 5 V, it can go up to 25 A. I think that’s because it uses a single transistor with relatively high resistance.
2. The power is capped at 150 W, with no way to increase it. A bit of a return to the DL24, although even that had a 1000 W limit.
3. The single transistor is also why the maximum power is limited at high voltage. I talked about this in my video on choosing transistors (did they watch that video too?).
4. Apparently, you can also power the load through the USB port, and it will request 12 V. Neat, but why?

So far, this looks like a downgrade, except perhaps for the ability to power it via USB (which will most likely be occupied by either a cable to the computer or modules).


They also recommend using a two-wire connection to test power supplies for some reason. Though, in principle, why not? You don’t need to measure watt-hours there :)


Now, what about the operating modes?
1. Constant current mode (CC): Supported
2. Constant resistance mode (CR): Supported
3. Constant Power Mode (CP): Supported
4. Constant voltage mode (CV): Supported
5. Battery Internal Resistance Test (BRT)
6. Power test(PT)
7. Cable Internal Resistance Test (CT)

Basically, the same as the DL24EW. But they’ve noticeably reworked the controls, which is a plus. And you can see that, in addition to the modes listed, there are at least CDC and CDCDC, which I covered in my DL24EW review.
There are actually three additional modes:
1.CDC mode test
2.CDCDC mode test
3.CDxn mode test

As I understand it, the third one is a cyclic test with a set number of cycles.




Oddly, the image showing the protection trip screens displays a current of 21 A and power of 185 W, when it would make more sense to show over 25 A and over 150 W.


The main modes. The bottom-right photo shows the cyclic battery test mode, so I was right.


The graph display mode is pretty nice in its own way. Again, you may have seen it in my DL24EW review, but I find graphs on a computer much more informative and convenient, and you can save the results there.



Next come several significant new features (in my opinion).
First, you can combine several loads for simultaneous control. Kudos for that, though the maximum is just two units. What stopped them from supporting at least 8–16, or better yet, 32–64...?
Second, they’ve rewritten the PC software, and it seems to have improved, though you won’t know until you try it.


And third, they’ve not only redesigned the settings menu, but also added two fairly important, if not essential, features:
1. Charging can now stop not only when the set voltage is reached, but also when the current drops (I think I mentioned this in my review).
2. You can now set a pause between charge-discharge cycles (I think I mentioned this too, but I’m not sure).

Well done. If it weren’t for everything I criticized earlier, I might even praise Atorch’s engineers.

By the way, it looks like they kept the same charging control module. Actually, no—it seems they removed the DC-DC converter too, but it’s hard to tell from the photo. And one more thing: the charge-control board had a DC-DC module with galvanic isolation, and it controlled a transistor on the ground side. Why it was there in that case is a mystery to me—I thought it was on the positive rail...




Anyway, this has reminded me of a familiar saying: fix one thing, break another. I think the point is clear: they took a pretty good device, added some useful features, then cut it back to the... tomatoes.

In any case, I sent the manager a message asking whether they'd be willing to send me one of these boards. Maybe I'll even get cheeky and ask for two—I need to see how they work as a pair. I wonder what kind of discount they'll offer...
And a question: does anyone know how the DT24PW and DT24TW modules differ? The price is quite different, but I still haven't figured out what the difference between them is.


That's all from me. I hope this was useful.
$33.12 - $49.68
Go to store
This page was found when searching for:
обзор atorch cl24r, atorch cl24r обзор, torch cl24r обзор , atorch cl24r, atorch cl24r инструкция, Atorch dl 24 -p 180dn ghjlf;b, cl24r или dl24, atorch, atorch cl24, описание atorch cl24r и dl24, atorch cl24r тестер емкости аккумулятора, full package, dl-24p или cl 24, подробный обзор atorch cl24r, отзывы atorch cl24r тестер емкости аккумулятора, standard, аналоги atorch cl24, sttorch cl24w manual, atorch cl24r 150w, https://www.kirich.blog/obzory/izmeritelnoe/1215-cl24-anons-novoy-modeli-elektronnoy-nagruzki-ot-atorch, dt24pw atorch, нагрузки cl24

Questions and answers

What are the stated specifications of the Atorch CL24 electronic load?

It is specified for a load voltage of 1–200 V, current up to 25 A and power up to 150 W. At voltages of 120 V or higher, total load power is limited to 60 W.

What changed in the Atorch CL24 compared with the DL24EW?

The CL24 drops the encoder and the option to install additional power modules; the article suggests it has only one power transistor. New features include stopping charge when current falls and setting a pause between charge and discharge cycles.

Which Atorch CL24 kits are intended for battery testing?

Kits with Bluetooth and WiFi modules are aimed at testing power supplies and measuring battery capacity. Kits that include the charge-control module and cylindrical-cell adapter are primarily intended for battery testing.

Calculate manuallyAll calculators

Discounted products


You may be interested in


Discounted products


Support the project

All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!

Comments16

Comments are published in their original language.

  1. 11 November 2023 01:43#1
    Получается в новой версии, они убрали возможность распределять нагрузку между транзисторами ( так как там всего 1 шт стоит ) но попытались повторить и улучшить функционал 24EW. Кажется,что -  бред какой то... Зарядка по падению напряжения - это по идее круто. Теперь можно будет правильно заряжать аккумуляторы ( литий, свинец ), пусть и крывым модулем для зарядки.  
      Получается, что эта модель ультра домашняя. Кому не нужны доп модули и не смущает работа от одного транзистора, но в тоже время кто хочет получить полный функционал из всех предыдущих версий...
        Лучше бы они режим CV допилили и сделали не программным ( как Вы говорили ) и тест БП ускорили, как и подкрутили точность показометра по тесту сопротивления шнурков.
    +1
    1. 11 November 2023 13:55#2
      Да, это такой скорее "домашний" вариант. В любом случае уже заказал, придет, сделаю обзор.
      Кстати, обратился к менеджеру, дал ссылку на анонс, они после этого значительно дополнили описание товара у себя на странице. Так что положительный эффект от статьи уже есть :)
      +3
      1. 11 November 2023 20:52#3
        хм... Собирался покупать 11.11 DL24 MP\DK ( квадратную ). Теперь похоже придется ждать Вашего обзора. Может эта новая будет лучше чем народная MP ( фиолетовая ).
        0
  2. 11 November 2023 02:38#4
    Как я понял - DT24PW имеет отдельный вход питания и опциональное реле для отключения нагрузки.
    DT24TW таких опций не имеет...
    +1
    1. 11 November 2023 13:57#5
      Тот вариант что с опцией реле стоит дешевле, даже странно. Вы думаете что вторая стоит дороже потому, что у нее внутри преобразователь и она может питаться прямо от входных 8-200 вольт? В принципе да, почитал еще раз описание, похоже что так, в остальном вроде они по сути одинаковы (кроме возможности подключения реле).
      получается что мне подойдет именно вариант где можно подключать реле, так как питание все равно будет от встроенного БП.
      0
  3. 15 November 2023 01:04#6
    Еще заметил, что тут убрали диод по входу на радиаторе как в версии MP.
     В версии EW там стоит предохранитель по типу автомобильной "скобы".  
    Тут видимо его перенесли под вентилятор куда то ?
    0
    1. 15 November 2023 03:53#7
      Здесь явно под радиатором стоит диод как в DL24, даже по трассировке видно что эта часть почти не отличается.
      0
  4. 18 November 2023 15:38#8
    Цитата: kirich
    Здесь явно под радиатором стоит диод как в DL24, даже по трассировке видно что эта часть почти не отличается.
    приветсвую . по рекомендуйте нагрузку для акб. какой оптимальный вариант приобрести. очень понравилась от вашего произвожства. но я только начанающий любитель в этом деле, не распологаю большими средсвами на этом этапе. благодарю за ответ. 
    0
  5. 24 November 2023 13:19#9
    Здравствуйте KIRICH!
    Подскажите пожалуйста отличия DL24EW и CL24!
    Что выбрать не могу определиться. 
    0
    1. 24 November 2023 13:27#10
      Там на самом деле много отличий, EW мощнее, больше ток, но крайне непродуманная схема и программа контроля заряда, я писал об этом в обзоре этой нагрузки.
      CL24 явно доработали, добавили контроль не только напряжения, а и тока, обновили ПО, скорее всего поставили новый микроконтроллер, удобнее управление. Но судя по описанию мощность заметно ниже, а так вроде только до 5 ампер.
      Пока не получу ее в руки, больше вряд ли скажу, это всё только на основании информации со страницы товара. Они там после моего обращения обновили инфу, но в любом случае жду ее, где-то едет.
      0
      1. 24 November 2023 13:40#11
        Спасибо! Возьму CL24.
        0
  6. 6 December 2023 06:31#12
    Взял по совету Кирича 24MP\DK.  Попробую в дальнейшем прикрутить энкодер к корпусу, в верхней части где нибудь на углу.  Подскажите, какой энкодер нужно покупать ? Я там видел разнопиновые есть и сопротивление разное.
    0
    1. 6 December 2023 10:51#13
      Да самый обычный недорогой энкодер, пять контактов (три от энкодера и два встроенная кнопка). Сопротивление у энкодеров не указывают, это не резистор, а по сути просто переключатель.
      0
  7. 15 December 2023 21:56#14
    Здравствуйте Kirich!
    Подскажите, чем отличаются CL24 и CL24R?
    0
    1. 17 December 2023 02:03#15
      При беглом просмотре вижу разницу в вентиляторе и возможность объединения до трех, а не двух устройств.
      0
  8. 17 March 2024 16:44#16
    Здравствуйте, скажите пожалуйста, правильно ли я понимаю что для тестирования аккумуляторов DL24EW/MP - предпочтительнее поскольку сможет работать с током больше 5А при напряжении ниже 5V?
    0

Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forum

Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.

Log inRegister