/       /       /    Universal battery holder with four-wire connection
Support the project on Patreon


Universal battery holder with four-wire connection

$6.6
Go to store
Lately, I’ve been getting more and more different batteries to test, so I decided to pick up a couple of simpler holders to complement my powerful universal holder. Today I’m reviewing two of these simpler—and therefore less expensive—holders.


The thing is, the large holder is designed for currents up to 20–30 A, which is great, but it’s convenient for short-term tests. For endurance testing and other tests that don’t require such high currents, simpler holders will do just fine. But while choosing one and getting some “hands-on experience” with these holders, I found that “not all yogurts are created equal.”

I bought them from the 100MHz store, although most holders like these come from there anyway, whether you buy them on AliExpress, eBay, or Taobao. So I don’t think it makes any difference where you buy one, as long as the price is right.
I paid 6.88 each, plus 1.88 for shipping within China, for a total of $15.62 for the pair, plus a separate fee for the forwarding service.
There are various options on AliExpress, but this particular model costs $25 each. Maybe I didn’t look hard enough, but I’ll explain below why I bought this one.

The holders arrived in a combined shipment without even a bag; they were just loose in the box.


No complaints about the appearance. They come fully assembled (there’s also a kit version), the wires are secured with cable ties, and everything is neat.


As I mentioned, these holders come in different versions, with different case designs and contact types. For example, the model reviewed here is available in 5 A and 10 A versions; I got the more powerful one.
But the case design makes a much bigger difference. This model has no side protrusions or walls, which makes it much more convenient to use.
I once wrote about this in a review and even showed a video demonstrating how much side walls can get in the way. That’s why I bought this particular type. The composite photo below shows various options from 100MHz. You can see that only the BS-3S has this design, apart from the aluminum one, which belongs to a different category.


The problem with inserting a battery into a holder like this looks roughly as shown in the video. Obviously, it’s partly a matter of getting used to it and so on, but the problem is still there. One user solved it with spacers, though.



The side walls were covered with protective film, so I peeled it off right away to keep it out of the way.


A comparison with the “big brother.”


The manufacturer’s name and the sizes of compatible batteries are marked on the side. The list is a little odd: 34, 44, 49, and 65. All are clear except 49, which should be 50—for example, for the 14500 form factor. In practice, though, it makes absolutely no difference.


The wires are already soldered on. They’re very flexible, stranded, and have silicone insulation. The power leads are 16AWG (1.3 mm²), and the sense leads are 20AWG (0.5 mm²).


Even these wires push the movable part out of position, so it sits raised when there’s no battery in the holder and is constantly pulled slightly toward the positive contact.


The contacts provide a proper four-wire connection, meaning they make contact with the battery terminals themselves. I explained how this works in my previous review.
The negative contact is spring-loaded. The sense contacts also have a slightly different design: in the more powerful holder, they not only have their own springs but can also rotate. Here they have additional springs too, but are fixed in place.


Unfortunately, things weren’t quite as smooth as I’d hoped. The contacts are notched, but on one of the holders the positive contact has noticeably smaller notches—I’d even say it’s almost smooth. It’s hard to see in the photo, but the smoother one is on the left and the normal one is on the right.


The previous issue was the manufacturer’s fault, but the next one came down to my own carelessness.
The positive contact is 10–11.5 mm across (depending on its shape), which would be fine, except that some batteries have a positive terminal only 8 mm across, protected by an insulator. As a result, you can’t use a battery like that without modifying either the holder or the battery.
Another option is to insert the battery with reversed polarity. The negative contact is 7.8 mm in diameter (it’s round) and fits the battery’s positive terminal perfectly.

The annoying thing is that the 5 A version would actually have worked for me too, especially since its contacts are slightly smaller in diameter. But, as always, I decided to “get one with some headroom”...


That was the end of the bad news; the good news started here :)
The holder can clamp the full range of common battery sizes.
1. You can even clamp a CR2032 coin cell
2. It also holds an 18650 perfectly
3. When I installed an 18650 battery, I noticed there was still some room to spare lengthwise.
4. I tried a 21700 battery, and it fits too. The difference is that you have to move the sliding part all the way back and insert the battery while pressing it against the holder’s negative contact. With the other sizes, you insert the battery first, then clamp it with the sliding part, which is held in place by the teeth on the holder.


I didn’t include any tests or measurements in the review, but I’ve already used both holders and can say that my concerns about the shallow notch on the positive contact of one of them were unfounded—everything works perfectly. The problem with its large size remains, though. I’m still deciding what to do: file it down to a diameter of 7.7–7.9 mm, or resolder the wires and install the battery the other way around. The second option seems more sensible, but it could cause confusion about the battery’s orientation if I switch between the large holder and the smaller ones.

The bonus is that you can also test 21700 batteries. I hadn’t expected that, so I was pleasantly surprised. I later noticed that the stated maximum diameter is 32 mm and the maximum length is 72 mm.

Now I just need to buy some connectors and modify the electronic loads a little so they can all be connected with a single connector instead of a bunch of wires. After that, I think I’ll carry on with various endurance tests :)
According to the seller, the two holders weigh 320 grams, i.e. 160 grams each.

That’s all from me. I hope you found the review useful.
$6.6
Go to store
This page was found when searching for:
Струбцина холдер-держатель 18650/21700, четырехпроводной зажим для обнаружения 18650,, держатель для подключения аккумулятора 18650 к измерителю сопротивления, держатель четырехпроводный 21700 для измерителя, четырёхпроводной холдер 18650, блок для установки 4 lion 21700, 4-проводная подставка для тестирования емкости аккумулятора, тестовый кронштейн для батарей 18650,26650,21700,aa,aaa, 4-проводной тестовый стенд,, держатель батареи 18650 для измерений параметров, как самому сделать четырехпроводной холдер для теста аккумуляторов, самодельный холдер 21700, https://www.kirich.blog/obzory/izmeritelnoe/732-universalnyy-derzhatel-akkumulyatorov-imeyuschiy-chetyrehprovodnoe-podklyuchenie, крепление четырехпроводное для 18650, плюсовой контакт держатель жала te100, держатель аккумулятора 21700 силовой, держатель аккумулятора 32700, универсальный держатель аккумулятора, держатель аккумуляторов для тестирования, 1, 7, холдер для аккумуляторов своими руками, держатели 21700, держатель 21700, держатель для тестирования аккумулятора, power wall 21700 держатель батареи 21700, держатель аккумуляторов, держатель аккумуляторов 18650, держатель 18650, держатель для тестирования аккумуляторов

Questions and answers

Which batteries fit the BS-3S holder?

The article shows it holding cells from CR2032 and 18650 up to 21700. For a 21700, the movable section must be pulled fully back, and the cell inserted while pressing against the negative contact.

How does the BS-3S four-wire connection work?

The contacts connect directly to the battery terminals. The power wires are 1.3 mm² (16AWG), and the measurement wires are 0.5 mm² (20AWG).

Does the BS-3S work with batteries that have an insulated positive terminal?

Not always: the holder’s positive contact is 10–11.5 mm wide, while some batteries have an 8 mm contact covered by an insulator. The author considers modifying the contact or inserting the battery with reversed polarity.

The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Tools

Calculate manuallyAll calculators

Discounted products


You may be interested in


Discounted products


Support the project

All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!

Comments2

Comments are published in their original language.

  1. Роман
    16 April 2019 00:11#1
    Здравствуйте Андрей. Спасибо за ваш труд.  Хотелось бы узнать Ваше мнение о данном варианте стенда для тестирования цилиндрические аккумуляторов  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGuzAScOtGQ   
    0
    1. 16 April 2019 01:43#2
      Посмотрел.
      Не совсем правильный вариант, хотя и хороший. Если Вы внимательно читали этот и предыдущий обзор держателя, то заметили, что я акцентировал внимание на правильном четырехпроводном подключении, когда контакты соединяются через клемму аккумулятора, в видео контакты соединяются раньше и влияет падение на контакте  клемма-аккумулятор, причем в двойном виде так как такой контакт на обоих клеммах.
      Конечно это мелочь, но формально даже обозреваемый вариант считается более корректным.

      Ну и мне было не совсем понятно, зачем автор измерял сопротивление проводов, когда при четырехпроводном подключении это просто не имеет смысла.
      0

Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forum

Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.

Log inRegister