/       /       /    Novatek-Electro PEF-320 Phase Selector
Support the project on Patreon


Novatek-Electro PEF-320 Phase Selector

1150₴ (около $42)
Go to store
At the end of February, I reviewed the PEF-301 phase selector relay. As I wrote then, I’ve been using these relays for a long time and am completely happy with how they work. But now a newer version, the PEF-320, has landed on my desk. One of the key differences is that it can’t control external contactors. As always, I’ll go into more detail in the review.


To be honest, at first I was skeptical about the new version. It costs more than the PEF-301 and can’t control external contactors. But after taking a closer look and thinking through possible use cases, I realized that the manufacturer was quite right to release a model like this.
In this review, I’ll try not only to show you this model, but also to compare it with the PEF-301.

The link in the title goes to the Ukrainian version of the site. For readers in Russia, the link is different.

The relay comes in a branded box. The insert inside holds it firmly in place, so it doesn’t rattle around.


The package is as simple as it gets: the relay and a manual with instructions.


The user manual, wiring diagram, and warranty card are all available at this link as a PDF.


To save you downloading the manual just to check the specs, I’ll reproduce them here.


Like the PEF-301, it comes with a stated 10-year warranty. Unfortunately (or perhaps fortunately), I haven’t been able to verify this claim: even the first relay I bought about 10 years ago is still working fine, and it’s certainly not been kept in ideal conditions.


But let’s get back to the subject of this review.


The first key difference from the PEF-301 is the size. The previous model took up 4 spaces in the panel (70 mm), while this one is exactly half as wide: 2 modules (36 mm).
There are four terminals at the top for the three phases and neutral. The four-terminal block at the bottom is for the output phase and neutral, though I’ll come back to the latter a little later. The terminal blocks are exactly the same as on the PEF-301. They clamp wires up to 2.5 mm² securely; you can squeeze in a 4 mm² wire if you really have to, but it’s better not to.
There are ventilation slots at the top and bottom.


There’s a wiring diagram on the side. It’s a small detail, of course, but a useful one—the PEF-301 didn’t have one.


Here’s a side-by-side comparison with the PEF-301 and a pair of circuit breakers. I should point out that the printing on the PEF-320’s case is a little fainter. In my view, this could make the labels around the "knobs" hard to read when working somewhere with poor lighting. It’s a bit of a nitpick, but the labels on the PEF-301 are easier to read, especially when the two are side by side.
To be fair, the same goes for the Schneider circuit breakers to the right.


The rail mounting mechanism has been changed, and a spring has been added, so you can simply snap the relay into place.


The indicators, their number, and the functions of the controls are identical to those on the PEF-301; they’ve simply been rearranged to fit the smaller front panel. I’ll give it a plus for the marks on the adjustment knobs, though. On the PEF-301, you had to look closely to see the knob position because the mark was black on black. In fact, even in the photo it’s hard to tell what it’s set to.
Also, the PEF-320 has light guides on the front panel rather than the "bare" LEDs used on the PEF-301. I think this, along with the different design of the adjustment knobs, makes the front panel more resistant to damage.

Since the controls work just like those on the PEF-301, I’ll repeat the revised description from my previous review.
Indicators
Three green LEDs show which relay is currently active. There are four possible states: 1, 2, 3, and 0.
One red LED indicates an input fault and counts down the delay before switching back once the voltage has returned to normal.

The controls consist of four variable resistors:
Umax - Sets the maximum allowable input voltage threshold; adjustment range: 230–280 V.
Umin - Sets the minimum allowable input voltage threshold; adjustment range: 160–210 V.
Тr - Delay before switching back to the previous phase. For example, if the relay switches from phase 1 to phase 2, then when the voltage on phase 1 returns to normal, it won’t switch back immediately, but only after the set delay. If you turn the knob all the way to the right (infinity), it won’t switch back automatically. Adjustment range: 5–200 sec + infinity.
Тon - How long the output stays on after an emergency shutdown. This function is needed if the relay is connected to equipment that shouldn’t be powered up immediately after being switched off, such as refrigerators. Adjustment range: 1 s–10 min.



But personally, I'm of course much more interested in taking it apart. I was especially curious to see how the manufacturer had packed the innards of the PEF-301 into a case half the size.
The relay is relatively easy to disassemble:
first, remove the bottom section; it's held by clips.
Then pull the board out about 5 mm and slide it back in.
After that, the adjustment knobs will stick out by the same 5 mm, so you can pull them out one at a time.
Once the knobs are out, remove the board.


Yes, the layout is clearly denser, but in some ways it's actually a little neater.


Inside, you can see capacitors, a voltage converter IC, and components covered in heat-shrink tubing. I later found that the tubing hides a diode and a 380 Ω resistor. As far as I can tell, the resistors limit the capacitors' charging current and also serve as fuses, since there are no fuses on the board.


All the components are mounted on three boards. The main board contains the power section and power supply; the left board (they're labeled) has the microcontroller, measurement circuits, and one of the relays; and the right board has just three trimmer resistors.


The central board also has the relay driver transistors and other small components.


The layout is really dense, but overall it actually turned out a bit neater and more solid than the PEF-301.


There are protective slots near the input and output terminals, as well as between the relay contact pads. They clearly didn't skimp on solder, so no complaints here—almost...


I do have a question about the labeling of the output terminal blocks. The wiring diagram clearly says to use the outer terminals, but in the photo above you can see that the terminals are used in pairs. In my opinion, using them in pairs is actually a big advantage, since you can connect two loads without any intermediate components.
There may be some nuances I'm missing, but I think they could either have put the L and N labels between the terminals, or labeled each terminal individually: L L N N. The important thing is to make it clear that the terminals with the same label are connected together, since people only look at the diagram when installing it, while they read the text description when "everything has already burned out".


Omron relays are used here: G2RL-14-E with 24 V coils. As far as I can tell, this has nothing to do with the design or any special features of the relay itself; they simply use either these or Fujitsu relays.


There is no structural difference between the relays.


But as far as I can tell, there's a slight difference in their specs: Fujitsu specifies 50,000 cycles, while Omron specifies 30,000.


The specified contact resistance is no more than 100 mΩ. According to the datasheet, it's measured with a DC current of 1 A and a source voltage of 5 V.
I ran a similar test. First, I measured a voltage drop of 1.6 mV across one relay and 3.6 mV across another. I tested the third relay as well because the test was performed with the unit assembled.
I measured the total drop between the first and third phases—the shortest and longest paths, as far as I can tell from the schematic—at about 6 and 12 mV, respectively.
The calculated contact resistance came out well below the specified value, at about 1.6–3.6 mΩ. The total voltage drop across the whole device at 16 A would be 96–192 mV, with power losses of 1.5–3 W. The PEF-301 gave roughly the same results.


But the actual voltage drop across the contacts is much lower.
The reason is that, due to the limitations of the test setup and equipment, I first energized the relay so it closed the contacts, and only then applied current. Under load switching, the results will be better because the current helps break through the oxide layer. The datasheet specifies only the current and voltage values, not the test method, so I’ve included both results.
The photo shows the same contacts, the same current, in the same sequence.


The side boards are soldered in place, but I was really curious, so I had to get out the soldering iron and partially disassemble the unit.


The second key change is that the PEF-301 used a capacitive dropper power supply, but apparently fitting it into a box this small was quite a challenge, so the unit is now powered by an LNK305PN PWM controller LNK305PN.
There are filter capacitors nearby. At first I was going to complain because they’re rated for 400 V, but then I took a closer look and found that they’re connected in series, so technically the input has a 2.35 µF, 800 V capacitor.
The thing is, Power Integrations controllers are quite tolerant of high input voltage. For example, the TOP series in one of my power supplies withstood 380 V at the input, with the controller simply shutting down. Obviously, this caused problems for the input capacitors, but I wasn’t expecting them to handle conditions like that.


This is a different controller series, and what’s more, it’s essentially just a step-down converter with a high-voltage input. Unfortunately, I couldn’t find anything in the datasheet about OVP protection, so I can’t say how it will behave with a high input voltage. Still, having some headroom in the input capacitor is a good thing.


I didn’t redraw the circuit, but it doesn’t look much different from the one in the datasheet. The only exception is that C4 has been replaced with an X2 capacitor, which, in my opinion, slightly reduces reliability.
The converter gets its power from terminals L1–L3 through diodes, forming a three-phase half-wave rectifier.


Another change, though not a major one, is that the voltage-divider resistors are now SMD. I have no complaints about that either: they’re installed three in series, and since the maximum voltage for a 1206 package is 200 V, the divider is rated for up to 600 V. Otherwise, the circuit design is identical to the PEF-301.


Let’s move on to the tests.
When voltage is applied, the red LED lights up first. If the voltage is within range, the delay countdown starts, after which the corresponding relay switches on. As a reminder, input L1 has priority.


My wattmeter isn’t very accurate, of course, but it reads a power consumption of 1.1 W; the datasheet specifies 1.2 W.
Out of curiosity, I left it on for about an hour and then measured the temperature inside. In my case, the hottest component was the first relay, which controls line L1.


At an input voltage of about 14.5 V, the device tries to start, with the LED flashing. At 16 V, it reaches normal operating mode. There’s not much point in this voltage range, of course, but it certainly won’t do any harm.


The threshold accuracy also raised no concerns. First, I checked the undervoltage protection.
1. Setpoint: 160 V; switches off at 160 V and back on at 167 V.
2. Setpoint: 180 V; switches off at 180 V and back on at 187 V.


Overvoltage protection.
1. Setpoint: 250 V; switches off at 250 V and back on at 245 V.
2. Setpoint: 255 V; switches off at 255 V and back on at 250 V.


Its response to voltage dips is also identical to the PEF-301. As before, I ran the test with a light bulb and a low-power isolation transformer, which caused the voltage to sag from an initial 205 V to about 155–160 V when the relay switched on.


As with the other threshold settings, the delay here was 12 seconds, but sometimes the relay behaved rather oddly: with the settings unchanged, the delay would sometimes occur and sometimes not.
This caught my attention, so I decided to check with the manufacturer just to be sure. Here’s the reply I got:
0.02 s switching occurs if the voltage suddenly drops 60 V below the lower threshold. If the drop is gradual and small, switching takes 12 s.

So it’s affected not only by the voltage drop itself, but also by how quickly the voltage falls. In my experiment, I simply hit the edge of the fault-detection threshold. In any case, this is normal behavior.


Simulating the loss and restoration of voltage on the first and second phases, just as with the PEF-301.



The demonstration of a sweep across the entire range took a little longer because the voltage range extends further downward. The relay also responds precisely as it should when the voltage crosses the thresholds.


This time, I captured the switching waveforms for two switching scenarios.
1, 2. Switching from the first input to the second when voltage is removed from the input. Switching usually took about 60 ms, but sometimes stretched to 80 ms. The output usually switched on at the start of the positive half-cycle, though at least once in four tests it switched on during the negative half-cycle.
3, 4. Switching back to the healthy input, initiated entirely by the device. In every test, the transition took one half-cycle, and it was always the negative one.


The same tests, but switching from the first to the third input (the second was de-energized). Everything I said above applies just as well here.


After checking everything I could get my hands on, here’s the main takeaway: the key differences between the PEF-301 and PEF-320 come down to three things:
1. Size: the PEF-320 is exactly half as wide, which matters a lot in small electrical panels.
2. Power supply: the PEF-301 uses capacitive droppers, while the PEF-320 uses a PWM controller. It’s hard to say which is better.
3. The PEF-301 can control external contactors; the PEF-320 cannot.

Everything else is cosmetic, and I ran the tests only to confirm that. To be fair, though, the adjustment knobs on the PEF-320 are more convenient—or, more precisely, easier to read.

There are a few minor shortcomings, too. I’d like to see:
1. Slightly higher-contrast lettering, like on the PEF-301, for example.
2. Markings on the case for all four output terminals, not just the outer ones. Since they’re connected on the circuit board, as far as I understand, they can all be used.
3. I’d still consider adding a fuse before the PWM controller—or, more precisely, between the rectifier diode junction and the rest of the circuit. I don’t see why there wouldn’t be room for one.

Basically, this is still the same time-tested PEF-301, and I’m glad the manufacturer didn’t make it worse when redesigning the enclosure, as sometimes happens.

As for how I plan to use it, this relay will control the power supply for a video surveillance system at one of my sites, again as an automatic transfer switch. The situation is simple: a house outside the city, an unstable grid, a generator, and some other power source (I don’t know what yet). The security staff switch over manually, but sometimes they might forget. Since the load is small, external contactors aren’t needed, and all the sources share a common neutral. A UPS will be installed downstream of the relay to handle switching and other interruptions.

That’s all from me. I hope you found it useful.
1150₴ (около $42)
Go to store
This page was found when searching for:
пэф 320 схема, 1, 2, схема подключения пэф 320, форумхаус пэф 320 отзывы, пеф 320, новатек электро дата виготовлення, пэф 320, пэф 320 инструкция, пэф 320 форум, аналог пэф

Questions and answers

How does the Novatek-Elektro PEF-320 differ from the PEF-301?

The PEF-320 takes 2 modules (36 mm) instead of 4 modules (70 mm), uses a PWM controller in its power supply, and cannot control external contactors. The PEF-301 can control them.

What are the PEF-320 adjustment ranges?

Umax is adjustable from 230 to 280 V, and Umin from 160 to 210 V. Tr can be set from 5 to 200 seconds or to infinity; Ton ranges from 1 second to 10 minutes.

What does the author plan to use the PEF-320 for?

The author plans to use it to supply a video surveillance system and switch automatically between sources at a country house. The load is small and the sources share a neutral, so external contactors are not needed.


Discounted products


You may be interested in


Discounted products


Support the project

All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!

Comments3

Comments are published in their original language.

  1. Внутренний транзит (дублирование) клемм L и N в изделии и отсутствие маркировки на корпусе.
    Причина по которой убрана информация на маркировке банальна. Мы получили негативный опыт (по другим изделиям) с данным решением, а именно многие клиенты видя свободную клемму N, прикручивали к клемме проводник от другой нагрузки. Тем самым организовывали транзит через наше изделие и превышение токовых характеристик. Как следствие - выгорание транзита и получение нами рекламации.

    С уважением,
    гл. технолог ООО "Новатек-Электро"
    Александр Синчук.
    +4
    1. 15 May 2020 19:13#2
      Спасибо за ответ.
      Жаль, пользователи такую идею загубили :(
      Но в принципе можно продублировать клемму L, а ноль оставить одним, так как ноль все равно часто идет на гребенку, а вот фазу от второй нагрузки подключить некуда.

      Тогда сразу попутно два вопроса:
      1. Функцию предохранителей выполняют резисторы последовательно с выпрямительными диодами?
      2. Входной фильтрующий конденсатор Х2, он ведь получается сейчас ограничивает максимальное входное напряжение, так как остальные компоненты более высоковольтные.
      +1
    2. 16 May 2020 03:26#3
      Сейчас подумал насчет дополнительных выходов, да, Вы правы, если насчет земляного я ответил раньше, то насчет фазного тоже проблема, ведь получается надо тогда ставить два АВ. Ну и собственно остается проблема некомпетентного электрика который может использовать выходы как транзит...

      0

Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forum

Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.

Log inRegister