/       /       /    BASEN 18650 3500mAh batteries, unprotected and protected
Support the project on Patreon


BASEN 18650 3500mAh batteries, unprotected and protected

$10.38 (за 2шт)
Go to store
Apparently, after reading some of my battery reviews, one store decided to send me some of its batteries to test. I was curious to see what they were like, so I agreed and got back to testing.
Inspection, tests, graphs, comparisons and conclusions—as usual.


A manager from the Basen store got in touch and offered to send me several types of batteries. I replied that I could give them a try, especially since this would let me compare them with branded batteries that I reviewed not long ago: review.
Some time later, I received the package. I hadn't originally planned to post a photo of it, but I was pleasantly surprised by the packaging: not only were there two envelopes, but the batteries themselves were packed together in a box in a way that made them almost impossible to damage.


There were six types of batteries, but I'll probably do five reviews, since today's one covers two types at once—they're essentially the same batteries.


Why was I interested in batteries under this brand in the first place, when AliExpress is full of all kinds of Liitokala, VariCore and others? The thing is, these are advertised as having their stated capacity, and when I looked for information about them, I also came across some good reviews on vaping forums. Since this is my first time seeing them, I thought the review might be useful.

First up are the O35 batteries. The name apparently means Orange and 3500 capacity—link. The price depends on the quantity: one costs $6.38, while 10 cost $48.08, or $4.81 each. Shipping to us was free. The store also offers a $2 discount for every $15 spent, so you can save quite a bit.

They come in cardboard packaging, with a plastic storage case inside.


They look very neat, but are much more "flashy" than branded batteries. For example, the battery specifications are printed right on them, along with a code for checking authenticity and a barcode.
There's also a matrix code visible under the heat-shrink wrap, like on many branded batteries.
There seems to be a safety vent under the positive terminal. The positive terminal is also recessed quite deeply, so keep that in mind—not every device will work with these batteries.

The terminals have a very unusual shape: the positive one is triangular, and the negative one has a circular indentation.


I was really curious about what these batteries actually were. They seemed vaguely familiar, so I started digging around on a well-known site and found an exact copy of the ones I'm reviewing. They match in terms of:
positive terminal shape
indentation on the negative terminal
three small stripes on the negative terminal
capacity

After that, I tried to find the original, but all my searches led only to the hypothetical LG18650M34. I say hypothetical because I couldn't find any information about them. Indirect evidence suggests these use LG cells, but all the ones I know have a different terminal shape.


Dimensions and weight, and right away, a comparison of the first and second batteries.


The capacity measurement is closest to the results from the well-known Opus and Liitokala chargers, since my charger also reads a little high.
The batteries initially had about 30–35% charge. A "conditioning" run with a discharge current showed a capacity of 3500mAh.


The following specifications were listed for the Vapcell batteries:
Model: NCR18650 3400mah 10A
Size: 18.3*65.3mm
Nominal voltage: 3.60V
End-of-charge voltage: 4.20V
End-of-discharge Voltage: 2.5V
Typical Capacity: 3400mAh (0.2C discharge)
Min capacity: 3300mAh (0.2C discharge)
Weight: Max: 49g
Internal resistance: Max: 25mOhm AC 1kHz
Standard Charge: 1000mA, CCCV 100mA cut-off
Quick Charge Current: 2000mA
Max Continuous Discharge Current: 10A

When I ran the tests, I didn't yet know the specifications listed above, so I charged them using slightly different settings: a charge current of 0.5C, with cutoff when the current dropped to 50mA. In practice, this doesn't change much; it affects service life more than capacity.
A full charge takes 2 hours and 42 minutes, which is quite normal for high-capacity batteries. By the way, I’ve seen these batteries described as high-drain, but that’s not the case. They’re high-capacity batteries, so the emphasis is on capacity, not discharge current.


Vapcell was more honest about the capacity, listing 3400 mAh, which is about what I measured at the discharge current. To be fair, brands often label their batteries by grade rather than capacity. For example, the Samsung 35E has an actual capacity of 3400 mAh. But let’s not get bogged down in the details. I tested it in five modes: 0.2C, 0.5C, 1C, 2C, and 10 A, taking C to be 3400 mAh.


Temperature rise at 2C and 10 A.


The second battery produced very similar results, which is encouraging and points to a well-established manufacturing process.



Of course, the results don’t mean much on their own. They’re more interesting when compared with better-known models:
Samsung INR18650-35E — red
LG INR18650-MH1 — orange
LG INR18650-MJ1 — yellow
LG INR18650-M36 — green
Panasonic NCR18650G — light blue
Panasonic NCR18650BD — blue
Sanyo NCR18650GA — purple
BASEN O35 — black

First, a comparison at 0.2C, or 680 mA.
In my opinion, the O35 did quite well. It was beaten only by the M36, MJ1, and Panasonic NCR18650G.


But the maximum-current test is much more interesting. In this case, the current was 10 A.
The Samsung 35E pulled slightly ahead, along with the earlier M36, MJ1, and Panasonic NCR18650G. But a fair comparison would really only be with the MJ1 and possibly the Samsung 35E, since the others were tested at lower currents: 5 A for the M36 and 6.9 A for the NCR18650G.


The battery’s resistance is about 20 mΩ, roughly the same before testing, after conditioning, and after all the tests.



The second battery has almost the same claimed specifications, at least in terms of capacity: 3500 mAh. It’s also rated for a continuous discharge current of 10 A — link. There’s some confusion here: the manufacturer’s website lists it as the BS186A, while the battery itself is marked BS186A Pro. However, the website says the BS186A Pro is an unprotected model...

These were the only batteries that didn’t come in a cardboard box.


Information from the manufacturer’s website.


The batteries are also marked 3500 mAh, with a current rating of up to 10 A. There’s a protective sticker with a code, but it... is under the heat-shrink tubing :)
The positive terminal has a raised button, which is typical of protected batteries, since this isn't the battery's original terminal but an add-on over it.
An analogue of a matrix code can be seen under the heat-shrink tubing, and the codes differ from one another.


Dimensions and weight.
Judging by its length, this battery would more accurately be called an 18700. But that's another typical feature of protected batteries: they're longer because of the protection board and the raised button.


The initial “warm-up run” produced the same results as the unprotected batteries, around 3500 mAh.


There's no datasheet again, but the product page has a graph showing results at currents of 2, 4, 8, and 10 A.


First, though, I checked the protection cutoff current using an EBC A10H electronic load in auto-test mode.


Unfortunately, no matter how hard I tried, I couldn't get more than 6.3 A. The second battery did even worse, at around 6.1 A.


Charging took a little longer than with the regular version, due to the protection circuit.


Tests at 0.2C, 0.5C, 1C, and 5.5 A.
The 5.5 A test didn't go well. Near the end, the battery's protection started tripping. I resumed the test several times (the load supports this), but eventually I just got tired of it, so this is the graph I ended up with.


There was a small hiccup with the second sample: I lost the data for the 1C test, so this graph uses data from the previous sample. Here, though, I limited the discharge current to 5.1 A, and the test completed properly.


Since the discharge current was relatively low, the batteries only heated up to 50 degrees. The first one is on the left, shown at the moment the protection first tripped; the second is on the right, at the end of the 5.1 A test.


Here are the comparative results at 0.2C and 1C for the BS186A Pro batteries (protected, blue on the graph) and O35 batteries (unprotected, red on the graph).
At low current, the results are identical. At 1C, the capacity in mAh is the same, but the protection board reduces the capacity in Wh, which is clearly visible in the lower graph as well.


Measuring the resistance of protected batteries isn't really valid, but I decided to do it anyway, using the same three checkpoints: before testing, after the “warm-up,” and after all the tests.
The previous batteries measured 20 mΩ; these are around 45 mΩ. In other words, the protection circuit adds about 25 mΩ.


Now, about the protection circuit and how similar the batteries are.
I decided to open up one battery after all—or rather, not the battery itself, of course, just its wrapping, so I could remove the protection board.
After removing the outer wrap, I got to the protection code, since the protected version of the battery was the one I had the most questions about.


But checking the code on the website showed that everything was fine: “Your batteries are genuine, bro. Enjoy using them.”


Then I decided to see what was on the protection board, because for some reason I was absolutely sure they'd installed just one transistor instead of two (it happens).
But after removing the entire casing and getting to the protection board, I found that there were indeed two transistors on it. In this case, they're dual 8205A transistors, each with a resistance of 25 mΩ, connected in parallel. So the configuration is 2S2P, which is why we got the 25 mΩ shown above. Everything checks out.

A small plus for the manufacturer: the board has a protective pad on the negative terminal instead of bare PCB copper, which of course makes the connection more reliable.


A little about why the number of transistors matters. This protection chip detects current from the voltage drop across the transistor's open channel, not across a shunt—it uses the transistors as current-sensing shunts. If you replace them with others that have lower resistance, the protection cutoff current will increase too.
The DW01 has a protection trip voltage of 150 mV. With the resistance of the MOSFETs, that gives us 0.15�.025=6 A

I think they simply used different transistors from the ones originally intended, which is why we get 6 A instead of 10.


After that, I just got carried away.


I couldn't tear off the positive contact; it was welded on solid. Well, I did manage to pry it up slightly, just enough to see that it has a triangular shape inside.
The negative contact is exactly the same as on the “unprotected” O35, which makes it clear that these are two identical batteries.

It also turned out that the protective matrix code is printed directly on the battery, and it's different on all four cells.


Thanks to one of the readers, I found out that these are Panasonic NCR18650BG cells used in Tesla car batteries. I found a listing on a Chinese site for these exact cells, and the photos match.



And now, the conclusions.
The batteries performed like branded cells. Though why say “like”? They are most likely genuine branded cells. Unlike the same “Litokala” cells, the manufacturer here didn't try to imitate a brand, but simply marked them with its own branding from the start.
But in my opinion, this is still a repackager, just like Vapcell; the only difference is probably the quality of the source cells. As for the claimed specs, I've often seen statements along the lines of: manufacturers like these select batteries and then wrap them in their own heat-shrink tubing. This is said about Vapcell, Basen, and similar brands. Apparently, these people don't understand that nobody is going to sort batteries, for at least two reasons:
1. It's expensive
2. It takes a long time, since you have to measure capacity at the very least.

Of course, you could just measure resistance, but in my opinion that kind of sorting tells you nothing if the batteries are the same type and are genuine.

Based on the test results, I'd say the cells themselves are good and perform on par with LG and Samsung. But there are some issues, mostly not with the cells themselves, but with the claims versus what we actually got.
O35 - the specs are overstated. These are actually 3400 mAh cells, with a maximum continuous current of 10 A. In my opinion, though, they'll work just fine at the stated 12 A. They will probably handle 30 A for short periods, but with a significant voltage drop, reduced capacity delivered, and shorter service life.
BS136A Pro - The same goes for capacity, both in mAh and Wh. Current is limited by the protection circuit: in reality, the batteries deliver only 6–6.2 A briefly, not 10 A, and 5.1 A continuously (1.5C).

That's all for today. I hope this was useful. I discovered some new batteries, and I'm curious to hear what you think: who is the actual manufacturer of these cells?
$10.38 (за 2шт)
Go to store
This page was found when searching for:
аккумулятор basen 18650 3500 mah, с защитой, https://www.kirich.blog/obzory/akkumulyatory/830-akkumulyatory-basen-18650-3500mach-obychnye-i-zaschischennye, basen 18650 3500 mah 3,7 v, 18650 basen 3500 мач 30а, basen 18650 3500mah высокотоковый аккумулятор, аккумулятор незащищенный 18650 u=3,7в 3500мач li ion basen 30а, акб 18650 basen отзывы, basen 40a 18650 тест, basen 40a 18650 для меха, basen bs186h, basen 18650 3500mah 30 a, basen 18650 3500mah, 18650 basen, basen bs186m, basen 18650, аккумуляторы basen 18650, basen тесла, basen 18650 vtc6 30 a отзывы, аккумулятор незащищенный 18650 basen 3500 мач 30а, аккумулятор basen 18650 красный, тест basen, basen, акб басен 18650, jhtutyfkmysq аккумулятор basen 18650 3500mah, basen 2019 18650 3500 мач

Questions and answers

What capacity did the BASEN 18650 batteries deliver in the tests?

Both types measured about 3400 mAh, despite the stated 3500 mAh capacity.

What continuous current can the BASEN O35 handle?

The author gives 10 A as its continuous discharge current. It may tolerate 30 A briefly, but with voltage sag and reduced service life.

What discharge current does the protected BASEN BS136A Pro provide?

Its protection limits current to about 6–6.2 A briefly and 5.1 A continuously.


This model is included in the summary table: Battery comparison: measured capacity and resistance

The figures from this review are in the measurement database: Batteries

Calculate manuallyAll calculators

Discounted products


You may be interested in


Discounted products


Support the project

All the content on the site and the advice are free, but we’d be grateful for your support of the project and the channel!

Comments1

Comments are published in their original language.

  1. 14 January 2020 12:22#1
    Хороший честный обзор! А, углеграфитовый штангель так и не приехал?  blush 
    --------------------
    Не шалю, никого не трогаю, починяю примус ....
    0

Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Go to the forum

Only registered readers can comment. It takes a minute to sign up, and you can log in with the same account you use on the forum.

Log inRegister