I'm often asked to recommend a soldering iron that's reasonably priced, yet offers decent quality and temperature control. Recently, I ordered a mini soldering station that might fit the bill. There are already a couple of reviews of this station on the site, so mine is more of a short addendum to the existing ones.
To be honest, I hadn't planned to write about this soldering station at all, but I liked it during testing, so I decided to review it. Besides, people have been asking me for a while to cover something like this. The link in the title is for the proper European version, which came out a little later. I bought the version with a different power plug, supposedly the American one.
The station arrived in a cardboard box. They also included a small promotional leaflet, apparently offering some kind of discount bonuses, but I didn't try it.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
There's a sticker on top with a number that you're apparently supposed to enter on the website to check whether the product is genuine.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
I tried it a couple of times, but got the same result each time. The screenshot shows a translation from Chinese. Anyway, I don't know whether it's genuine or not. I was more interested in how it was put together and how it works.
Everything inside was tossed into a pile like this. Nothing was damaged in transit, though I think the packaging could have been sturdier.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
All right, enough about the packaging. Let's move on to what I actually bought. 1. Power supply with controller. 2. Handle for a T12 tip 3. The T12 tip itself 4. Instructions 5. A small warranty card 6. Soldering iron stand and a small sponge for wiping the tip.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The instructions are a standard A4 sheet, printed on one side. I'll include a Russian version in the supplementary materials; I think it'll be much more useful.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The warranty card is straightforward: a neat little sheet, but here it's almost completely useless. I actually liked the stand. It's small and simple. Too bad you can't bend it back and forth many times; otherwise, it would be great for portable use.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The handle for the T12 tip is quite neatly made. The cable is flexible, its insulation is heat-resistant, and it's about one meter long. Overall, it's a thumbs-up.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The handle is marked Bakon LF005. The connector has a secure screw-locking nut, and the cable is firmly secured too. Another thumbs-up; it'll be hard to pull out.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The kit included a T12-B tip, made in China.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
A sharp conical tip. I usually prefer a different type of tip, but in practice this one turned out to be pretty good too. It tins very well, solder sticks to it nicely, and I had no trouble picking up even a large blob of solder. The tip is also marked Bakon LeadFree, although as far as I know, all T12 tips were originally designed for lead-free solder. At least, when I chose a soldering station about 8 years ago, I bought one with this type of tip, and it was also advertised as LeadFree.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
Drawing of the included tip.
Here is the included tip (left), compared with the tips from this review and the one included with the Aoyue 2738 station (right). You can see that the dimensions match Hakko tips, which is good, since the tip for the Aoyue 2738 station is shorter and harder to find.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
The tip extends about 40 mm. In one of my reviews, I wrote that for more comfortable work, you should aim to reduce this distance. In other words, the shorter the distance from your grip to the soldering point, the better.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
In that same review, I wrote that the Aoyue 2738 soldering iron is the best in this respect. Here, the tip extension is exactly the same, so I can confidently give it 5 points for this criterion. Comparison in the photo: TS100 The soldering iron under review Aoyue 2738 Solomon
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
I’ve inspected the soldering iron—or, more precisely, the tip and handle—and have no complaints. Time to move on to the power supply and controller. This soldering station has the power supply and temperature controller housed in the same enclosure. The only downside was that the soldering iron has a non-European plug. By the way, the plug has an earth pin. If you happen to get a soldering iron with this type of plug, use a suitable adapter that connects the earth contact too, not just the live and neutral.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
It looks very neat. As I mentioned above, I don’t know whether this is an original or a copy, but I have no complaints about the appearance. A dark cover over the display would probably have helped, since it detracts from the look a little, but that’s just nitpicking :)
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
1. There is a three-digit display at the top showing the temperature. Below it are two buttons for selecting the operating mode (preset) or temperature. But why, once again, are the plus and minus buttons the wrong way around? Surely it makes more sense to have plus on the right and minus on the left. It seems like a small thing, but it really is confusing. If the labels weren't molded into the case, I'd swap them around, but as it is, that would only make things even more confusing. :( 2. The front panel has a connector for the soldering iron, a hole for the trimmer potentiometer covered by a rubber plug, and a spot for installing something. I later found out that some stations have a power switch there. I'm not sure which is more convenient, but personally I don't care whether it's on the front or the back. If you want, though, you can buy a switch designed for a round hole and install it. 3. As you may have gathered from the previous point, the power switch is on the back. The power cable is securely held in place by a molded plastic insert. 4. It even has a warranty seal, which tells us the station is very new: it was made in mid-April this year, just over a month ago.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The bottom has both a plus and a minus. The plus is that the manufacturer provided holes for mounting the station on a wall in different orientations, which is very convenient. But they skimped on fitting four rubber feet. The case doesn't slide around on the table only because the soldering iron cable is long and flexible, but it's still a drawback: situations vary, and I wouldn't want to have to catch this little box as it slides off the table.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Since the warranty seal is pointless, let's open it up. Though warranty seals have never stopped me anyway :)
Remove the four screws hidden under the missing feet and open the case.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The power supply board is screwed to the bottom of the case, while the control and temperature-control board is mounted in the top cover.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The power switch is connected via a connector, which is a plus. The downside is that it only breaks one wire. Normally, the power switch on a switching power supply should disconnect both wires. The ground connection, on the other hand, is done properly: no connectors, just soldering. It would have been better to connect it directly to the connector, but this approach is acceptable too.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The first pleasant surprise was a proper input filter, a fuse, and a thermistor to limit the capacitor's inrush current. I was very pleased to see a 100 µF input capacitor; I expected something like 47–68 µF. No complaints at all on this point; everything is excellent.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Now let's take a closer look at the main components installed on the circuit board. 1. The primary-side high-voltage switch is an IRF840. I was surprised to see a transistor rated for just 500 V in this circuit, since 600–650 V parts are more commonly used. Of course, some readers will ask why that's a problem when the input voltage is only a little over 300 V. That's true: it's around 315–320 V. But this is a flyback power supply, and the primary winding has a voltage spike of at least Vout × N (the turns ratio). Judging by the 60:8:8 marking on the transformer, I'll assume that's the turns ratio—which makes sense for this topology. That means the transistor will see around 320 + 20 × (60/8) = 470 V, leaving very little headroom. This is, of course, a very rough calculation, but it gives us a ballpark idea of the situation. I did a quick search online for user reports and didn't find any mention of this transistor failing, but a 500 V transistor in the primary circuit is still not a good choice. 2. No complaints about the output diode: STPS20H100CT, rated at 20 A and 100 V. This diode assembly is used in 24 V power supplies, so no issues here. 3. The PWM controller is an OB2202CP. I'll probably come back to it later, but for now I'll just say I'm skeptical about placing the controller and power transistor far apart. 4. The interwinding noise-suppression capacitor is a standard type, not a Y1 or Y2 safety capacitor. On the one hand, that doesn't matter if the unit is grounded. On the other hand, the manufacturer has skimped on a dirt-cheap capacitor, so I recommend replacing it—especially since it's rated for just 1 kV. A 78M05 regulator is also visible nearby, powering the controller board.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The output capacitors have plenty of capacitance, but their voltage rating is just about adequate. For an output voltage of 19–20 V, 35 V capacitors are recommended, although I think these should work fine too. The thing is, the power supply doesn't have a particularly heavy load, and it's only used intermittently. The soldering iron draws around 15–20 W on average, with a current of about 1 A. At that load, 25 V capacitors should also work fine. You might ask what capacitance and voltage rating have to do with output power. The capacitance is straightforward: 2000 µF in total is more than enough for a maximum current of 2–2.5 A. The voltage rating is a little more subtle. Capacitors heat up when operating at high frequencies. The higher the voltage rating, the larger the capacitor. The larger the capacitor, the greater its case surface area. And the greater the surface area, the better the heat dissipation and the cooler the electrolyte inside stays. Also, a switching power supply produces brief voltage spikes, which don't do the capacitors any favors. Speaking of spikes, here's a nice little touch: there's an output noise-suppression inductor inside.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The circuit board layout is surprisingly good, especially around the output rectifier and filter. The board is also soldered properly and is clean, earning it a solid 4+. I took off half a point because putting the power transistor and PWM controller on opposite sides of the board isn't ideal; it should only be done if the layout is designed with that in mind.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
I reconstructed the power supply schematic from the circuit board. There may be some errors, but I tried to include all component values (the capacitance of some capacitors is approximate) and reference designators.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Controller circuit board. This is the part that actually regulates the temperature and controls the operating modes. While taking it apart and putting it back together, I stripped the threads cut by the self-tapping screws. It felt like they hadn't been screwed in at all, but simply forced into the plastic—a small mark against the manufacturer. It doesn't affect operation, but it can make disassembly and reassembly a bit of a pain. By the way, the photo shows the connection to the power supply board using four wires, marked In, 20V, GND, 5V. In reality, the connection is 20V, GND, GND, 5V.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The controller board. Overall, I'd give it 4 out of 5: there are traces of flux and some rather untidy soldering, although most of it is fine.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
On the back are the solder pads for the connection to the power supply, the soldering iron connection, a trimmer, and the contacts for reprogramming the microcontroller.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
1. It uses one of the most popular microcontrollers, the Atmega8. 2. The thermocouple signal is amplified by a dual LM358 op-amp, but only one channel is used. 3. Power to the soldering iron's heating element is switched by an AOD425. This is an N-channel MOSFET rated for a maximum current of 50 A, with an on-resistance of 17 mΩ—more than enough for this application. It dissipates no more than 0.1 W :) 4. At the end of the teardown, I measured the power supply's output voltage: just over 19 V, although it's rated at 20 V. The tip is actually designed to run on a 24 V supply.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
After I'd already drawn the power supply schematic, one of the readers sent me a link to the schematic for this station. I already had the power supply schematic, so here I'll include the linked schematic for the control board. The power supply schematic for my unit is slightly different. In particular, the resistor values in the PWM controller's voltage divider differ.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
First power-up. If you try to switch it on without the soldering iron connected, the station displays an S-E error, indicating an open circuit in the heater circuit. All right, let's connect the soldering iron. By default, the station starts in mode 3, which corresponds to a temperature of 350 degrees. There are 5 modes, with preset temperatures in degrees Celsius: 1 — 250 2 — 300 3 — 350 4 — 400 5 — 450
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Since I'd switched it on, I immediately tried it out. What can I say? I liked it. Though, to be more precise, it feels like the soldering iron from the Aoyue 2738, just without the fume extractor. It's comfortable to solder with. Overall, 4.5 out of 5. I can already hear the question: why 4.5? Where did the other 0.5 go? I took off half a point because the tip has a little play in the handle. A beginner probably won't notice, and it isn't a big deal for one anyway, but a professional will spot it right away. It doesn't really affect the work, but it does leave a bit of a bad taste.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Besides testing how well it solders, I always do another test: how comfortable is the soldering iron to hold in a relaxed grip? Here, as above, it's better than the iron from the Aoyue 2738, mainly thanks to its thin, flexible cable. 5 out of 5.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Testing how quickly it heats up before calibration, right after I received it and turned it on to take a look. In fact, after calibration it takes only a little longer to heat up.
Of course, I wanted to measure the actual temperature at the tip. In general, when I'm working, I rarely rely on the exact temperature reading. The exception is when I need to follow the temperature profile specified in a datasheet, but that only applies to particularly «delicate» components. For most other parts, it doesn't matter much, at least to me, because over time you start to «feel» the temperature and timing.
Since the result was noticeably off, I tried adjusting the temperature with the trimmer potentiometer. As it turned out, that was a mistake. The manual explains how to calibrate it, and this station is calibrated in software, but who reads the manual BEFORE experimenting? :) I adjusted the temperature at the midpoint, 350 degrees: before adjustment on the left, after on the right.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
After I ended up with something incomprehensible, I finally checked the manual to see how it should be done.
In brief, calibration works like this: 1. Measure the actual temperature. 2. Write down or remember the reading (I simply kept the thermocouple pressed against the tip). 3. Press both buttons on the station at the same time and wait a couple of seconds for the first digit on the display to start flashing. 4. Use the buttons to enter the measured value (the left button changes the value, the right button selects the digit to change). 5. Press the right button once more, and the controller will save the setting. 6. If you're not happy with the result, repeat the process.
So, let's give it a try. First, I returned the trimmer potentiometer to roughly its original position (fortunately, I still had photos of the measurement results). 1. Measured value. 2. Press both buttons at once in the appropriate mode. In the photo, the first digit is off; in reality, it's just flashing. 3. Enter the measured value of 307 degrees, then release the buttons. 4. The temperature «jumped» upward, but the difference between the actual and set temperatures became smaller.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
1–4. I repeated the process several more times. The result didn't improve any further, but it seems perfectly acceptable to me.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Now let's run through the entire range once more. Before software calibration on the left, after on the right.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
You can see that the result is better than when adjusting it by turning the trimmer potentiometer. But the nonlinearity is still quite noticeable. I'll try again, but I suspect the trimmer potentiometer is actually what controls the calibration linearity.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
While testing it, I kept thinking how inconvenient it is to use these fixed presets—especially since in practice you need three settings: 300–350 and 400, because 250 and 450 are already extreme. But I found information in the manual about selecting any temperature you want. You do this by holding down any button; the station then switches to temperature adjustment mode in 1-degree increments. According to the manual (the Russian-language version), when you release the buttons, the station should save that value and use it from then on. But I couldn't get it to work: the station stubbornly “forgot” the value and, when switching between presets, kept setting the same 250, 300, and so on…
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
In use, the whole setup looks roughly like this:
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
By the way, the power supply doesn't get very hot. I used the soldering iron for about an hour, periodically desoldering one of my boards that I keep for parts, then measured the temperature with a thermal camera. The board in the photo isn't the one I took apart; it's a board sent to me by one of my readers so I could trace the power supply circuit. You can also clearly see in the photo that the hottest component in the power supply is the transformer.
As a “heavy-duty” test, I tried desoldering a capacitor from a motherboard. Let's just say I got it out, although I wouldn't say it was easy. But I tried it with the temperature set to 350 degrees, and the included tip isn't very well suited to this kind of work. If you raise the temperature and replace the tip with a larger one, this kind of work becomes a little easier.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Still, I decided to improve the station's performance. The way to do that is to increase the power supply voltage.
First, let's figure out how much power the station actually delivers. I measured the resistance of the soldering iron together with its cable, since that's how it will be used, and I'm modifying the power supply specifically for this setup. I got 8.73 Ω. Knowing that the power supply output is about 19.36 V, we get a current of 2.22 A. The total power in this (cold “startup”) state is 42.9 W.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The heater accounts for (8.43/8.73) × 42.9 = 41.4 W. In my opinion, that's still not enough power for “heavy-duty” work. While I was at it, I checked the resistance of the tip's grounding path: 0.24 Ω, which is perfectly fine.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
There are many ways to modify it; here are a few: 1. Simply change the resistor values in the feedback divider and the IC protection divider. There is a risk of the high-voltage transistor failing, since the voltage across it will increase, and it already has very little headroom. 2. The same thing, but replace the transistor as well. This is a reasonable option, but the power supply will operate less than optimally because the output voltage is increased by more than 20%. 3. Add a few turns to the transformer's secondary winding and change the feedback divider values. In my opinion, this is the best option. You may not even need to replace the high-voltage transistor, since its voltage stress will remain almost the same. The downside is that the modification is more complicated.
There were even some completely crazy ideas. 1. Just replace the power supply. That didn't work: the dimensions of the “generic” power supply are clearly larger than the original's. 2. Rework the high-voltage section, removing the PWM controller and all its associated components along with the high-voltage transistor, and replacing them with a TOP248 or an equivalent. Complicated and expensive. 3. Remove the transformer too, and build the power supply around an IR2151-2153. Since a soldering iron doesn't really need a regulated voltage, this is a good solution, especially in terms of heat. But winding a transformer and building almost everything from scratch? No, that's too long and complicated.
Anyway, I thought it over and decided to add turns to the transformer's secondary winding and change the feedback divider. But first, I needed to figure out what the original power supply could deliver.
The photo below compares it with a 24 V, 100–120 W power supply. Our transformer is clearly smaller.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Since the PWM frequency is the same as that of the TOP2xx ICs I use, I tried simulating a similar transformer to see roughly how much power one of this size could handle at the same frequency. My estimate was that this transformer can deliver about 62–63 W continuously in a closed enclosure.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
In principle, I could have left the high-voltage transistor as it was for my modification, since I planned to add turns to the winding. But for better reliability, I decided to replace the transistor too. The output capacitors also have to be replaced as part of this modification.
The originals are 1000 µF and rated for 25 V. That's already cutting it close with a 19 V output, and 23–24 V is out of the question. It's best to use low-impedance capacitors, since the switching frequency is 133 kHz. I found a LowESR Capxon LZ 1000 µF, 35 V capacitor at home, but it was too long, as well as a 470 µF, 35 V KF-series capacitor. The KF-series capacitors would have been a better fit. They seem more reliable to me, but a 1000 µF, 35 V capacitor from this series would be too large in diameter, so I decided on a small “hybrid”: a 1000 µF, 35 V capacitor before the filter and a 470 µF, 35 V one after it. I'll show later why I did it this way.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
For the modification, I chose an SPP20N60C3 transistor. This transistor is used in a 25 V, 4–5 A power supply that I reviewed some time ago. The transistor cost just under two dollars offline.
For comparison, here are the key figures from the datasheets. You can see that the replacement is much better than the original; the only thing the new one loses on is gate capacitance, which is twice as high. The higher gate capacitance increases switching losses and heat: the higher the capacitance, the more slowly the transistor turns on and off. But I figured 133 kHz wasn't high enough for this to be a major concern, and I could always see how it performs in real-world conditions.
First, I desolder the output capacitors and the high-voltage transistor. Perfectionists can straighten the heatsinks while they're at it. In my case, the output diode's heatsink was tilted toward the transformer, so I bent it back a little. Of course, I didn't just bend it—I heated the diode leads first, then bent it :)
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
I decided to add a few turns for a reason. There’s plenty of room on the transformer for an extra winding, so it would be a shame not to use it.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
To add the winding correctly, you need to understand how the existing one is wound. I didn’t want to unwind the transformer, and couldn’t be bothered to even desolder it, so I simply took a close look at the direction the wires run from the terminals. Transformers are often wound with the turns crossing over each other like this, but you still need to be careful: it’s easy to accidentally connect the winding out of phase and spend ages wondering why nothing works.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Next, cut the trace leading to the output diode as shown in the photo, and drill a couple of holes. The holes should be about 1.8–2 mm in diameter. Clean the solder mask off the contact pad on the right and tin it.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Take two pieces of copper wire (insulated, of course), about 0.5–0.7 mm in diameter and twice the length of the board. It’s better to use two wires rather than one thicker wire, since this reduces voltage spikes and puts less stress on the snubber, improving reliability.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Strip and tin one end of each wire, insert them into the hole to the left of the transformer terminal (above it in the photo), and solder them to the transformer terminal. Then wind two turns using both wires. Try not to bunch the turns together, but don’t wind them too close to the edges either: turns from other windings protrude there, which could be unsafe. The goal is to get the turns laid out evenly, at least as neatly as in the photo.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Experiment to determine how much wire you need to solder it into the board, trim off the excess, strip and tin the end, slide on a piece of insulating sleeve or heat-shrink tubing, and insert it into the hole on the right.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Solder it as shown in the photo: solder the contact on the left first, then wind the wire, and finally solder the one on the right.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
If you feel like it, you can put the original insulating tape back in place. I couldn’t be bothered to desolder the input capacitor, so I did everything with it still in place. But it’s easier to desolder it first, then wind the coil and put the tape back on.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Don't be alarmed, this isn't the output voltage :) The photo shows the voltage across the PWM controller's supply capacitor. I'll explain why I measured it. Since the output voltage is regulated, we can add or remove turns without changing the output voltage (unless, of course, we push the power supply completely out of regulation). To check whether we did everything right or connected the winding backwards, we can use the IC's supply voltage as a guide. If everything is correct, the voltage should drop by 3–4 V. If the winding is connected backwards, it should rise by the same amount. Warning: this voltage is measured on the “hot” side of the power supply, which is directly connected to the mains. Be extremely careful! Also, I recommend doing the first tests with the power supply connected through a light bulb, for example a 15 W bulb. It should flash briefly, then either go out completely or glow very dimly.
I made a mistake and didn't measure the voltage before the modification. But since I knew the PWM controller's supply voltage was above 11 V, and mine measured 12 V, I couldn't have raised it: if I had, the voltage before the modification would have been outside the normal range. Still, it's better to measure it before making any changes.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 iron
Next, we need to change the feedback divider's resistance slightly to raise the voltage. There are several ways to do this, too. 1. Solder a 20 kΩ resistor in parallel with the 4.42 kΩ lower resistor. I calculated this value for an output of 23 V (I arrived at 23 V based on a maximum power of 62 W). 2. Replace the divider's lower resistor with a 3.6 kΩ one. 3. Replace the divider's upper resistor with a 36 kΩ one. 4. More complex options, which I won't cover.
The values in options 2 and 3 won't give exactly 23 V, but they'll get you closest. I chose these values because they're from the common E24 series, rather than the less common, more precise series.
For a 24 V modification, however, you can't always stick to the E24 series, so the values are as follows (in the same order as above): 1. 16 kΩ. 2. 3.45 kΩ 3. 38 kΩ (you can use 39 kΩ, but the voltage will be higher than 24 V)
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 iron
We soldered another resistor on top of one of them. Let's see how it turned out. We got the calculated 23 V, actually a little more, but that's fine. The voltage on the PWM controller's supply capacitor also went up. By the way, this made me suspect that the secondary windings may have had different numbers of turns to begin with, since in that case the PWM controller's supply voltage would have returned to 19 V. But I can't say for sure, because I didn't check it before the modification.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 iron
After that, I planned to put the board in the case and run it for an hour or two. I also wanted to use this photo to show why I chose these output capacitors. The capacitor on the right needs to be shorter than the one on the left; otherwise, it will hit the case standoff. Of course, I could bend it sideways, but that wouldn't look very neat. Since the right-hand capacitor is after the inductor, reducing its capacitance to 470 µF will have almost no effect on operation in this case. In other words, 1000 µF before the inductor and 470 µF after it is perfectly acceptable. I wouldn't do it the other way around, though: the capacitor has a harder job before the inductor, and the lower capacitance would make things worse.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 iron
But unfortunately, the test didn't go as planned. The soldering iron powered up quite briskly, but when it reached 350, the station rebooted. The power supply's overload protection kicked in briefly, since we'd increased the power. It was clear that the power supply was operating right at its current limit: everything seemed fine, but it was just a little short. I decided to raise the protection trip current slightly, especially since I'd installed a more powerful transistor. But because the trip current was already almost equal to the actual current, I didn't want to increase it by much.
A 0.27 Ω resistor is connected in series with the high-voltage transistor. I had two options: replace it with a lower-value resistor or add another one in parallel. A 2.4 Ω resistor happened to be at hand (although I'd originally planned to use a 2.7 Ω one). Connecting it in parallel would reduce the resistance (and increase the current) by about 12%, which was more than enough for me. For this approach, you can use 2–3 Ω resistors. If replacing the resistor, use a value of 0.22–0.24 Ω.
I covered the resistor with heat-shrink tubing and soldered it in place on the trace side.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
Now it starts up normally, with no more reboots. Let's put the cover back on and move on to the tests.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
I left the station on at 400 degrees for a while, then lowered the temperature to 350 and soldered a board. But since the station had worked perfectly with ordinary boards even before the modification, I finished up by trying the more “demanding” test again. When I tried to desolder the same capacitor as last time, the improvement was obvious: the power had increased by almost 1.5 times. But I still had trouble desoldering small capacitors, mainly because their bodies were heating up. Things should improve if you raise the temperature to 380–400 degrees and use a more suitable tip than a sharp conical one.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
The temperature profile, however, remained unchanged. How can that be, some readers will surely ask: it was 40 W, now it's 60 W, and the power supply is still just as hot? Here's how. The higher voltage (and therefore higher power) affects how quickly the soldering iron heats up and how well it recovers. During normal use, its average power consumption may even go down. Imagine this: a 50 W soldering iron is heating a huuuge copper pour for about 5 minutes. With a 100 W iron, you might heat it in 1.5 minutes, not 2.5. That's a saving. With a 25 W iron, you might not be able to heat it at all, and you'd be there forever.
Of course, if you continuously draw heat from 50 W and 100 W soldering irons, the 100 W iron will dissipate exactly twice as much. But that calculation doesn't apply to normal use.
While I was at it, I checked the temperature inside with the cover off. The transformer was around 60, so there's room to increase the power further. The high-voltage transistor's heatsink was around 40–45. The diode's heatsink was around 60, about the same as the transformer. All those temperatures leave plenty of headroom, but the 5 V regulator heated up to nearly 100, which isn't good.
Bakon BK950D, a compact soldering station with a T12 soldering iron
For the 5 V regulator, I made this improvised “heatsink” from a tinned piece of 2.5 mm² wire. Some people might find it funny, but this tiny heatsink is enough to bring the temperature down by 15–20 degrees, and I don't need any more than that. Besides, it's always close at hand :) If you're feeling fancy, you can use a tab from a high-power diode. Since I was already tinkering with it, I also replaced the interwinding noise-suppression capacitor, just to be safe. People often ask me what these look like in a shop and how to search for them. The capacitance usually isn't critical; 100–2200 pF is enough, with 1000 pF being ideal. The voltage rating is determined by the capacitor class, so any of them will work. They look like this, or like this. I used a capacitor from the circuit board of some monitor power supply.
Almost forgot. If you want to make it even safer, don't screw a self-tapping screw in near the 5 V regulator. The manufacturer laid out the circuit board correctly, with protective air gaps and proper routing. But they overlooked one thing: if you screw in that self-tapping screw, the total distance between the components on the “hot” side and the regulator's flange will be very small. And if a breakdown does occur, it'll happen right there. Of course, this is a rather hypothetical situation, but it's theoretically possible.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
On the right is what I ended up with, and on the left is what's left over. Don't throw away the leftover components; they may well come in handy :)
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
And here's the schematic, updated to reflect the changes made. Replaced components are shown in red, and added ones in blue.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
Clean up the residue with a cotton pad and acetone. I thought about coating the circuit board with varnish, but then changed my mind.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
Solder the power and ground wires back on, then put everything back together. By the way, reassembly isn't very convenient—the power button keeps trying to pop out.
Bakon BK950D, compact soldering station with T12 soldering iron
What can I say in conclusion? First, let me list the pros and cons. Pros Good build quality Comfortable soldering iron Compact size (though smaller ones are available) Ready to use straight out of the box Soldering iron stand included, but it's very basic
Cons 40 W of power. The high-voltage transistor has almost no headroom (though I couldn't find any reports of failures) The tip has a little play in the handle. Doesn't save intermediate temperature settings
My opinion. Although the station has some drawbacks, as listed in the review, I liked it. It works reliably, has a convenient design, and is pleasant to use. You can use it as-is, but it won't work for multilayer boards because it doesn't have enough power. With a small modification, it can solder even “heavy” boards. Before the modification, the station delivered about 40–42 W. A simple change—raising the voltage to 20–21 V by changing the voltage divider—can boost the power a little. But for proper operation, I'd recommend modifying it as described in the review. After the modification, I got a reliable 60–62 W. Judging by the temperature behavior, though, I think the voltage could safely be raised further to reach the rated 70–75 W. I was pleased with the well-laid-out circuit board, neat enclosure, comfortable soldering iron with a flexible cable, and reliable power connector. Overall, it's a worthy alternative for anyone who doesn't want to build a station from scratch but wants a decent result, even if it does take a little work. What disappointed me was the odd choice of high-voltage transistor, the reduced power (due to the low voltage), the lack of memory for intermediate temperature settings, and some difficulty with calibration.
Whether it's right for you is up to you. I've tried to describe it as best I can, and as always, I look forward to your questions and additions in the comments. I'll keep the station for now and can test something if needed. Later, it'll go to a friend, who is actually the one I ordered it for. As an addendum, here's the Russian-language manual. The only difference is the precise temperature setting mode — download.
Comments are published in their original language.
Discuss on the forumHave a question or some experience to share? Discuss the article with the author and readers: the forum is a convenient place to share schematics and photos.
Comments are published in their original language.